|
29th February 1936, Page: 258, Column: 1 Safety In Coal MinesSome Points in EvidenceSir Alfred Faulkner, Permanent Under-Secretary for Mines, gave evidence at the first public sittings of the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines. The Commission is to inquire whether the safety and health of mine workers can he better ensured by extending or modifying the principles or general provisions of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, or the arrangements for its administration, having regard to the changes that have taken place in organisation, methods of work, and equipment since it became law, and the experience gained. Disappointment was felt that after the large amount of money that has been spent on research into the prevention of accidents there seemed to have been no real improvement over a long period. It rather seemed that the improvement which research had actually brought about had been counteracted by other causes. Referring to the difficult conditions under which coal mining is carried on, Sir Alfred emphasised the point that there has been a complete revolution in methods of mining without any notable decrease in the number of accidents. The Mines Inspectorate. The matters put forward for consideration in relation to the strength and organisation of the inspectorate included these points: Whether the inspectorate should be organised in small divisions or districts, particularly if the appointment of more inspectors were recommended; whether, if smaller districts were recommended they should be grouped together and linked with headquarters by responsible superintending inspectors, or whether headquarters' staff should be strengthened to deal with district inspectors direct; the position of sub-inspectors in any scheme of reorganisation that might be recommended. A point Sir Alfred sought to make was that inspectors must not be responsible for matters of detail in the working of the mines and should not be called upon to go farther than to give their opinions to the management. He said that if the inspectors were given more authority it would almost amount to them saying how the mine should be laid out and worked. In this way the manager would not be deciding anything, and all his responsibility would be removed. The point which the Department submitted to the Commission for consideration was how far inspection could be increased without the responsibility of the manager being subordinated to that of the inspector. The view of the Department is that the standard of competency of mines inspectors is very much higher than it was twenty years ago. Sir Alfred further said there was no suggestion whatever that mine managers are not sufficiently well trained. With regard to the statutory duties of deputies, apparently they were only to examine, supervise, and report, but he suggested that the Act and practice are at variance in this matter. The Act made the deputy responsible only for supervision, whereas in practice he was responsible for seeing that things were done. It was a difficulty to separate responsibility for safety and responsibility for output. Workmen's Inspections. Upon the question of inspections on behalf of the workmen, it was stated that for many years the rights have been widely exercised in the northern coalfield and in South Wales, but in other coalfields they are exercised to a limited degree, and usually at particular mines or groups of mines. It is the opinion of the Mines Department that safety can be promoted by the workmen and their representatives taking an active part in matters of safety through the medium of these inspections, and the Department suggests as an important matter for the consideration of the Commission the question of how such inspections can be made general and still more effective. In reply to questions Sir Alfred said he did not know of any cases in which inspections on behalf of the men had shown working supports to have been interfered with and that the men who made the inspection had been approached afterwards by the officials of the mine and asked not to report what they had found. Judge Allsebrook said that under grouping schemes there was probably a managing director, a general manager, an agent and a manager, and with such a state of affairs it would be rather a farce to say that the manager had the control or the management of the mine. He suggested that it might be that the Commission would have to reconsider the whole question of responsibility and where it ought to be placed. Sir Alfred Faulkner agreed, and in further answer to a question by Sir Malcolm Delevingne as to how this difficulty was to be got over, he suggested that information might be sought on the point from some of the big groups of mines. In some cases the manager was actually being by-passed, and that was a matter which had to be looked out for. Intensive Mining and Accidents. In his second day's evidence Sir Alfred Faulkner dealt with changes in methods of work and equipment, and said the most important of these to be considered were those brought about by intensive or machine mining. As regards the whole body of accidents, he said that throughout a time of large development in machine mining, the general fatal-accident rate had shown no change of corresponding magnitude, either for better or worse. Broadly speaking, the main conditions necessary for safety in intensive mining, though they might differ importantly in degree, were the same in kind as for older methods of work. Tables put in showed that in 1934 seventeen men were killed and 2,934 injured underground due to the use of