26th October 1935, Page: 116, Column: 1
Silicosis In Anthracite Mines
By T. David Jones, Ph.D., M.Sc., F.G.S.
Summary of paper read on the 14th October before the North
Staffordshire Institute of Mining Engineers on "Lung Trouble
attributed to Silicosis in Anthracite Mines (23rd report to the
Committee on 'The Control of Atmospheric Conditions in Hot and
Deep Mines')."
For the whole of the country there were 702 certificates (118
deaths. 417 total disablements, 167 partial disablements) in
which the presence of silicosis was certified by the Medical Boards
appointed by the Home Office from their initiation in 1928 to
31st December, 1984. Over 85 per cent. of the deaths, 90 per
cent, of the total disablements, and 86 per cent. of the partial
disablements were in the South Wales coalfield. Nearly 90 per
cent, of the total certificates issued by the Boards concerned this
coalfield.
An examination of the facts collected directly from the collieries
reveals in a most unmistakable manner that the majority
of the cases in the Swansea Division come from the anthracite
area, i.e., the area west of and including the Vale of Neath. It
is natural to ask what are the differences, if any, which exist
in the anthracite collieries as compared with collieries in the
remainder of the South Wales coalfield. The differences may
be stated as follows: (a) No stone-dusting is done in the anthracite
collieries. (b) The strata do not contain any higher percentage
of free silica; if anything, the Coal Measures contain less free
silica in the rock. (c) More explosives arc used during the working
shifts on the coal face. (d) Spakes are in common use. (e) The
amount of dust on the roadways is no greater, in fact is less,
than in collieries where stone dust is used. On comparing these
data available from the collieries, it would appear that there is
a more definite connection between the free silica-content of the
strata worked and the incidence of silicosis in the South Wales
districts outside the anthracite area.
The Use of Spakes.
In the majority of the South Wales anthracite collieries access
is given by means of slants or inclined adits, and not by shafts.
in a large number of collieries it is customary to ride the men
for long distances to and from their work, and a special train
of trolleys, known as a "spake," is used for this purpose. A
spake is composed of a number of fiat trolleys fitted with wooden
seats placed at intervals at right angles to the length of the trolley,
and consequently at right angles of the slant itself. The term
"bridle" is sometimes substituted for spake. The following
may be taken as an example of a spake. Each trolley is fitted
with seven seats and each seat is capable of seating three men,
thus the capacity of each trolley is 21 men. Five trolleys go
to make up the spake, therefore, 105 men are brought to the
surface per spake. The figures vary for each colliery. The
distance travelled by the spake also varies at each colliery, but
is always over half a mile, and the time taken by the spake is
usually about 20 minutes. The men sit on the spakes with their
faces towards the bottom of the slant, and, since the spake usually
runs in the main intake airway, they travel with their backs
towards the direction of the wind on being brought out from
their work. In winter, the temperature change from the workings
to the surface is over 40°F.
The men are subjected to high wind- or air-velocities of from
1,500 to 2,000 feet per minute, in addition to the change of
temperature.
Classifying the anthracite collieries into (a) those with spakes,
and (b) those without spakes, the former are shown to have
several times more certificated cases of silicosis than the latter.
The Registrar General's Report on Occupational Mortality for
the years 1921-3 is rather illuminating, and it would appear as
if the use of spakes in anthracite collieries is responsible for the
high rate of deaths from what was then called bronchitis, but
which would include a large number of cases now diagnosed as
silicosis, for the western area of the South Wales coalfield.
The facts indicate that the apparent harm attributed to the
dust in anthracite mines is, in reality, dependent on bronchitis
resulting from exposure to cold in the spakes, with secondary
accumulation of coal dust in the lungs in consequence of the normal
process of elimination of dust from the lungs being paralysed.
Taking 34 anthracite collieries from which information is
available (a) of the increase of 142 claims during the period (April,
1984, to May, 1935), only 14 were from collieries without spakes
(b) of the increase of 117 certified cases during the period, only
5 were from collieries without spakes.
The use of spakes is generally adopted in the anthracite collieries,
and the high incidence of cases certified as silicosis in the
collieries using spakes as compared with the collieries without
them, indicates that here we have a factor hearing essentially
on the state of affairs which exists. It is not suggested that the
abolition of spakes would mean immunity from what is called
silicosis, but it is apparent that some form of protection is necessary
for the men who use these spakes to -get to and from their
work. This protection may be afforded in the following way
(1) Spakes should, where possible, be run in the return airway.
(2) Where spakes are used in the main intake airways, which
is more general and which unfortunately cannot be avoided,
then protection may be afforded by (a) the use of hoods on the
individual trolleys which make up the spake, and (b) some sort
of personal or individual protection in the form of a cowl. With
regard to the latter, much work requires to be done in order to
ascertain the suitability of various forms of materials. Hoods
have been tried on the spakes at one or two of the collieries, but
these have not altogether been a success, although they afforded
good protection.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Jones, T. David | | | |