9th November 1935, Page: 137, Column: 1
Apparent Case For Steam Pumping
By Geoffrey W. Bell, B.Sc., Stud.I.M.E.
Summary of paper read on 26th October before the Associates
and Students' Section of the North of England Institute of Mining
and Mechanical Engineers. Schedules showing items were exhibited
with the paper as given.
The subject of this contribution is the consideration of an
actual problem encountered at a colliery, but it is necessary to
state that the case depended upon certain conditions remaining
constant, such as the water feeder and the low grade fuel supply
which was otherwise valueless. As subsequent events proved
the conditions did vary substantially, and a survey under otber
conditions would probably lead to a vastly different conclusion.
The fact to be faced was an increase in the water feeder, in the
near future, of 2,000 gallons per minute against a total head of
360 feet. Electrically driven centrifugal pumps had been installed
several years previously and were capable of dealing with the
feeders of that period. It was therefore necessary either to
install additional pumps or to replace the existing ones with
larger capacity units.
As the water standage was limited pumping operations would
be continuous when the additional feeder was encountered. Since
electrical energy was purchased from the Supply Company, and
steam was generated at the colliery for all surface plant, the
installation of a steam turbine driven centrifugal pump seemed
worthy of consideration. Alternatively an electrically driven
pump could be installed.
In the case of an electric unit capital expenditure was necessary
on pump, motors, switchgear and cable. The cost of the pump
may be neglected as it is common to both units. Efficiencies of
80 and 90 per cent. should be obtained for the pump and motor
respectively and, taking the cost of energy at one-half-penny per
unit, the annual charge will be £4,126. An itemised annual
account shows the total annual cost of the unit as being £4,682 10s.
A scheme for the installation of a steam turbine driven pump
would entail a greater capital expenditure as additions and
alterations would be necessary to the existing steam plant. The
boiler plant consisted of six Lancashire boilers hand-fired with
low grade fuel having a calorific value of 9,790 B.Th.U. per lb.
and an ash content of 26.8 per cent. The feed water was preheated
to a certain extent by exhaust steam from No. 1 winder.
The steam requirements of the various plants under normal
conditions when the boiler plant was working to full capacity
were :—
A test was run on one boiler to ascertain the thermal efficiency
of the boiler plant and it was found to be 44.1 per cent. It was
considered that the efficiency could be raised to at least 65 per
cent, by the use of a Galloway supermiser.
The steam requirements of a turbine suitable for the pumping
unit were then considered. As the boiler plant was only capable
of a maximum steam pressure of 80 lb. per square inch the first
set of conditions applied, i.e., at 70 lb. per square inch the turbine
required 171 lb. dry saturated steam per B.H.P. hour and be
capable of developing up to 287 B.H.P. The water from the
pump would be delivered through the condenser in order to obtain
the necessary vacuum of 28 inches.
In order to obtain the necessary supply of steam it was proposed
to fit a Galloway supermiser to the six Lancashire boilers and a
super-heater of suitable size to counteract the losses of the steam
range, regrind No. 1 winder cylinders and fit new pistons to
improve the steam consumption, replace the screen endless
hauler and two steam engines with electric motors. There would
also be a considerable saving by dispensing with a long steam
range from the boilers to the screens. It was estimated that
normally about 9,800 lb. of steam per hour would be available
from which the turbine could be supplied.
The capital expenditure necessary to carry out the scheme
was estimated at £7,215.
The fuel, consisting of coal-cutter kirvings and coarse coal,
was valued at 4s. per ton and the annual charge for fuel was
calculated to be £858. The total annual cost of pumping by
steam power was estimated to be £3,410 19s. showing a saving
in favour of the steam plant of £1,271 11s. per annum, or 27 per
cent.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bell, Geoffrey W. | | | |