|
8th November 1935, Page: 857, Column: 1 The North Gawber ExplosionConclusion Of The Inquiry At BarnsleyThe Chief Inspector of Mines (Sir Henry Walker) continued at Barnsley on Friday last the Department of Mines inquiry into the explosion at North Gawber Colliery on September 12. Mr. J. M. Hall (for the Yorkshire Miners' Association) resumed his cross-examination of Mr. Cyril Weaver, the under-manager of the mine. Mr. Weaver said that the ripping shot was fired in No. 4 south face upon the shotfirer's responsibility, and he had no idea what caused the explosion. Electricity, he agreed, might have caused the explosion, but he was doubtful about that. The only thing left was the shotfiring. But that seemed mysterious to him, because, according to the evidence, the last shot was fired from 30 to 60 min. prior to the explosion. If that shot had ignited, surely the people in the vicinity would have seen the gas alight. In addition, the shotfirer and persons concerned were positive that the shot had done its work, and they had gone away satisfied. Questioned regarding the use of electricity in mines, Mr. Weaver said that if it were possible to get coal without electricity, he would get rid of it, but in this pit he believed it impossible to do without electricity. Compressed air was much safer, but he could not say why it had not been used. Asked if he felt satisfied that there might have been a cause for this explosion which could have been avoided, witness said From our experience previously it could not have been avoided." He said that he did not know that the divisional inspector of mines had written to the management of the colliery asking for a reduction in the number of shots fired during each shift. At North Gawber a notice had been posted limiting the number of shots to 30 per shift. Mr. George Cook, senior inspector of mines, said that in his opinion the explosion was caused by the ignition of firedamp caused by the shot fired in the ripping in No. 4 south face. That shot, he thought, ignited the gas in the old settling gate. The gas continued to burn until an explosive mixture was reached. The interval of time between the firing of the shot and the explosion might be explained by the fact that, though the gas was ignited, an explosive mixture was not formed for some time afterwards. He said that lamps and electricity had been ruled out as possible causes of the explosion. Mr. Herbert Smith quoted from reports showing that on a number of occasions shotfirers had fired more than 30 shots a day, and he suggested that the instructions had not been strictly carried out. That does not look like 'instant dismissal' when regulations are broken," he commented. He asked if that did not look like carelessness to orders. Mr. Cook replied More than carelessness; it looks like disregard of orders. Mr. Samuel Lawrence: manager of the North Gawber Colliery, said that he had never received any report that his shotfirers were not carrying out their duties properly. When he noticed that certain men were firing more than 30 shots a day he had given several warnings, and on the last occasion had said that any further breach would lead to dismissal. He agreed with the evidence that had been given which tended to rule out any defect in the electrical equipment as a possible cause of the explosion, and was satisfied also that the lamps were not responsible. Mr. Lawrence was questioned by Sir Henry Walker about loose explosives which had been found in the mine, and agreed that there had been some carelessness about these explosives. Ever since the explosion he had had the powder locked up as well as the detonators, and he was not allowing any handing over of explosives from one shift to another. Major H. J. Humphrys, divisional inspector of mines, said that he attributed the explosion, which took place at about 2.30, to the firing of the shot which was said to have taken place at 1.40 p.m. on September 12. Delayed ignitions were not uncommon, two having been reported in the past year in Yorkshire. In one instance the flame burned for two weeks and its existence was not discovered for a week. The remedies he recommended were the solid stowing of waste and the use of sheathed explosives, where the use of explosives could not be dispensed with altogether. At the concluding session of the inquiry on Saturday, evidence relative to the causes of explosions during the 15 years 1919 to 1933 was given by Mr. J. A. B. Horsley, Chief Electrical Inspector of Mines. Replying to Mr. Herbert Smith, witness said that so far as he knew no ignition of firedamp had been brought house to compressed air. He would not claim for a moment that electricity was equally as safe as compressed air. Mr. Smith said he was prejudiced against the use of electricity in mines, and was anxious to know if there is room for inquiry as to the use of electricity and compressed air in pits from the point of view of safety. Mr. Horsley admitted that such an inquiry might serve a useful purpose. Mr. Sam Diggle, agent to the colliery, said he had not been able to discover any cause for the explosion other than the possibility that it was due to delayed ignition, following the firing of a shot. He had, however, been unable to trace any signs of burning between the firing of the shot and the explosion. Replying to Major Humphrys, he said that the mines inspectors had given proper attention to North Gawber Colliery, and recommendations which they had made regarding shotfiring had been acted upon. In answer to Mr. Smith, he said he was aware that a small trace of gas had been frequently reported, but he would not look upon North Gawber as a gassy mine. Mr. J. A. Hall asked if it was possible to have the report of the inspectors relative to North Gawber for the last 12 months but this was refused. Mr. Hall, in evidence, said the men had been working in dangerous conditions, and if the inspectors had seen those conditions he was satisfied that they had not done their duty. He added that, in his opinion, the explosion was caused by the pummel at the end of the trailing cable being pulled out, causing a spark which ignited gas. He contended that the condition of the airways constituted a contravention of the Coal Mines Act, but Sir Henry pointed out that they provided a means of egress which the Act required. I don't believe in the section, it ought to be better worded," added Sir Henry. Mr. Hall : The Act cannot be contravened, then, unless there is complete stoppage? Sir Henry : That's all. Sir Henry (to Major Humphrys) : Do you say there is a means of egress that a man can get through, no matter how? Major Humphrys : Yes. And that it complies with s. 42 ? Yes. Sir Henry : If you find such a place where you have to crawl on your stomachs would you be satisfied to leave it at that ? No. You would go beyond the regulations and make representation to the management to make a better road ? Yes, I do so continually. Mr. Herbert Smith said he was pleased to hear that Sir Henry agreed that mines inspectors needed more power, and added that under the present conditions of mining a new set of regulations is required. The Inquest. Addressing the jury at the close of the inquest at Barnsley on Tuesday, on the 19 victims of the disaster, the coroner (Mr. C. J. Haworth) asked them to support hint in putting forward to the Mines Department that the overhauling of the regulations for shotfiring should be seriously considered. "We cannot shut our eyes," he said, "to the fact that explosions due to shotfiring do take place from time to time. The obvious thing to say is that precautions should be taken. I am not talking about this pit, but pits generally. With intensive mining of to-day there are certain dangers which would probably not have existed some years ago. If you are going to have this speeding up and the advancement of the face very much faster than before, I think it is exceedingly necessary that the whole question of the regulations, especially with regard to ventilation and shotfiring, should receive the most serious consideration of the authorities. He added that there had been a certain amount of slackness at the colliery, but no evidence that there was any general slackness which led to the explosion. The jury returned a verdict of "Deaths from misadventure" due to an explosion of firedamp following the firing of a shot, and added that they felt strongly that where shotfiring was allowed there should be greater supervision, and that there should he greater supervision and control in the working of the pit. They asked the mines inspector to put forward these recommendations.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||