machinery, whilst 14 were killed and 50 injured through the use of electricity. On the surface 18 were killed and 649 injured through the use of machinery, and two killed and 11 injured through the use of electricity. Sir Alfred's evidence went to show that falls of roof and side were by far the most prolific causes of accidents at mines. Between 70 and 80 per cent. of them occurred at the working face. The general system of precaution had been in operation for over thirty years. It had not yielded the benefits that were expected, and this might be due, to some extent, to the changing methods of working. Mr. W. T. Miller, a member of the Commission, referred to the use of pneumatic and of electric drills, and suggested that they created more dust than hand drills. Sir Alfred replied that the question was rather too general for him to answer, and there were various methods in use for dealing with dust. He did not think it followed necessarily that the danger would be greater. Another question raised by Mr. Miller was that the noise caused by the use of coal-cutters constituted a danger, in that the men using them were not able to hear roof movements which might result later in a fall. Sir Alfred said that the Secretary for Mines, in two recent speeches, had asked the manufacturers to take steps to deal with it. There were many aspects of it to be taken into account. Difficulties Due to Legislation. Difficulties due to existing legislation were referred to by Sir Alfred in his evidence on the subject of ventilation, hinging upon Sections 29-31 of the Act, upon which Section 67 had an important bearing. The Mines Department suggested as a question for consideration by the Commission whether and in what circumstances systematic tests (by analysis or preferably other more rapid method of estimation) of the firedamp content of the ventilating current — with a record of results — would serve as an effective check on the adequacy of ventilation at and near the working faces, more especially perhaps as a means of determining whether or not conditions were sufficiently safe to permit the use of electric machinery or shot-firing. Statutory responsibility in the matter rested mainly on the deputies and shot-firers and the person in charge of electrical apparatus at present. The systematic sampling and analysis of dust from mine roadways were already required as a check on the precautions against coal dust explosions, and that requirement had proved workable and on the whole effective. Mr. E. O. Forster Brown said that he had read through the three sections of the Mines Act to which reference had been made, and they were difficult to understand ; the matter was complicated by the fact that there were different percentages for safe conditions and withdrawals, and safety-lamps. He gathered the suggestion was that better facilities should be given the Mines Department for fixing standards. Sir Alfred Faulkner agreed, and said the main difficulty was that Section 30 stated the requirements for the measurement of air in the return airway, but that was not really a satisfactory means of deciding the amount of firedamp at the face. Sir Henry Walker said he gathered the difficulty had been that the standard laid down as the percentage of inflammable gas in the general body of air which necessitated the withdrawal of workmen had become the standard of ventilation. Sir Alfred Faulkner agreed, and said that when a standard of withdrawal was set, it was difficult to enforce the argument that some other standard of ventilation was required. He further said that the measurement of the quantity of air passing to the face did not necessarily show that the ventilation at the face was adequate. He agreed that the Department sought some definition of what was adequate, and the means of ascertaining that it was adequate. In reply to a question by the Chairman, Sir Alfred agreed that laying down principles as to standard of equipment of roads was a matter to which attention should be drawn. The Department felt that the Act rather devoted itself to seeing what happened after an accident occurred rather than preventing an accident occurring, and it was suggested that the Commission might devote more attention to the steps which should be taken to prevent accidents happening. A matter which required attention by the Commission was the number of haulage accidents which would be reduced If regulations were made prohibiting anyone travelling over haulage ways except those actually on business there. Reference was also made to the absence of regulations, except in general terms, that there should be adequate lighting at important road junctions. Sir Arthur dealt with the human element in relation to accidents and to the failure of pit committees. The human element undoubtedly lay at the root of a big proportion of accidents, and summarising evidence on this question the Chairman said that workmen in mines were not less alert or less responsive than other people, but there was an element of human frailty in everybody which might lead to serious accident and must not be ignored. Occupational diseases were also discussed. The Royal commission went into session again on Monday, 24th February, and Tuesday, 25th February, when Mr. J. R. Felton, O.B.E., H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines in charge of the North Midland Division, and Mr. H. J. Humphrys, D.S.O., M.C., H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines in charge of the Yorkshire Division, were in attendance for the purpose of giving evidence.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||