|
21st December 1935, Page: 186, Column: 1 Electric Versus Oil Flame LampsFrom debate on "Miners' Electric Lamps versus Miners' Oil Flame Lamps" at the meeting on 30th November of the Associates and Students' section of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers. Mr. Bell stated the case for the oil lamp, his seconder being Mr. Thomas Hall, Assoc.IM.E. Mr. Nicholson stated the case for the electric lamp, his seconder being Mr. W. S. Hutton. Case for the Oil Flame Lamp. By Geoffrey W. Bell, B.Sc., Stud.I.M.E. The prime purpose of a safety-lamp, whether it be an electric or an oil flame lamp, is to supply illumination without initiating an explosion in an atmosphere containing firedamp. Whilst the first so-called safety-lamps neither gave very much light nor remained safe under all conditions, they were a great advance on Spedding's flint mill and the phosphorescent fish skins. Similarly the modern horizontal candle-power flame safety-lamp is a great advance on the Stephenson and Davy lamps. It is generally agreed that poor lighting is favourable to the contraction of nystagmus, the disease which costs the mining industry upwards of half-a-million pounds a year. Lighting is not the only factor to be considered in this connection, as some men are more susceptible than others, and the disease is not rigidly confined to coal miners. Since the old standard of lighting was condacive to nystagmus investigations were carried out to determine what intensity of illumination was required to reduce, and if possible eliminate, the number of new cases. During the course of his evidence before the "Miners' Nystagmus Committee," Dr. T. Lister Llewellyn stated that a 3 c.p. lamp would have the result of preventing the occurrence of nystagmus. Both flame and electric lamps are obtainable which are amply capable of this candle-power, and results of tests carried out at Nunnery Colliery and Tinsley Park Colliery support Dr. Llewellyn's conclusions; indeed Dr. Wellwood Ferguson said with regard to the Nunnery and Tinsley Park experiments that the importance of using lamps of from 2-2.5 c.p. as compared with lamps of 0.5 to 1 c.p. normally used could not be overestimated. The lamps used at Nunnery Colliery were "Davis Kirkby" lamps, which gave a maximum horizontal candle-power at the end of nine hours burning of approximately 4 c.p. From the official polar diagram of the Hailwood A.D.C.4 lamp it is soon to have a maximum horizontal candle-power of 3.8 after nine hours burning and a minimum of 2.25 candle-power over a horizontal angle of 190°. These figures are results after nine hours burning, and from observations published by Prof. W. H. McMillan the average fall in mean H.C.P. of several types of oil flame lamps after nine hours burning was only 3.8 per cent. ; in one case it was only 2.56 per cent. Therefore, the oil flame lamp provides an almost constant suitable light throughout a shift. The electric lamp, on the other hand, if it is to be easily handled, can only provide a waning light as the terminal voltage of the accumulator falls. In the case of the 4-volt lead acid lamp the drop in c.p. after nine hours burning reaches the alarming figure of 26 per cent., and 23 per cent. in the 2.6 volt alkaline lamp. It is admitted that after nine hours burning some electric lamps may have a mean horizontal candle-power approaching 3, and their initial maximum candle-powers appear very attractive, but these facts must not be allowed to camouflage the psychological effect on a man working in a waning light during a period which coincides with increasing physical fatigue. These conditions will undoubtedly impose additional strain on the nervous system. In addition to the intensity of the light its quality must also be considered. Whilst one man is working in comparative comfort his fellow is caused considerable annoyance, and may be temporarily blinded, by the glare of the first's electric lamp. The majority of firemen, examiners and deputies, together with a competent proportion of face workers, are required to make tests for firedamp. in order to do this they must be provided with approved gas detectors. The ideal instrument would automatically indicate the presence of gas in an obvious manner, and also register the percentage without further adjustment or manipulation. As the electric lamp can give no indication of the state of the atmosphere, a separate instrument must be employed. Various forms of gas-detecting instruments have been produced, but they suffer from various deficiencies. Those which indicate automatically the presence of gas operate at a pre-determined figure and other percentages cannot he estimated; those which can be used to determine the percentage of gas present do not indicate automatically the presence of gas-a test must be made. Prof. W. M. Thornton, during a discussion on his paper "A Miners' Gas Measuring Electric Lamp," said in referring to his lamp, which incorporated a compact and accurate gas measuring device, "like every other form of detector it was necessary to make the test for gas," and he continued "the flame lamp was the only type which gave automatic warning, and then it must always be burning." A miner is dependant on his lamp, and he will notice almost immediately any variation in the flame of an oil lamp which will indicate the presence of firedamp by spiring and of stythe by becoming small and dim. No other form of detector will indicate the presence of both firedamp and stythe without manipulation. Moreover, forms of detectors other than the oil flame lamp can be hung up in a convenient place, and forgotten or neglected for considerable periods during which any conceivable amount of firedamp may be liberated in the working place. With an oil flame lamp, using suitable fuel, the percentage of firedamp in the air can he estimated from 1 per cent. Pamphlet No. 4B, issued by the Mines Department, contains the following paragraph : "The flame safety-lamp affords the readiest and simplest means of detecting firedamp