6th July 1935, Page: 401, Column: 1
Miners' Welfare Fund
Committee's 1934 Report
Proceeds of Levy.
The thirteenth annual Report of the Miners' Welfare Fund
(1934) lies been issued, the price of the Report, which is issued
through H.M. Stationery Office, being 1s. 6d. It will be recalled
that the Mining Industry (Welfare Fund) Act of 1934 reduced
the amount of the levy from the year 1932 on the output of coal
from 1d. to ½d. per ton, and required the Committee to make
appropriations in 1934 and succeeding years from the proceeds
of the reduced levy before crediting the four-fifths due to the
District Fund, as follow: (a) Such sum as will, together with the
proceeds of the royalties welfare levy for each year, amount to
£375,000, which is to be applied to providing pithead baths;
and (b) £20,000, which is to be applied to research into methods
of improving the health and safety of workers in or about coal
mines.
Last year the total receipts of the output levy were £416,767,
and they were appropriated thus : (1) Baths Fund, £182,676
(2) Research, £20,000; (3) Districts and General Funds, £214,091.
the latter, the four-fifths credited to the Districts Fund
amounted to £171,273, to which was added £38,823 for interest
earned by balances standing to the credit of some districts. The
total sum available for the Districts Fund was thus £210,096,
or 31 per cent. of the amount available in 1932 (£674,944), the
last year of the 1d. levy.
Since its institution in 1920 the total receipts of the Welfare
Fund have amounted to £14,510,530, including £11,731,656 from
the output levy, £1,554,000 from the royalties levy and £1,224,874
from interest on balances. Grants made to the end of last year
amounted to £13,941,914, the net balance of receipts over grants
being £568,616. The grants made to the several purposes of the
Fund in the fourteen years were Recreation, £4,963,159 ; Pit
Welfare, £3,454,463; Health, £3,246,254; Education,
£1,166,117;
Research, £846,642 ; Miscellaneous, £53,963.
Children's Playgrounds.
The recreation grants in 1934 amounted to £162,600, more than
half of which was devoted to recreation grounds, including
pavilions for players. Twenty new grounds were provided, and
there were numerous additions and improvements to grounds
that had already been started. The grants for children's playgrounds
amounted to 43 per cent, of the total sum allocated for
recreational purposes, the number of schemes being 35, of which
15 were entirely new. Congratulating the District and Local
Committees upon the efforts being made the Welfare Committee
express the hope that increased attention will be given to the
development of schemes for the children and youth of the mining
communities, to help them in body, mind and character to become
useful citizens. As Commander Coote says: "We ought no
longer to leave to chance the recreation of youth, a period at
which it probably has more effect on the moulding of character
than during those which either precede or follow it."
Pithead Baths.
As the result of eight years' working the Baths Fund receipts
amounted to £2,939,222, the allocations £2,975,341, and payments
£2,391,565, so that there was a balance of receipts over payments
of £547,657, which will, of course, be paid away during the progress
of building contracts covered by the allocations made. The
Baths Fund has also been financed out of the Districts Fund,
the grand total for pit welfare purposes being £3,454,463.
Last year 27 baths were completed, with accommodation for
35,702 men and 56 women, bringing the total up to 154 baths
for 200,674 men and 262 women. In addition there were 32 other
installations, accommodating 24,643 men, which have been built
by colliery companies or colliery welfare committees mostly before
the Miners' Welfare Committee assumed this function. Altogether,
therefore, there were at the end of 1934 installations to the number
of 186 with accommodation for 225,317 men and 262 women.
The number of men for whom provision has not yet been made
is in the neighbourhood of half a million, but of these some are
at collieries which are either too uncertain as to their future or
too small to be regarded as candidates for baths, and in the present
situation of the coal mining industry the Welfare Committee say
it is impossible to estimate with accuracy bow many collieries
and men have yet to be provided for. There has been a progressive
improvement in the percentage of men using the baths
provided. The average proportion in 1931 was 83 per cent.;
rising to between 85 and 89 per cent. last year. Particulars were
received from 112 installations showing a net credit balance of
£17,934 after meeting the year's expenses for repairs and renewals,
but before making any transfer to reserve for that purpose. Twenty
of the installations showed a debit balance, some of these having
suffered from reduced employment at the colliery; at some the
colliery owners did not assist the baths to the extent that most
owners do; and at some the men's contribution was unusually low.
