|
8th November 1935, Page: 879, Column: 1 Notes from the Coal FieldsThe Midlands[Local Correspondence.] At Newcastle County Court recently his honour Judge Ruegg, K.C., heard a claim brought under the Workmen's Compensation Acts by Mrs. M. Williams, in respect of the death of her husband, O. Williams, a collier, against his employers, Madeley Collieries, Ltd. Mr. R. McG. Clarkson said on February 16 Williams, who was a day wage collier, was brought home by ambulance with an injury to his foot caused by his being struck by a fall of coal. It was contended that Williams, who died on August 23 from myocarditis, died as a result of the accident, and compensation to the amount of £271 16s. 6d. was claimed. On February 25 Williams was sent to the North Staffordshire Royal Infirmary, where be was N-rayed and a fracture of the big toe diagnosed. On March 18, after he returned from the infirmary, he was taken ill from influenza, followed by influenza-pneumonia. On July 15 he was certified fit for light work, and went weeding the track on the' colliery bank. On August 9 he was diagnosed as suffering from bronchial pneumonia. He never worked again, and died on August 23 the immediate cause of death being myocarditis. Mr. Clarkson said that from first to last Williams never fully recovered from the injury to the toe. He sweated and suffered from sleeplessness. and was so debilitated by the pain and loss of sleep as to be a ready victim to the pneumonia germ. Mr. Tucker said the case for the respondents was that death was due to natural causes, not related to or accelerated by the accident. Dr. Duncan, Madeley, panel doctor of Williams, said he considered that death was due indirectly to the injury. Dr. B. Stross, who spoke to attending a post-mortem examination of Williams on August 27, said he thought Williams would have recovered but for the accident. His honour announced that be would reserve judgment. The importance of workmen giving early notice, even of what seem to be trivial accidents, was emphasised in an action which came before his honour Judge H. L. Tebbs, at the Walsall County Court on Thursday, October 24, when H. Morgan, stallman, applied for an award against the Conduit Colliery Co., Ltd., Norton Canes, under the Workmen's Compensation Acts, in respect of an injury received on Saturday, May 4 last. The case for the applicant, for whom Mr. A. P. Marshall appeared, was that he was incapacitated as the result of an injury to the first finger of his right hand received' while he was at work. One of the grounds on which liability was denied by the respondents, who were represented by Mr. F. E. Metcalfe, was that the accident was not reported to them as required by the Acts. Morgan, in the witness box, said that he was working in company with a man named Grainger laying rails. He was using a sledge-hammer, and he caught his finger between the shaft and the rail. He did not report the accident at the time because he thought it was a trivial one. He continued to work until one o'clock, and Monday being Jubilee Day, he did not return until the following Tuesday. His finger pained him somewhat and in the evening he saw his panel doctor, who advised him fomentations. He also asked him if he wanted a note to go on the box, but he refused, as he thought it would be well in a few days. He did not, however, return to work until the following Sunday evening, and apart from short time, he continued until May 31. He was still receiving medical treatment and on May 23 his finger was examined at the Walsall General Hospital and it was amputated on June 4. His pre-accident earnings were £2 8s. 9d. a week, and he had not been paid any compensation, nor had he been offered light work. Dr. McCollough, the applicant's panel doctor, and Dr. Robert Forrest, of the Walsall General Hospital, both said that in their opinion the injury was caused by the blow in the pit. Mr. Metcalfe submitted that the application must fail because no notice of the accident was given to the respondents within the meaning of the Act. Mr. Marshall said notice of the accident to Morgan was given as soon as practicable, and that complied with the Act. It was not until May 23 that steps were taken which resulted in the discovery of the injury to the bone, which was the real incapacitating injury. Another point was that there were cases in which it had been held that an application for compensation did not fail solely because early notice of what appeared to be a trivial accident had not been given. His honour, giving judgment, said the Act laid it down that notice must be given in writing as soon as practicable after the accident. It was quite clear that on the Tuesday following his injury, Morgan thought it sufficiently serious to visit his doctor who advised him not to go to work. All the medical evidence which had been given was agreed upon the point that it was a bad thing for him to go back to work, and although it was not for him to speculate on what the employers would have done if they had had earlier notice of the accident, it was possible that they might have ordered Morgan to rest, and that may have prevented the septic trouble from developing into necrosis. Workmen knew quite well that they must give notice of accidents which might give rise to claims, and they could not abandon their claims themselves and at the same time keep them alive in a secret way against their employers. The action, he said, therefore, failed, and there would be judgment for the respondents with costs.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||