|
31st August 1935, Page: 56, Column: 2 Notes On Surveyors' ExaminationCentral Examiner's ReportThe question Papers set at this Examination have been published in pamphlet form and are obtainable (2s. net) from H.M. Stationery Office. The Central Examiner's report on the examination for mine surveyors' certificates held in May (1935) shows that, of the 112 candidates who presented themselves, 27 qualified in the written examination and 21 qualified in the practical examination, representing 18.8 of the total. Compared with the examination held in November last the results indicate a definite improvement, the percentage of candidates ultimately qualifying for a certificate being almost double what it then was. Even so, the Central Examiner says, the initial feeling of satisfaction at such marked improvement is to a certain extent tempered by the fact that the percentage of candidates qualifying is very little better than the average for the last three years. A careful study of the questions set will probably result in an endorsement of the view held by the Examiner, that the results might have been better. That view is well substantiated by the fact that the average marks earned by candidates who failed to qualify in the written examination only amounted to 30 per cent, of the possible total. The outstanding feature of the written examination was the work accomplished by candidates at the Newcastle centre. Apart from the fact that the percentage qualifying was considerably higher than at any other centre, the report says their work generally was definitely superior to anything accomplished elsewhere, the compulsory question in the afternoon paper being exceedingly well answered. Another feature was the fact that one excellent candidate in that centre obtained 87 per cent, of the possible marks — an achievement which has never been surpassed in recent years. Comments on Answers. Below we give the text of the questions set at the examination, each question being followed by the comment of the Examiner on the work generally of the candidates. The "comments" are in italics. (1) Morning Session: Compulsory Question. — The plan . . . . shows details taken from a Geological Survey map, and a general section showing the relative positions of the various seams whose outcrops are indicated thereon. The faults are known to "hade" at 450, Describe briefly the principal geological features of the area shown, and thereafter determine :— (a) The, amount and direction of throw of the faults A B and C D at the points B and D respectively; (b) the approximate depth at which a bore which is being put down to prove the measures, and has intersected the J.P. coal at the depth indicated on the plan, will intersect the index limestone. (12) Answers generally were disappointing. What was hoped for was a brief statement referring to the anticlinal and synclinal formation of the measures situated to the north and south respectively of the fault A B, and the uniform westerly dip of the measures to the south of the fault C D. Rarely were these details completely given, many candidates contenting themselves with lengthy descriptions of the surface configuration as indicated by the, contour lines, and with the nature of the alluvium. The estimated size and direction of throw of the two large faults was frequently mere guesswork, without details as to how the conclusions were arrived at. It was also surprising, to say the least of it, to find that out of 108 candidates who attempted the question only 4 realised that as the bore referred to must pass through the hade of the fault A B, the distance between the J.P. coal and the index limestone would be considerably less than shown in the general section of the strata. (2) A B and B C are two straight portions of railway which are to be connected by a curve of 25 chains radius The apex point is inaccessible. E and F are points on A B and B C respectively which are not intervisible, and the notes of a theodolite traverse from one to the other are as follow :— @ Calculate the apex angle, and determine the positions of the beginning and termination of the curve in relation to E and F respectively. (12) This question was generally attempted. Answers on the whole were not nearly so good as they ought to have been, only 25 correct or even approximately correct solutions being obtained — an unsatisfactory result to a straightforward and comparatively simple question. (3) A segment of a circle has a chord 6 ft. long, and the height at the mid-point of the chord is 1 ft. 6 in. Calculate the height of the segment at a distance of 20 inches from one end of the chord. (12) Candidates with a knowledge of the properties of a circle invariably made a satisfactory attempt at the solution of this question. The others rarely did so. (4) What is meant by the terms "topographical" and "cadastral" as applied to maps? What are the approximate limits in the scales to which topographical maps are drawn? To what meridian are the large-scale maps of your district plotted? Draw a diagram to a scale of 1 inch = 1 mile, showing the inter- relationship of the Ordnance Survey maps drawn to scales of 1/10560, 1/2500 and 1/1250 respectively. (8) Answers were only moderate, there frequently being confusion as to the meaning of the terms "topographical" and "cadastral," and only a few candidates had any idea as to the limit of the scales asked for. The latter half of the question was, however, generally well answered. (5) Give a brief description of an internal focusing telescope as applied to a modern type of theodolite or level. Illustrate your answer by a sketch showing the arrangement of the lenses. State the advantages of the above telescope over the "draw-tube" type. What is the one disadvantage, and how is it compensated for? (8) Answers generally were satisfactory, apart from the sketches, which with few exceptions were crude in the extreme. (1) Afternoon Session: Compulsory Question. — The co-ordinates of two shafts A and B and a point C in the Six-feet seam, based on the Ordnance Prime Meridian, are respectively as follow :— @ The notes of a theodolite traverse made between the shafts A and B in the Seven-feet seam are as follow :— @ It is proposed to form a new airway between the Six-feet and Seven-feet seams by driving a cross-measures drift from E to C. Calculate the length of the proposed drift and its azimuth in relation to the Ordnance meridian. (14) Answers generally were only fair. There was frequently confusion in correlating the surface and underground traverses, and arithmetical errors in working out the solution were surprisingly frequent. (2) A roadway, A B, advancing due east on the strike of a coal seam, encounters at B a downthrow fault, bearing at right-angles thereto, with a vertical displacement of 60 ft. and "hade" of 60 dog. Another roadway A C is advancing from the point A, and the co-ordinates and relative levels of the three points A, B and C are respectively as follow :— @ The direction of full dip on both sides of the fault is due north, the rate on the lower side being 2 inches per yard. Calculate the distance that A C must be produced to reach a point at which a roadway driven eastwards on the strike of the seam can pass through the line of the fault without dislocation. (12) Although a considerable number of correct answers were obtained, this comparatively simple question obviously puzzled the majority of candidates who attempted it. Once the line of full dip of the measures in the west side of the fault had been obtained the solution should have been easy, but many went completely astray in this part of the question. (3) It is proposed to drive a level cross-measures drift from the surface at a bearing N30°E to penetrate a hillside, which rises at an inclination of 1 in 1 in the direction N15°W. The drift, when completed, is to be 8 ft. in width, with a total height of 9 ft., and the upper portion is to be a semi-circular arch of 4-ft. radius. Draw a plan of the drift-mouth to a scale of assuming that the material does not require to be supported. (12) This question was not often attempted, and while several correct answers were obtained there were others which indicated a lack of proper understanding of what was required. (4) A seam of coal which dips 36° in the direction N45°W is cut through by a borehole which dips 76° in the direction N20°W. The thickness of the coal seam as measured in the core extracted from the bore-hole is 12 ft. 3 in. What is its true thickness? (10) Approximately one-half of the answers were correct. Many of the others indicated an entire absence of knowledge of the method of solution. (5) Calculate the volume contained between three successive sections of a railway cutting 50 ft. apart. The width at formation level is 10 ft., the side slopes are one vertical to two horizontal, and the heights at the top of the slopes, in feet above formation level, are as follow :— @ There were a large number of surprisingly poor answers. Generally the method of determining the volume was correctly understood, but the methods adopted in calculating the cross-sectional areas were frequently absurd and led to considerable inaccuracy. (6) The undernoted details appear in Volume 1 of the Catalogue of Plans of Abandoned Mines published by H.M. Stationery Office In 1928:— @ State briefly what the details refer to, and from them draw a rough sketch showing the situation of the mine workings. (8) Answers generally showed a fair knowledge of the details asked for.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||