The average consumption of water at the baths for which figures
were received in 1934 was 9½ gallons per bather per day. At
installations heated and ventilated by the plenum system driven
by electricity, the average consumption per bather per year was
10.5 cwt. of coal (or alternatively 7,269 lb. of steam from colliery
boilers), and 53 units of electricity. At installations heated by
steam pipes and radiators the average consumption per bather
per year was 11.9 cwt. of coal (or alternatively 7,993 lb. of steam
from colliery boilers), and 14.1 units of electricity.
The average cost of the installations tendered for during 1934
was £11 16s. per person accommodated, which is slightly less
than that of the installations tendered for prior to 1934, namely,
£11 17s. 6d. The Committee control the cost by requiring the
architects to work to a tolerably rigid scale of accommodation
and the narrow limits of a standard specification, which is reviewed
from time to time. The cost is made up of two components
(a) The shell or carcase of the building; (b) The internal fittings
and equipment, which are largely determined by scale according
to the number of users. Under this bead are included the heating,
hot water and electrical installations, water supply, shower
cubicles, sanitary fittings, lockers, drainage and sanitation.
On the average about 56 per cent, of the total cost is attributable
to (b), that is, of the average cost of £11 17s. per person nearly
£6 13s. was attributable to (b) and £5 4s. to (a). The cost of
the building carcase ranges between 5d. and 6d. per cubic foot,
which is a low rate for buildings of this type.
Small Collieries' Case.
Generally speaking, the cost per person tends to increase as
the size of the installation decreases, but the Welfare Committee
do not feel justified in allowing the cost to rise unduly. With
the demand for baths as strong and widespread as it is at present,
they feel impelled, generally speaking, to expend the money
available so that it will provide as many men as possible with the
accommodation.
There are some small collieries where the need for baths is
great, perhaps greater than at some of the larger collieries, having
regard both to the working conditions and to the distance travelled
by the workers to their homes. But if small collieries are to be
provided with baths the accommodation must be modified in
some way so that the cost is not excessive. The burden of maintenance
at a small installation is an additional reason for some
alteration of the arrangements appropriate to. a large installation.
They mentioned last year that they were building an experimental
installation of modified design at a small colliery at
Toftshaw Moor in West Yorkshire, with accommodation for 120
(subsequently increased to 126). This installation, which was
opened in April, 1934, has proved a great success. The same
degree of privacy is not asked for in small installations as in some
large ones. Possibly this is because the former tends to assume
the character of a club rather than a public institution, a closer
fellowship existing amongst the smaller number of men. At any
rate, this new departure has been completely successful and is
reported to be quicker and cleaner for the users, while it is also
easier for the attendant to keep the place clean. These baths
are operated economically by one attendant working for three
short periods daily, the work required having been further reduced
by fitting the boiler with an automatic self-stoking appliance.
But this of course added to the capital cost, which turned out to
be £19 4s. per head.
Though substantially less than that or an installation on normal
lines, the cost is still too high in comparison with that of larger
baths. It would hays been nearly £3 per head less if it bad been
practicable for steam to have been supplied from colliery boilers.
That obviously will always be an important consideration, but
apart from that it seemed desirable to make a further examination
into the costs of providing small installations.
The normal type of structure is economical considering its
durability. If cheaper materials were used, the structure would
cost more to keep in good condition, and the smaller installations
are certainly not able to set aside larger reserves for that purpose.
Further economy in building costs must therefore be sought in
some further alteration of the accommodation. While the Committee
would not suggest dispensing with lockers for the home
clothes, it would seem satisfactory at small baths for the pit
clothes to be spread on open hooks or racks.
General Pithead Improvements.
