|
1st November 1935, Page: 814, Column: 2 The North Gawber ExplosionProgress Of The Inquiry At BarnsleyWhen the inquiry into the explosion which took place at North Gawber Colliery on September 12 was resumed at Barnsley on Friday of last week, J. Brook, of Darton, a deputy, stated that on the night before the explosion he reported a slight trace of gas in No. 3 South District. Between March 1 and the day of the explosion he had reported slight traces of gas 135 times. H. Senior, a deputy, stated that he had reported slight traces of gas between 4 a.m. and 6 am, on the day of the explosion. Asked about the return airway, he said that it was about 5 ft. high by 7 ft. wide, 100 yd. from the coal face. He did not think that the force of the explosion would make it any smaller. It was about 3 ft. by 3 ft. in the smallest place. He did not agree that the return airway was in a dreadful state of repair before he began work on it. He had not seen stones thrown on or fall on the electric cable. He would describe North Gawber as a normal pit so far as gas was concerned. H. Kenworthy, a deputy called as a witness by the Yorkshire Miners' Association, said that he had called attention to the fact that he had found gas in his district on 136 occasions between March and August. Since then he had reported no gas. F. Thompson, of Stairfoot, a deputy, said that he had fired 31 shots the day before the explosion. It took him from 10 to 15 min. to examine and fire a shot. Mr. Herbert Smith said he was very sorry to hear witness say that. Shotfiring and electricity, he added, was bothering him more than anything else in the pit. G. Cooper and M. Clapham both stated that only a few seconds elapsed between the time when F. Clayton fired a shot and the explosion. The ripping, to move which the shot was fired, was still in position when they left at 2.15. On Sir Henry Walker's instructions Clayton was brought back to give further evidence, and confirmed that he fired the ripping shot at 1.40. H. Burton, a lampman, giving evidence on Tuesday, said that all the men who had been killed, except one, had carried electric lamps. The flame lamps in No. 3 and 4 districts (the scene of the explosion) had since been tested. So far as he knew all the lamps were sound. About two years ago he received instructions that the boys should receive flame lamps. Two months ago he gave them electric lamps, and they continued to have them up to the time of the explosion. That, he agreed, was contrary to instructions. Capt. C. B. Platt, superintendent of the Mines Department Testing Station at Sheffield, who received 44 lamps for inspection, said in evidence that none of them was in a condition that an ignition of firedamp and air could be directly attributed to it, except one. The, glass of that one was broken, but it was impossible to say when it was broken. He regarded the flame lamp as being not less safe than an electric lamp. In certain circumstances it might be more safe. J. W. Land, chief engineer at the colliery, said in evidence that on September 6 he received a report of severe sparking on the motor in No. 3 district, and found that the sparking was not electrical, but mechanical. He did not connect the explosion with the electrical apparatus of the mine. J. Cowan, junior electrical inspector of mines, said that he examined various electrical instruments in the mine, but found no defects to which he could attribute the explosion. Mr. J. A. B. Horsley, electrical inspector of mines, was asked by Mr. Hall if he believed disasters in mines would he fewer if there were no electricity in the pits. He replied "No," and added that the facts proved to the contrary. If a cutting machine were working at a time when gas bad been reported he would stop the machine. He was not aware that machinery had been working during the time when gas had been reported, and was satisfied that electricity did not cause the explosion. Mr. Horsley agreed that there was need for more care in the operation of electricity in mines, and that if they were going to fire shots, cables should be protected or removed. Further witnesses were called to endeavour to arrive at the time when the last shot was fired before the explosion. H. Buckley, giving evidence, said that he saw F. Clayton, the shotfirer, at 1.30 p.m., and the shot was fired soon afterwards. F. Stone, sub-inspector of mines, said in evidence that after the explosion he found four packets of explosives, a canister containing 5 lb. of explosives, and an open box of explosives in the pit. Mrs. E. Roberts, whose husband was killed in the explosion, said that he had been at No. 3 south face since last Easter, and that he came home night after night and told her about the gas there, and used to say, "Sure as eggs are eggs there will be trouble." In September, just before the explosion, he said that sooner or later he expected the pit to go up. He said that the cutting machine was sparking and was working very hot. Further witnesses were called and questioned, particularly about the time that elapsed between the firing of the last shot and the explosion. E. Senior said that the shot had not been fired at 2.15 p.m., and G. Tetlow gave evidence that the shot was fired at 2.20 p.m. C. Weaver, manager of the mine, said that shots were fired only on rare occasions in No. 4 South Top Gate. He disagreed with the suggestion that it would be dangerous and risky to fire a shot into the ripping at a point where the shot was fired by Clayton prior to the explosion. Witness said that he had seen the deputy's reports about gas in the mine and on several occasions had disagreed with them. He had never found 1 per cent. or more of gas. There had been no breach of the regulations governing the firing of shots, neither had there been any complaint about the way in which deputies carried out the shotfiring. To his knowledge there had been no requests by the men for an examination of the pit. It was not a hot pit. He had supervised the carrying out of the regulation with regard to the searching of men before they went down the pit. On three occasions when 2½ per cent. of gas had been reported near the old settling gate the men had been withdrawn. Deputies had a perfectly free hand in making their reports. Describing the explosion, Weaver said that he was at the bottom of the shaft when the pit telephone bell rang. He answered it and someone said "Come down straight away. The air has reversed. Something is wrong." He then went towards the coal face with Mr. Poxon, who began to feel ill. "I said, 'We must get on" said Weaver, "and we went and found a smith's body. I insisted on going in again. We came across two dead horses. By this time Poxon was semi-conscious. I stayed until everyone was accounted for except two, and then I was taken home and was put into a bath. I remember no more until the next day." Witness said that he had not heard of five letters of complaint regarding the condition of the travelling road being addressed by the secretary of the North Gawber Miners' Association to the manager of the mine. F. Stone, a sub-inspector, on Wednesday, when asked by Sir Henry if he had any idea as to what caused the explosion, replied : "The original opinion I held was that the pummel end of the electric trailing cable had been drawn out of the band while the current was on. But from the evidence I have since heard, and the examination I have since made, my opinion has begun to change. Since then I have been wavering between the opinion of the shot in No. 4 south face and the pummel end. It is possible, I think, for a shot to ignite a small amount of firedamp which would be too rich to explode at the moment, but would continue to burn in the break so that an explosive mixture would be formed by the burning. Asked if he had any idea how the subsequent derangement of the airway could be caused, witness said it was possibly caused by a door being left open or by damage to a door.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||