7th December 1932, Page: 176, Column: 1
Penetrating Power Of Lamps
While experiments were being carried out at the works of
Hailwood and Ackroyd, Ltd., the impression was gathered that
there was a possible difference in the quality of vision between
electric and flame lamps. The penetrating power of lamps being
deemed a matter of importance, the firm decided to call in an
independent authority to investigate the problem, the work being
undertaken by Mr. D. McKerracher, B.Sc., A.R.T.C., whose
report has been published, with four diagrams illustrating the
results of the inquiry. Excerpts from the report are appended
The lamp, an essential part of the miner's equipment, is used
fundamentally to illuminate the various objects in his immediate
vicinity. These may be the "face," a prop, a tool, but whatever
they may he it is essential and desirable that they should be
observed with the minimum of strain on the eye.
Any object is seen simply by the light which it sends to the eye,
and is generally observed in terms of its brightness and colour.
Different surfaces may be receiving the same amount of light, but
the brightness of the surfaces may be very different. It is this
difference in brightness which enables various objects to be clearly
distinguished. Obviously the brightness and the colour of an
object depends ultimately on the source of light employed. The
greater the intensity, that is the candle-power, of the source,
whatever type it is, then in general, for the same distance of
observation, the greater is the brightness of the object. The
colour, however, depends very largely on the type of source used.
For example, the light from an oil flame lamp differs from that
obtained from an electric lamp.
Colour is unfortunately not a characteristic of mines, but
perhaps the colour characteristics of the source plays an important
part in determining the visibility of objects, particularly with the
comparatively low illuminations in general use.
The spectra due to two lamps, one, an oil lamp of the high
candle-power Hailwood type and the other of the type which is
known as a high candle-power electric lamp, were examined with
a constant deviation spectroscope. The candle-powers of the
two lamps were adjusted to approximately the same values, and
the flame or the filament in each case was placed at the same
distance from the silt in the spectroscope.
It is indicated that the sources of white light have quite different
spectra. The oil lamp flame possessing, as it does, greater proportions
of the red, orange, yellow and green rays and loss of the
blue and violet rays, would be calculated to he more agreeable
to the sensitive eyes of a miner, and particularly to a miner
suffering with nystagmus.
The intensities or brightness of the luminous hand in various
parts of the spectra due to the same two lamps above were compared
by means of a simple type of spectrophotometer. This
simple method at its best is not one which leads to high accuracy,
and the necessarily short distances involved decreases it still
mere, but a series of readings indicates that for equal candle-powers
the intensity in the red particularly and the orange,
yellow and green for the oil lamp is substantially greater than
for the electric lamp, while the intensity in the blue and the
violet of the oil lamp flame, is very much less than that of the
light given by the electric lamp. This perhaps has considerable
significance in determining the visibility of objects, particularly
under comparatively low illuminations, and with surfaces reflecting
light largely in the middle region, that is orange, yellow
and green, of the spectrum such as is given by coal faces.
There is a limit to the distance between two illuminated point
objects for which the eye is capable of distinguishing them as
two separate objects. This is the principle on which the test
charts used in sight testing under normal conditions of illumination
is based, thus small letters, which have less distance between
them, can only be read when viewed from a shorter distance than
is necessary for the large letters. On the standard optician's
chart alongside each row of letters is marked a distance, and at
this distance a normal eye should be able to read the letters
distinctly. This type of chart was used to examine the visual
acuity (or acuteness of vision) under the illumination from the
two types of lamp. Each lamp, in turn, was placed at various
distances from the standard optician's chart hung up on the
wall of a dark room, thus obtaining a range of intensities of
illumination on the chart. The position of the flame of the oil
lamp or the filament of the electric lamp was in a line at right
angles to the centre of the portion of the chart utilised. All
observations were made at a distance of thirteen feet (the maximum
distance available in the Investigator's laboratory), with the
lamp screened so that no light fell directly on the eyes of the
observer, the eye being adapted for the low illumination by
remaining in the dark room for ten minutes before making any
observations. The results of one set of observations, which is
typical of others, showed that with an illumination of 0.9 foot-candle
the smallest row of letters (0.2 inch high) can be read
with the oil lamp illumination, but only the second smallest row
(0.29 inch high) with the electric lamp illumination when the
chart is observed from the same distance.
To test the visibility under something like normal mining
conditions, two miner's lamps — one was old and very dull black
in appearance, the other being considerably brighter, these lamps
were not alight — and also two wooden rods were placed side by
side against a dull black wall (dull black painted). With the
high candle-power electric lamp at a distance away of eight feet,
all the outlines of the lamps and rods were visible, but with the
oil lamp of the same candle-power and placed at the same distance
the outlines of the articles were more distinct, the dull lamp
outline being easily distinguished. Repeating with the same
high candle-power lamps at eleven feet, the rods and brighter
lamp were visible, but not the dull one, when using the electric
lamp, whereas with the oil lamp all were visible, the outline of
the dull lamp being quite definite.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| McKerracher, D. | | | |