In their Report for 1933 the Welfare Committee mentioned
that it is their aim when building pithead baths to achieve thereby
some general improvement of the pithead amenities. They are
glad to be able to report that, not only has there been a growing
response by colliery companies to the suggestions of their architects
in this direction, but proposals for concurrent developments
arranged in harmony with the baths have also been originated
by colliery officials. Sometimes suggestions have been adopted
at once, and sometimes the Committee have been asked to allow
for them in their plans so that they can be carried through at a
later date. In particular, they are pleased to report co-operation,
in works of varying degrees of importance, with Messrs. Manvers
Main Collieries, Ltd., Warwickshire Coal Co., Ltd., Wigan Coal
Corporation, Ltd., Manchester Collieries, Ltd., Airedale Collieries,
Ltd., United Collieries, Ltd., and Fife Coal Co., Ltd.
Well-arranged and well-kept surface buildings, apart from their
effect on operating efficiency, arouse a psychological response in
the miner resulting from improved environment at the place of
work. The work appears less burdensome and some improvement
in the life's occupation of the miner is effected.
During the past decade the intensification of the demand for
more hygienic conditions has resulted in a new approach to the
problems of design and construction and in the employment of
new materials. This advance is reflected in some of the work
of the architects, which has attracted occasional criticism because
the new or unusual is apt to convey an impression of expensiveness
or extravagance. But the modern trend is towards obtaining
effect by line and proportion instead of ornament, towards
simplicity of design that makes for inexpensiveness. Good
design is not a luxury either in a building or in a fitting.
Bright end cleanly interior decorations are provided in baths
and canteens in order to strike the note of brightness, cheerfulness
and cleanliness in the users-an inestimable benefit to men just
raised from the underground gloom. But bright-coloured paint
and tiled surfaces are unusual and unexpected at the pithead,
and it is not surprising perhaps that the first thought is of undue
finish and expense. This erroneous impression quickly changes
to appreciation and enthusiasm upon further consideration, but
it can be harmful to the work if repeated by the less thoughtful.
Bright and attractive colours are no more expensive than dull
colours, and in a place which has to stand up to such exacting
service as a baths installation, good and durable surfaces and.
fittings are needed in order to reduce the burden of maintenance.
Canteens.
The Act of 1934, which stabilised the revenue of the Baths
Fund at £375,000 a year, empowered the Welfare Committee
to provide out of that revenue such accommodation and facilities
as they think can be conveniently and properly combined with
pithead baths. Under this power they decided in future to
provide baths installations with canteens at the cost of the Baths
Fund where they are satisfied that a canteen is required, and is
likely to be used adequately.
As the new financial basis of the Baths Fund only operated
from 1934, that Fund cannot take over the responsibility for
canteens at installations provided from allocations made before
1934. The provision of canteens in those cases must continue
to be the responsibility of the District Funds, and can only be
undertaken upon the recommendation of the District Committees.
The sums allocated from the District Funds for canteens up
to the end of 1934 (at baths provided before 1934) amounted to
£63,517 for 67 canteens. In addition, some years ago two canteens
were provided out of allocations for baths from the Northumberland
District Fund and two experimental canteens were built
independently of baths out of grants amounting to £1,623 from
the General Fund.
During 1934 grants for canteens were made out of the Baths
Fund for 16 new baths installations of a total amount of £15,446.
The total number of canteens, therefore, for which grants had
been allocated from the Welfare Fund up to the end of 1934 was
87. It is interesting to note that provision for a canteen was
included in all but five of the grants from the Baths Fund for
new baths installations during 1934.
Of the 35 canteens in respect of which accounts came to baud
in 1934, all but four showed a profit on the year's working. The
four losses amounted together to only £85. The profits shown
by the other 31 canteens ranged up to £496, and amounted to
£4,276 in total or £138 per canteen, after providing for the wages
of the canteen staff where distinct from the baths staff. The
service of the canteen was in some instances extended to include
the sale of tools, boots, and other articles of clothing. The annual
turnover was 29s. 8d. per bather on the average. It is evident
from these results that the canteens provided were almost always
appreciated by the workers, and that they usually formed a
useful source of assistance towards the maintenance of the baths
tending to relieve the workers' weekly levy. On this evidence,
and on the results of investigations with regard to each baths
installation started in 1934, the Committee feel justified in their
decision to provide canteens from the Baths Fund in future.
Health.