in the air and of estimating the percentage that is present . . . The electric safety-lamp, on the contrary, gives no indication or warning of the presence of firedamp ot any other dangerous gas." Thus the flame safety-lamp forms the only fully automatic gas indicator which can be used with a minimum of manipulation for the estimation of percentages. With regard to the relative costs incurred by flame and electric lamps, it is difficult to obtain figures of real value unless a colliery changes over completely from one type to another within a short space of time. The costs of the two installations must be compared over a period of normal working and, unless the lamps are maintained by the makers and hired to the colliery company, a long period must elapse before the cost of replacements can be estimated with any degree of certainty. Actual costs at different collieries cannot be taken as comparative, as the cost of the lamp installation per ton of output will depend upon the output per underground worker, and the treatment and conditions to which the lamps are subjected. These factors will vary with the conditions, which are seldom identical even at adjoining collieries. In any specific case, however, there are three main advantages which an oil flame lamp installation would enjoy over an electric lamp installation, whether the latter are of the lead/acid or of the alkali type. Firstly, the capital expenditure is less, the flame lamp being about half the price of an alkali lamp of similar candle-power, the lead/acid lamp being between the two in price. Secondly, maintenance charges are lower; the lead/acid cells require re-plating in from six to twelve months ; the alkali cell is more fortunate and, with care, will last nearly ten years. Both types require new bulbs for every 600-1,000 burning hours, depending on the degree of efficiency which is aimed at; the bulb should be changed at least four times a year. The oil flame lamp will require a few asbestos washers and occasionally a new wick. Thirdly, the cost of installing and maintaining approved gas detectors in addition to the lamps is eliminated completely. Whilst the modern electric safety-lamp does not require the stripping and cleaning that an oil lamp dues, it demands an electrician's expert attention. More than a passing knowledge of the subject is required in order to maintain efficiently an installation of electric lamps and adjust and calibrate gas detectors requiring the attention of scientific instruments. Case for the Electric Lamp. By N. E. Nicholson, B.Sc., Assoc.I.M.E. My aim is to prove that an electric lamp is superior to an oil lamp for use underground. The question will be regarded almost entirely from its practical side, and all figures and results have been taken from recent papers given on the subject of mine lighting and manufacturers' quotations. The main function of a lamp is to give as good a light as possible under certain specified conditions, which conditions are (i) That the light be continuous for at least nine hours at a rate of not less than 1.5 c.p. over the horizontal angle of distribution, and that the M.S.C.P. be 0.40 for cap lamps and 0.75 for all other types of lamps, at the end of nine hours burning. (ii) That the lamp be strong enough to withstand any blows it may receive without damage, provided that these blows are within the bounds of reason; any attempt to use the lamp as a hammer is regarded as outside all reason. (iii) That the lamp is not easily extinguished, and that no time is therefore lost in its relighting. (iv) That the lamp can be used to examine the roof and sides at any angle required of it. (v) That the lamp does not heat and has little or no chance of igniting firedamp. (vi) That the lamp throws no shadows and gives a uniform, soft light. (vii) Easy to keep in good repair. (viii) Reasonable cost of installation and maintenance. (ix) That some method of gas detection can be used. (x) Prevention of miners' nystagmus. Condition No. 1. — In 1929 an alkaline lamp for 22 amp. hours capacity was made capable of rendering 3.5 c.p. after one hour burning and 2.6 c.p. after eight hours burning. This was six years ago and since then a great deal of research has been done due to the new "Lighting in and about Mines Regulations." The candle-powers of a modern electric lamp are well over the specifications laid down by the Ministry of Mines, although the increased power has been obtained by an increase in weight; it may be of interest to know that the weight of the lamp under discussion is 9½ lb. This weight is not really great when it is remembered that the lamp is hung up during most of its shift. Condition No. 2. — The modern electric lamp is made so robust that it is almost impossible to damage it with ordinary treatment. Cap lamps are an exception here, as the wear and tear of the accumulator case is excessive. Condition No. 3. — An electric lamp is not easily extinguished; it may be dropped or bumped without its owner being in the dark. An electric lamp can be taken into an air-current of any velocity and will remain alight. The concussion due to shot-firing does not extinguish an electric lamp. (Do these apply to an oil lamp ?) Condition No. 4. — An electric lamp can be tilted and turned to any angle and neither smokes the glass nor is it extinguished. Any break in the roof or side can be thoroughly examined by an electric lamp, but not always by an oil lamp. An electric lamp may be so hung that the shadow, which is always cast by the oil vessel of an oil lamp, is entirely eliminated. Condition No. 5. — An electric lamp does not heat up; this is due to the fact that the bulbs in use are often vacuum bulbs. Now a vacuum will not propagate heat waves, the lamp is therefore cool. An oil lamp heats, and the heat given off from a number of oil lamps may he sufficient to raise the temperature of the air to such a degree that it takes up too much water vapour and becomes saturated. When saturated air will not absorb the sweat given off