|
25th October 1935, Page: 781, Column: 1 The North Gawber ExplosionInquiry Opened At BarnsleySir Henry Walker (Chief Inspector of Mines) opened at Barnsley on Tuesday the Mines Department's inquiry into the North Gawber Colliery disaster on September 12, in which 19 men lost their lives. Dr. H. S. Houldsworth, representing the colliery company, said that before the formal part of the inquiry opened he would like on behalf of the managing director of the company (Sir William Sutherland) to express the owners' sincere sympathy with those who had been bereaved and also with the injured. Sir Henry Walker said he was sure all present would associate themselves with the expression of sympathy. J. Crow, a loader man, who was in 3 south level at the time, said that the air was good just before the explosion. He described the explosion and how he assisted three injured men towards safety, and added that the conveyor continued working for about half-a-minute after the explosion. In reply to Mr. Herbert Smith (president of the Yorkshire Miners' Association), witness agreed that as he was in charge of an electrical engine he should have had a flame lamp, but he had not had one for a fortnight before the explosion. He said that he had seen no sparking from the engine during that time, but that sparks had been seen about 12 months ago. Witness said that the officials of the colliery did come round to inspect for gas with an oil lamp, but he saw no inspection made on the day of the explosion. At the conclusion of this witness's evidence, Mr. Smith complimented him on what he did. G. Bowen, a trammer, who was one of the injured men, said that before the explosion there was nothing to give cause for alarm. He was carrying an oil lamp which was put out by the explosion. The loader ran for about 3 min. after the explosion. S. Hunter said he had seen tests made for gas, but not on the day of the explosion. H. Hardcastle, engine driver, said that about two months ago he detected gas, but although he informed a collier, he did not report the matter to a deputy. R. E. Winstanley said he tested for gas on the morning of the explosion, but found none. He had found some about three months previously when his lamp was put out. J. Barlow, miner, said he tested for gas three times during the shift and found "all clear." Just after the explosion he found a light trace of gas. On the day before the explosion his and other men's lamps were put on when the ventilation was interfered with following a fall of ripping. Witness stated that he had not seen any stone-dusting done or any test fur gas made prior to shotfiring, but that alter the shothole was stemmed the shotfirer always ordered him away, and it might be that a test for gas was made then. In reply to Mr. J. A. Hail, he said that after a shot had been fired he had never seen any evidence of stone dusting having been done. Answering Dr. Houldsworth, witness agreed that both precautions might have been taken without his knowledge. D. Jones, miner, agreed with Mr. J. A. Hall that a test for gas ought to be made before even a shothole was charged, and said it was his experience that that was done. He said he had known a deputy refuse to fire a shut after making a test, and tell the men they would have to get the coal by hand. Dr. S. W. Fisher (medical inspector of mines) said that in the presence of Dr. Millar and Dr. Whincup he examined the bodies of 15 men. The majority died from carbon monoxide poisoning, and their injuries in many cases were only slight. Sir Henry Walker said that there was a man who wrote a message on stone in the pit and succumbed and asked witness if he could explain why, if a man could write something on stone, he could not walk out of the pit? Dr. Fisher replied that one of the peculiarities of poisoning by CO is that power in the legs is first lost. Whatever was on his mind he would be likely to do. Obviously feeling very ill, but conscious, he would know, perhaps, he could only go a little further, but he would be able to take a piece of chalk and write such a message. He estimated that the message took between a half and three-quarters of a minute to write. At the close of the doctor's evidence Mr. Smith remarked, "You have made a name in Yorkshire — a name that the miners revere." When the inquiry was continued on Wednesday, J. T. Wally, who lost his brother, G. A. Wally, in the disaster, said that he was quite sure that his brother would have cut the power off the machine he was using when the explosion occurred. He was a most careful man. After the explosion witness shouted for the electricity to be cut off. B. Sanderson, the deputy in charge of No. 4 south district, where the explosion occurred, said that he was hit on the face and hands by hits of coal. He tied a handkerchief around his face and sent a man to telephone to the overman. Sanderson broke down and cried as he described how he found one body after another of the men who had worked under him. After finding one body he went back to the foot of the shaft. Then there was a call for volunteers. Only two of them were there at that time, and they went back again and stayed until the rescuers came. He had last reported gas in No. 4 south district on July 9. It was very slight. He was satisfied with the type of oil-lamp provided in the mine. Between March 3 and July 9 last 87 appearances of gas had been reported. Replying to Dr. Houldsworth, Sanderson said that even the slightest traces of gas had to be reported. Since July 9 he had found no trace of gas, and had received no complaints from any of the men on his shift. Men in charge of electrical machinery always tested for gas before starting up. The statutory requirements as to stone dusting before shotfiring were always fulfilled. There was always an adequate amount of stone dust available. Sanderson said that be was satisfied with the ventilation and had received no complaints. W. Mansfield, captain of the rescue brigade, said that he received instructions to try to reach nine men still in. They had not gone far before they bail to put on respirators. Then they were stopped by a fall. When they had moved it they found a man underneath, dead. They went another 10 yd., and were stopped by a fall, but got over that and found two more bodies. Soon afterwards they found another fall. Immediately they had cleared it the ventilation began to get better, and by the time they had reached the last man the air was quite good and fresh. He saw a canary near one of the men; it was not dead, it was just flapping its wings. C. Moores, who was underground, said that when the disaster occurred he started to leave, but returned, and came across J. Wally. Moores said that he found Harrison, and shoved him and Brant on in front. When they got to No. 3 south level and had a drink of water he and Brant went back, but Brant was exhausted and fell down. He brought him back to the level end. There was a call for volunteers, and he went back again. Finally, someone suggested that they should get out. He was about done, and got out as quickly as he could. Sir Henry congratulated Moores on his efforts. W. Brant, continuing his evidence on Thursday and, replying to Mr. J. A. Hall, said that he had not seen a mines inspector in his part of the pit during the last four or five months. In reply to Dr. H. S. Houldsworth, Brant said that he had conscientiously carried out his statutory duties to see that his men were not exposed to danger. He had reported every occasion on which he had found gas, and his notices, posted at the pithead, could be seen by the men. He said that he had never seen anything to suggest that proper stone-dusting had not been carried out. He saw nothing on the day of the explosion connected with the electrical appliances or cables which was a possible source of danger. T. Kelly, of Darton, formerly a deputy at North Gawber Colliery, said that in September 1934, he had found 2½ per cent. of gas in one part of his district. The men were withdrawn and the area fenced off. During the last six or eight weeks that he was at North Gawber he did not find much gas. At this point a discussion arose between Sir Henry Walker and Mr. Herbert Smith (for the Yorkshire Miners' Association) regarding methods of ripping. Each held that the method he opposed would interfere with ventilation. Sir Henry said that an actual experiment in the mine might settle the point. Dr. Houldsworth said that every facility would he given by the owners for such an experiment. G. W. Poxon, of Darton, an overman, said that stone-dusting was always carried out and the statutory regulations were always observed in regard to shotfiring. G. Heaversidge described how the day before the explosion part of the mine where he was working became hot and the gas came. His lamp flickered and went out. The inquiry was adjourned until to-day (Friday).
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||