Considerable sums have been allocated from the District Funds
upon the recommendation of the District Committees for purposes
connected with the health of mine workers and their dependants.
The total up to the end of 1934 was £3,246,254, which is 36 per
cent, of the whole of the allocations made from those Funds.
In 1934 itself the allocations for health purposes amounted to
£88,818, 30 per cent, of the total allocations for the year.
The purposes of the grants were as follows :—
Some districts, in addition to or instead of providing Convalescent
Homes themselves, have purchased tickets of admission to other
Homes or have established Endowment Funds for that purpose.
The total sum allocated under this head up to the end of 1934
(including certain small amounts for capital expenditure at Homes
not provided from the Welfare Fund) was £600,344, of which
£56,950 was allocated in 1934.
Education.
One of the first things which the Miners' Welfare Committee
did on taking up its duties in 1921 was to seek advice as to the
best way of utilising a proportion of the resources of the Fund for
promoting mining education. After carefully studying the report
made by a sub-committee of the University Grants Committee
which was set up specially to consider this problem, they decided
to set aside a sum of £500,000 from the General Fund to provide
buildings and equipment for senior, advanced and university
instruction in mining. This sum was later increased to £750,000,
and finally to £790,000, of which £773,420 had been allocated at
the end of 1934. In addition, £20,780 has been granted for
similar purposes from the District Funds.
In 1921 the facilities for mining instruction in this country
were very far from satisfactory. Good work was being done here
and there, and there were a few reasonably well-equipped centres
of instruction, but most of them were ill-adapted for their work,
and there was not a single centre where both accommodation and
equipment were entirely adequate; in many areas there was
provision for nothing but the most elementary forms of mining
instruction, or there was no provision at all.
The aim the Welfare Committee set themselves was that every
area should have a series of centres where preliminary instruction
in mining would be given; then a number of senior centres for
students who successfully pass through the preliminary courses;
beyond these, advanced centres for those who complete the senior
courses, and finally, at the universities in the coalfields, properly
equipped mining departments for students who are able to carry
their mining education to the highest level. They considered
that the local education authorities should themselves undertake
the provision of the preliminary centres, but they offered to giant
from the Miners' Welfare Fund the cost or part of the cost of such
new buildings or equipment as might be necessary for senior,
advanced and university instruction.
Nearly all the education authorities have taken full advantage
of the offer, although it involved their having to undertake the
future upkeep of the new instruction centres, and at the present
time there is only about £16,000 out of the allotted sum of
£790,000
which has not been granted or promised for one or another form
of facilities for mining education. Out of these grants 46 new
senior or advanced centres have been wholly or partly provided,
and 14 existing senior or advanced centres extended or re-equipped,
while 14 others are under construction or are planned, and every
university situated in the coalfields — seven altogether — has had
a grant given or promised of a substantial sum for its mining
department. This country now has what is probably the most
ample and widespread provision for mining instruction of any
coal-producing country in the world.
Scholarships and Grants to Students.
Miners' Welfare National Scholarships. — The Scholarship
Scheme was established in 1926 by means of an endowment grant
of £150,000 from the General Fund of the Miners' Welfare Fund,
and in 1930 this sum was increased to £160,000 by another grant
from the same source. In addition, sums aggregating £14,055
have been capitalised under the terms of the Trust Deed, making
the total endowment £174,055. The income from the Endowment
Fund in 1934 amounted to about £8,000, and approximately
97 per cent, was disbursed in scholarships. The number of
applicants in 1934 was 692, 82 per cent, being children of mine
workers, and 15 scholarships were awarded.
Scholarships under this scheme are only tenable for internal
degree courses at a university or constituent college of a university,
but there is otherwise no restriction as to the course of study
chosen. Twenty-one scholars completed their scholarships in
1934, including three who were doing research work. Of the other
eighteen scholars, three failed in one subject, but all were likely
to complete their degrees successfully by retaking the examination
in 1935. The total number of scholarships awarded during the
eight years in which the Scheme has been in operation is 106,
of which 50 were for mine workers and 56 for children of mine
workers. Thirty-eight scholarships were being maintained at
the end of 1934.