from the men's bodies, the men become languid and are unable to work at their maximum output. An electric lamp can ignite gas only if its filament is exposed to the gas, and this can only happen if both the well glass and the bulb be broken. In the new electric lamps arrangements are made by which the electric circuit is broken as soon as the outer glass is broken, thereby rendering it almost impossible for an ignition of gas to take place. In an oil lamp only the outer glass need be broken ; the gauzes need only be damaged and the lamp can cause the ignition of firedamp. The gauzes of an oil lamp may become too hot and thereby be a source of danger; an oil lamp may he upset and the oil go on fire; these are dangerous characteristics from which an electric lamp is free. An oil lamp must be under constant supervision or it is a source of danger; an electric lamp needs no such supervision. Condition No. 6. — The production of shadow is due to pillars, dirt and scratches on the well glass, all of which can be overcome by means of a prismatic well glass, which consists of an untinted glass possessing on its inner surface vertical prisms which have been lightly etched over. This loses a certain amount of light, but with proper etching this loss need not exceed 6%, while with correctly cut prisms all shadows cast by the pillars can be cut out, and cuts and dirt, etc., on the well glass have no effect. If prismatic glass is fitted to an oil lamp, it ceases to he a good gas detector as it is not possible to see the cap through a prismatic glass; and as gas detection is one of the main advantages of an oil lamp, the use of prismatic glass is debarred on oil lamps, which will therefore always cast the shadows of any dirt or scratches which may be on the well glass, and these shadows dancing before the eyes as the lamp moves are very unpleasant to the eyesight. By the absence of shadow there is no tendency to flickering; the light is therefore restful to the eye. An electric lamp lends itself to the fitting of all modifications which tend towards improvement, such as prismatic well glasses, spherical well glass, reflectors, etc. Oil lamps are not so adaptable. Condition No. 7. — The maintenance of an electric lamp depends almost entirely on the maintenance of its accumulator. The modern lamp room equipment is very efficient and, by careful organisation, the accumulator can be kept in good repair and the lamp can always he ready for instant service at a cost of about 3d. per lamp-week. A skilled lampman is essential in any cabin having an electrical equipment. Condition No. 8. — The initial cost of installation and the maintenance costs of an electric lamp equipment are necessarily greater than those of an oil lamp installation (cost of underground relighters must be added to the oil lamp installation). It has been mentioned previously that the wear and tear on a cap lamp is far greater than on a hand lamp; this is due to the fact that the accumulator case is constantly being rubbed against some object or another. The advantages offered by a cap lamp so far outweigh this excessive wear that there is no question of the superiority of a cap lamp over any other form of illumination. With a cap lamp the man's hands are free, the light is always directed where the eyes are looking, there are no shadows, the light is always with the man; the eyes do not need to adapt themselves so much to varying conditions, therefore they do not get tired so easily. Cost of maintaining 65 cap lamps over four years, 4.75d. per lamp-week. Will it be possible to make an oil cap lamp ? Condition No. 9. — It is often said that the oil-lamp is far superior to an electric lamp because with it it is possible to test for gas. It was said at the commencement of this debate that the primary function of a lamp was to give light, let them therefore be judged on this basis. If it is a question of gas detection, there are some excellent electrical devices for that purpose. Condition No. 10. — With the introduction of higher candle-power electric lamps, figures show that there was a decrease in the number of nystagmus cases; now whether this decrease was due to the electricity or merely to the higher candle-power I do not know, although I tend to favour the higher candle-power as the cause of the decrease. Nystagmus is a form of nervous disease, comparable in certain cases to shell shock, and is due to the dancing, flickering lights on the coal face and also to the state of the man's nerves when working at the face. The spectrum of an oil lamp shows, as can be expected, an increase in the red, orange, yellow and green lights; this is due to the fact that all the heat waves are free to pass into the atmosphere, while the actual source of the light is at a lower temperature than that of an electric filament. The spectrum of an electric lamp gives less red light and more violet and blue light; this can also he expected, as the long red waves are not propagated by the vacuum bulb, while the high temperature of the filament gives use to the blue and violet light. The blue and violet light is injurious to the eye, but owing to the fact that this short wave length light is more readily absorbed by the atmosphere, it does not get a chance to reach the eye in sufficient quantity to he dangerous. We see therefore that the oil lamp has a slight advantage in the number of effective rays — emitted, but at the cost of raising the temperature both of the lamp and of the air. The only real advantage that an oil lamp has over an electric lamp is that "bugbear" of all mining questions, cost, against which the electric lamp may cause a greater output due to its obvious underground advantages; this greater output may be sufficient to warrant the difference in cost. Taking an oil lamp and an electric lamp and comparing them item by item, one conclusion only can be drawn, and that is "that an electric lamp is superior to an oil lamp for underground use."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||