Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

20th July 1935, Page: 10, Column: 1

Modern Mining And Coal Cleaning

Abstracts from paper on "The Response of Coal Cleaning Practice to the Demands of Modern Mining," read on 11th July before the Newcastle meeting of the Institution of Mining Engineers.

By George Raw, B.Sc., and F. F. Ridley, B.Sc.

The increase in the percentage of coal mechanically cleaned hears a close relationship to the increase in the proportion of coal mechanically mined, for the reason that, while clean or discriminative mining is possible with manual production, this discriminative factor is discounted by the automatic operation of machinery.

Mechanisation was first applied to relatively clean seams and its effect was to introduce small quantities of extra dirt" into the coal, particularly in the small sizes caused hy contact of the machines with the roof or floor. The introduction of mechanisation, however, into inferior seams, occurring with interstratified hands of higher ash material, has resulted in aggravation of the ash difficulty. As considerable proportions of the impurities resulting from such hands are of intermediate specific gravity and ash-content, referred to as middlings, the corrective treatments also become more difficult. It is thus evident that reduced working-costs following mechanisation will tend to result in more impurities in the coal produced, and it is clear that in these circumstances no investigation of the relative merits of mining methods can lead to accurate ultimate conclusions unless it is made in conjunction with a consideration of the economic and technical probabilities of cleaning.

Generally speaking, the evidence of data shows that the index of discriminative production falls with the extent of mechanisation introduced. A colliery management is therefore faced, as it considers the mechanised mining of any seams of coal, with the dual consideration — (1) of the cost of producing the raw material consisting of coal and extraneous matter by the method chosen; (2) the cost of eliminating the extraneous portion of the raw material so produced. These two factors are embodied in the over-all cost of mining and preparing the commodity for the market where the cost divisor is the net disposable quantity produced. Though it may sound elementary to say so, the mining cost of producing the raw material, if considered alone, may prove disastrously misleading.

Methods of Cleaning.

For the purpose of examining the relative features of different treatments the main cleaning processes may be grouped broadly under three headings :— (1) Normal wet washing; (2) Dry Cleaning; (3) True gravity separation, using a dense medium.

Normal Wet Washing. — The normal methods of wet washing, to a certain extent, cover a common field of utility, but different systems have fields in which they are most adaptable, particularly in view of the increasing number of difficult and specialised treatments required.

Wet washing is generally applicable to the treatment of coal up to 4 or 5 in. in size, and comes into immediate consideration for the treatment of coal which comes out of the mine in a condition too wet for dry treatment, and also for coals in which it is permissible or desirable to have a proportion of moisture. The resulting clean coal will have a free moisture-content varying in the sizes as classified from about 3 per cent. in the largest to 8-15 per cent. in the smalls, according to whether slurry is included or not.

The suitability of wet-washing methods as regards cleaning results depends upon the ash-content required in the clean coal and the washability curve of the coal. Normal wet-washing machines are all capable of efficiently rejecting impurities heavier than 1.6 sp. gr. from coal of under 1.35 sp. gr., but within this density range have a reduced discriminative ability. When there is an appreciable proportion of material between these specific gravities present in the raw coal, this imposes a limit to the possible clean coal ash-content and to the yield of clean coal produced.

Jig Washing. — This system, of which the Baum is the main type, has had the widest application in England in the past, and also covers the main field of German wet washing. Its advantages lie in simplicity of operation, compactness of arrangement, and an almost automatic consistency of results for given conditions.

In Baum jig washing the coal is treated without pre-sizing and any classification required follows washing. Coal of 3 or 4 in. to zero can he treated in one wash-box, but when the coal is of difficult character containing appreciable quantities of middlings, especially in the finer sizes, the small coal below about in. may need to he rewashed in a second wash-box. Multiple-compartment jig boxes also provide the opportunity of separately adjusting the conditions to give some selective treatment of different fractions. These methods enable better separation to be made in difficult coals containing middlings.

Improvements in the operation of jig wash-boxes, particularly in regard to treatment of middlings, have been made by the introduction of stirring devices which make the bed more sensitive to stratification by keeping it free and preventing entanglement. Also automatic refuse discharges controlled by floats operating in the bed, enable variations in the dirt-content to be dealt with more accurately.

Jig washing is able to show to its best advantage when treating coals of easy or average washability characteristics, which are not liable to vary greatly in character, while if the finest sizes are very dirty, auxiliary equipment may be necessary for their treatment.

Trough Washing. — The main features of trough systems are the absence of moving parts, the automatic nature of the separation, and the practice of rewashing certain fractions. The system is particularly adapted to the treatment of coals having a high content of middlings, and is efficient in the cleaning of the finer sizes, as a very accurate density stratification is obtained in the troughs. The main differences between trough systems lie in the methods of separating the materials which have been stratified in the troughs, these comprising various designs of controlled outlets for the discharge of the heavier fractions and upward current separating devices. The practice of rewashing one or both of the fractions resulting from the primary separation is always followed. Usually a certain quantity of pure coal or pure shale is first obtained, and the remaining heavier or lighter fraction passes to further troughs for rewashing. The rewashing can be repeated and the conditions varied in different troughs to a considerable extent according to the character of the coal. The separation is thus progressive as regards rewashing of particular density fractions, and the middlings of specific gravity close to that at which separation is desired receive the most prolonged treatment. As the washing troughs are inexpensive units in themselves a considerable degree of rewashing of the middlings fractions is practicable.

Dry Cleaning. — This method is of comparatively recent development. Pneumatic methods comprise the only widely applied dry systems applicable to the treatment of all the small coal. The prime considerations in regard to dry cleaning are the moisture contents of the raw and clean products. Dry cleaning cannot come into consideration if a coal is mined in too wet a condition for its efficient operation.