Other Grants to Students. — Besides the National Scholarships,
grants to the total value of £22,320 had up to the end of 1934
been made direct to students, £1,541 had been granted for disbursement
to students by special committees subject to approved
conditions and £132,935 had been invested in trust funds whose
objects are wholly or mainly to make grants to students. The
total allocated from the Welfare Fond under this head, therefore,
was £1 56,796. These figures include grants from the General
Fund as well as the District Funds.
The number of students who benefited from the £22,320 granted
direct was 430, so that the average amount of grant was £52, The
recipients fall into two distinct categories in respect of the method
of their selection. The larger category are those selected by the
District Committees ; these grants are defrayed entirely from
the District Funds. The number of recipients up to the end of
1934 was 281, and the total value of their grants was £15,260.
Scholarship Scheme for Part-time Students of Mining. — Since
the Welfare Committee commenced making grants for mining
schools there has been a considerable development in the provision
of mining classes, the number and quality of the instructors
and the type of the instruction. The majority of the classes are
held in the evening, however, a time when the student who has
been working during the day, and is therefore physically tired,
is not best able to direct the whole of his faculties to study. It
would obviously be an advantage to such students if they could
devote a whole day a week to the classes.
Such an arrangement would be impossible for all the students
attending the numerous preliminary, senior and advanced courses;
but it would be especially valuable to advanced students, and the
Committee are hopeful that employers may be able to release
these for a day a week and that part-time day classes may be
provided for them. To encourage this, the Committee some time
ago proposed to form an endowment fund, the income of which
would be applied to providing scholarships for students taking
part-time advanced day courses in mining at approved institutions.
The proposal was deferred pending the preparation of a definite
scheme and the accumulation of sufficient money in the General
Fund, but in 1934 they made a grant of £75,000 from the General
Fund to endow a scheme worked out for them by the Board of
Education and the Scottish Education Department. Detailed
regulations have not yet been prepared but it is hoped to be able
to award about 30 scholarships each year, tenable for four years,
of an average value of £20 a year, which should be sufficient to
cover the cost of fees, books, instruments and travelling expenses,
and perhaps to provide some small amount of compensation for
loss of wages. The Committee hope that the establishment of
these scholarships will not only enable students to take advantage
of the existing part-time day courses, but will encourage local
education authorities to provide fresh courses of this nature.
Lectures, Non-vocational. —The grants made for this purpose
in 1934 amounted to £1,967, £1,645 being from District Funds
and £322 from the General Fund, which contributed one-fifth
of the grants for the two principal schemes. The total up to the
end of 1934 was £51,718, namely £42,165 from District Funds
and £9,553 from the General Fund.
Safety Instruction. — The Committee are glad to learn of continued
progress in the movement in the mining industry for
organising, in co-operation with the local education authorities,
courses of instruction for the collective training of colliery boys
in matters of safety. The instruction is usually given by a
colliery official either at a colliery or at a school. At the end of
these courses there is an oral examination in which representatives
of the colliery owners and the workmen take part, and usually
safety badges are awarded to those boys — a large majority — who
satisfy the examiners.
The movement started in Yorkshire three years ago, and has
since spread to all parts of the country. The cost of providing
instructors and facilities for instruction is undertaken by the
local education authorities ; but there are certain expenses which
cannot be borne by them; these are defrayed by contributions
from the colliery companies or grants from the District Funds.
Some of the classes receive no assistance from the Welfare Fund.
Where grants have been made they have been chiefly to provide
badges.
Research.
Research being one of the objects of the Welfare Fund under
the provisions of the Mining Industry Act, 1920, the Committee
make a grant out of the General Fund each year to be expended
by the Safety in Mines Research Board on researches into matters
affecting the safety and health of mine workers and in disseminating
information regarding the application of the results of the, researches
to mining practice. Up to the end of 1934 these grants
have amounted altogether to £846,642, but this includes £259,528
which was capitalised as an Endowment Fund of which the
income is applied towards the cost of the Board's work.
The efforts of the Board and the district investigators to devise
and promote the use of protective equipment, e.g., hard hats,
safety boots, goggles, gloves, etc., are a promising means of
preventing accidents.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Coote, B. T., Commander | | | |