15th February 1936, Page: 251, Column: 1
Coal For Mechanical Stokers
From a study of the relationship between ash and boiler
efficiency, said Mr. H. L. Pirie, M.I.Mech.E., in his paper on
"Coal for Mechanical Stokers" before the Institution of Mining
Engineers on the 30th January, it would appear that the lower
the ash, the higher the efficiency to be expected. This conclusion
can he applied to coals which are hand-fired without serious
error, but it must he noted that some varieties of coal, irrespective
of ash-content, are entirely unsuitable for burning on certain
standard types of mechanical stoker.
Characteristics of Coals.
Dealing with the characteristics of coals, he remarked that in
effecting a "marriage" between a coal and the appliance on which
it is to be burned it becomes necessary to study the characteristics
of the former, and it is convenient to classify coals according to
their behaviour under the influence of heat.
Coking Coals. — Coking coals may be defined as those which coke
and swell appreciably. Such coals, where the tars fuse at a
temperature below that at which they are driven off as gas and
percolate the fuel-bed so that it coheres strongly, require that the
coke as it is formed be broken to enable air to pass through, as
they readily burn only when the exposed surface is increased by
fracture. Coals of this nature are, it is submitted, best burned
in conjunction with stokers in which provision is made for the
agitation of the fuel-bed.
Caking Coals. — These coals cake but do not swell (or if they do,
the swelling takes the form of a frothy weak spongy mass), and
are probably the most satisfactory for the vast majority of
mechanical stokers. A coking coal is necessarily a caking coal,
but the reverse is not the case. When "slacks" are used, it is
advisable that they should be of a slightly caking nature, otherwise
there will generally be undue ash pit loss. Certain slacks
have a low caking index, are free-burning, and are therefore not
considered suitable for stokers where bars moving relative to
the fuel-bed are used, as they riddle excessively and interfere
with the maintenance of the requisite fuel-bed thickness.
Free-burning Coals. — Free-burning coals are those which neither
coke nor cake but retain their shape throughout the burning
period.
With regard to coal cleaning Mr. Pirie explained that whether
dry or wet cleaning should be practised must be decided by each
individual colliery, regard being paid primarily to the nature of
the coal seam — whether it is dirty or contains a low percentage
of adventitious ash. If the former, doubtless washing will be
resorted to, but other factors must he taken into consideration,
such as the gravity of the "middlings" and the extent of intergrowth.
Grouping Mechanical Stokers.
Discussing mechanical stokers he said these may be grouped
under the following heads (a) Stokers for water-tube boilers which
naturally fall into two main classes: (i) Progressive, in which the
grate surface is movable and travels at the same speed as the
coal which lies undisturbed thereon, e.g., the chain-grate type;
(ii) Non-progressive, in which the grate is usually fixed and the
coal travels over its surface by gravity or otherwise, e.g., the
retort type,
(b) For use with narrow flue internally-fired boilers such as the
Lancashire: (i) Coking, which imitates the coking method of
hand-firing; (ii) Sprinkler, which imitates the sprinkling method
of hand-firing; (iii) Underfeed, the principle of which is obvious
from its name; (iv) The ram type.
(c) For use with central-heating boilers: (i) Underfeed type
(ii) Gas-producer type; (iii) Overfeed type; (iv) Progressive
type.
Suitable Coals for Stokers.
The relative suitability of coals for stokers of any type is largely
dependent on the rate of combustion (lb. per square foot per hour)
which is to be employed. The upper limit of the rate of combustion
with any stoker and with any fuel is reached when the
air velocity through the fuel bed becomes such that an excessive
quantity of grit is entrained by the flue gases. Some coals,
particularly those of the coking and caking type, will withstand
higher air velocities than others. It follows that there are fewer
coals which can be burned at high fuel-burning rates than at low
fuel-burning rates. Accordingly, a good deal of conflicting
information in existence to-day about the relative suitability of
coals for specific stokers arises from the fact that the variable of
combustion rate per square foot is generally omitted from consideration.
Summarising, it may be said that suitable coals for the types
of stoker enumerated are: (a) (i) Caking or free-burning types.
When the coal fluxes its ash at furnace temperatures, this type
of stoker gives good results. Peas or smalls are the sizes usually
specified. (a) (ii) Coking, caking or free-burning type. The
caking or coking types being more particularly suited for installations
having higher rates of combustion.
Modern stokers of progressive and non-progressive types will
burn slacks or sized coals from nuts to 1/8 in. smalls. Generally,
it is not economic to burn small slacks remote from their source
of origin, but as it is possible to get reasonably good results from
many so-called "low-grade" coals Mr. Pirie does not see why
they should be sold so much below their cost of production, which
is often the case.
The inference is not to be drawn that all makes of stoker in the
respective classes will necessarily burn the coals recommended,
but at least one make from each class is capable of so doing. As
well as giving trade names, the Author quoted actual sizes. This
precaution is necessary because the variation in the sizes of coals
marketed under the same nomenclature is considerable, as will
be seen from an inspection of the Table :—
Powdered Fuel Firing.
After discussing blending, evaluation of coals, coal purchase
and combustion of anthracite duff Mr. Pirie remarked that no
paper on coal for mechanical stokers would be complete unless
some reference were made to powdered-fuel firing. In his view,
whether for Lancashire or water-tube boilers, this method of
firing should be considered at least by all collieries which clean
their coals. The de-dusting or extraction of fines, provided the
coal is initially sufficiently dry, facilitates washing or cleaning,
and the aspirated dust can be submitted to grinding, which will
render it serviceable for boiler work. This dust is high in ash,
but the emission of fly ash at collieries, which are not as a rule
situated in a residential neighbourhood, need not receive too close
scrutiny.
He would hesitate to recommend the use of powdered fuel for
larger boiler plants situated in the midst of dense centres of
population. Grit and ash emission can, of course, be overcome
by the installation of washers or precipitators, but these cost money
and it is a moot point whether they will pay an adequate return
on the capital expended. He considers it essential that very low
ash coal should be purchased if it is to be used in any quantity in
a residential neighbourhood.
Many collieries have adopted powdered-fuel firing both for
water-tube and Lancashire boilers, while anthracite duff has been
decided upon for Swansea's Tir John North Power-station.
Anthracite was obviously the fuel to use at that station, and
as it was found that powdered fuel would be more suitable than
mechanical stokers in that instance, the plant was designed to
suit the fuel most readily available.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Pirie, H. L. | | | |