Pneumatic methods are generally applicable to coal up to 2 or 2½ in. in size, and above this size either hand-picking or wet washing is usually adopted. The combination of hand-picking for coal above 4 in., wet washing from 4 to 1 in. or 2 in., with dry cleaning for the smalls, has been applied in a number of installations. The cleaning results obtainable by dry cleaning must, like wet washing, depend upon the washability characteristic of the coal.

Pneumatic systems, which have been widely adopted in this country, follow two main methods, which may be discriminated between as the "dynamic" and the "static," in reference to their respective modes of pneumatic operation. The dynamic method, of which the Birtley system is the best-known example, operates by the selective stratifying effects of air-currents rising through the layer of coal on a vibrating table. The coal is presized within limits depending upon the character of the coal, each grade being separately treated on individual tables.

The static method of the Static Dry-washer System operates on unsized coal. In this system air-current effects are substantially eliminated, the compressive properties of air being used to achieve a balance between a fluctuating or pulsating air pressure and the closely-packed bed of coal on a vibratory table. The effect produced is a condition of fluidity in the bed, which allows the denser material to sink by displacement, thereby obtaining stratification.

Gravity Separation. — The essential feature of dense medium or true gravity separation is that the separation takes place by simple displacement in a medium of such specific gravity that the portion required to be recovered as clean coal is floated, while the refuse sinks.

Gravity separation is likely to be applied more particularly to coals which are intended for the production of special fuels, such as high-grade and low-temperature coke, and for hydrogenation where a super-clean coal is essential. It also has a field in the treatment of coals which, although not particularly difficult to clean, have such a high inherent ash that it is necessary to eliminate entirely all impurities to obtain a quality comparable with less accurately cleaned coals of lower inherent ash.

Owing to the nature of the float-and-sink separation, dense medium-gravity processes are applicable to a larger range of sizes, and coal up to 6 or 8 in. can be treated. This almost eliminates hand-picking, and shows an important further application of this method. It is necessary, however, to extract the dust or a coarser grade of fines before washing. The combination of gravity separation for the coal 6 or 8 in. to 1/8 or 1/16 in., with dry cleaning of the fines, is an attractive preparation scheme of the future, as it enables nearly the whole output to be treated and the lowest ash-contents to be obtained without slurry or moisture difficulties.

The most recent development in true gravity separation is the De Vooys process. In this process it has been attempted to combine the technical perfection of the heavy-solution method with the low cost of the suspension method. The heavy medium consists of a suspension of finely-ground barytes and clay in water for the separating bath. It is found that barytes, having a specific gravity of 42, when ground through 200 mesh and mixed with water and a proportion of clay, which normally results from disintegration of the shale, forms a practically stable suspension and therefore equivalent in effect to a solution. This stable suspension is maintainable over a considerable range of densities which are useful in coal-washing and may be given approximately as 1.25-1.65 according to the proportion of solids in the suspension. The stability of the suspension permits of a static float-and-sink separation being made which yields a practically perfect separation at any gravity, irrespective of the characteristic of the coal.

A property of this heavy medium is that, when diluted with water, there is a relatively rapid settlement to nearly its original specific gravity, leaving clear water above. This permits of thickening and recovery of the heavy medium and enables the process to operate economically. The heavy medium is readily removed from the products by spraying with water and the resulting diluted medium is then thickened by sedimentation and used again in the separating bath. The clarified water resulting from the thickening is used again for spraying the products, the process thus operating in closed circuit except for losses of liquid. In practice, the barytes loss amounts to two to three pounds per ton of coal treated which permits of an over-all working-cost little different from normal wet-washing systems.

A modification of this process is a wash-box in which it is possible to make three products-clean coal, middlings, and shale.

Dust Extraction.

Do-dusting of coal before washing has become very general practice and has considerably helped towards the general improvement of the washing process by the reduction of slurry troubles. Its object is to remove as much as possible of the fine slurry forming fraction from the raw coal before it is wetted and thereby keep it Out of the washing system. De-dusting may be carried out by fine screening or by air-currents, but these do not cover quite the same field. Screening usually becomes impracticable below about 1/16 in., and pneumatic de-dusting commences where a screening finishes. The pneumatic method is now the most general and is that usually referred to as de-dusting. Pneumatic systems are capable of extracting fractions below about 1/100 in., which is the material most responsible for slurry formation, but they can be adjusted to take out coarser fractions, up to about 1/16 in., from the raw coal if necessary. The efficiency of de-dusting is important as a partial dust extraction will seldom do more than reduce the amount of slurry formed and may give little real benefit in operation.

The circumstances in which de-dusting is not suitable are mainly when there is an excessive moisture in the raw coal and when the shale is of such a character that it is subject to serious disintegration in washing. In some cases de-dusting will not confer sufficient benefit. in slurry reduction and in these cases methods of slurry treatment become necessary.

Slurry Recovery and Flocculation.

This subject is concerned with another means of attacking the same problem which de-dusting aims at solving, namely, the prevention of accumulation of solids in the wash water and elimination of nuisance due to the running to waste of large and dirty effluents. While de-dustsing attempts a solution by preventing the slurry-forming constituents from entering the wash water, this method aims at separating the solids from the water after slurry has been formed.

Before adopting a given treatment the slurry should always be submitted to proper examination to enable the best treatment to be applied. Various slurries react differently in regard to the reagent and quantity used, while the character of the water supplied to the washery affects the treatment.

There are two main applications of the treatment, namely, the treatment of the whole of the washing water and, alternatively, the treatment of only a portion of the circulating water which is withdrawn from the circuit at a suitable point. Both methods permit of closed-cycle working of the washing water.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Raw, George      Whos Who Page
Ridley, F. F.      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print