22nd June 1935, Page: 394, Column: 1
Deterioration Of Haulage Ropes
As part of the research programme of the Wire Ropes Research
Committee of the Safety in Mines Research Board, an investigation
has been made into the causes of failure of twenty-three haulage
ropes (used for hauling men) broken in service at collieries. Full
particulars of the ropes and their conditions of service were collected
and samples from the broken ropes thoroughly examined and tested.
S.M.R.B. Paper No. 92 (H.M. Stationery Office, is. net.) summarises
the results of such an examination of the causes of failure of a
number of ropes and indicates the relative importance of the various
factors which caused the deterioration of the ropes.
In their introduction Professor S. M. Dixon and
Dr. M. A. Rogan say the deterioration of haulage ropes in service may be
attributed to three factors, war, corrosion and fatigue. It is
difficult, however, to classify the various failures under these
headings because as a rule they are the result of the combined
operation of several forms of deterioration. Haulage ropes are
particularly susceptible to external wear through rubbing against
the floor, sides or roof of the roadway, through the use of several
layers of rope on the drum and through the action of clips or lashing
chains on endless rope haulages. If the roadway is wet, corrosion
of the worn surfaces will accelerate the deterioration on account
of the abrasive action of the corrosion products on the various
surfaces which rub together as the rope is bent over drum and
pulleys. Again, if a rope is undergoing internal corrosion this
will be accelerated by wear between the wires as the rope is bent.
Wear and corrosion acting together tend to produce rapid
deterioration, resulting in serious reduction in the cross-sectional
area of the wires. When the section of the wires is reduced
sufficiently to cause the stress on them to exceed the fatigue limit
deterioration by fatigue will begin.
Of the ropes examined twenty-one were in use on main rope
haulage systems where the haulage roads were inclined up to a
maximum of 60°. The other two were the main ropes on main-and-tail
haulage systems. Deterioration was found in all the ropes.
The predominant type of deterioration associated with nine of the
failures was wear, with ten corrosion, and four were classed as
capel failures.
The Authors say the selection of a rope for use on a given haulage
depends on the system of haulage in use and on the working conditions,
such as gradient, size of engine, drum or driving pulley,
and the amount of moisture on the road. The various points
they direct attention to divide into three groups: (a) the strength
of the rope to be used; (b) the type of rope (c) the construction
of the rope.
The strength of the rope to be used is obtained by multiplying
the calculated maximum tension by a factor of safety; this gives
the breaking strength of the rope required, the maximum tension
being obtained from a consideration of the heaviest load which
may be hauled by the rope, due allowance being made for the inclination,
friction and the weight of the rope itself. It is impossible
to lay down a standard factor of safety for haulage ropes.
The Authors' experience indicates that on main rope haulages no
rope should be allowed to remain in service after the static factor
of safety has fallen below 6. When the rope is new the factor of
safety should, in general, be considerably more. A somewhat
lower factor of safety may be used on slow speed endless rope
haulages.
As to the type of rope external wear is one of the most serious
causes of deterioration of haulage ropes, and it is desirable to
choose a type which is as resistant to wear as possible. The view
is expressed that where external wear is the most serious form of
deterioration a flattened strand rope should give better results
than a round strand rope.
The strength of a flattened strand rope of a given diameter
is usually greater than that of a round strand rope because a
flattened strand rope, owing to its formation, contains a greater
cross-sectional area of steel. Hence for a given strength, the
flattened strand rope will be smaller, and will contain somewhat
smaller wires than a round strand rope. Under certain circumstances
the reduction in diameter of the wires may be a grave drawback,
and the flattened strand rope may give less satisfactory
service. Splicing is more difficult.
Under the heading (c) the type of steel to be used in the wires,
the make-up of the strands, the core, and the lubrication of the
rope during manufacture are considered. The properties of the
materials and the methods of manufacture should be in accordance
with the relevant British Standards Specifications.
Installation of Haulage Ropes.
Extracts from the section dealing with the installation of haulage
ropes are reproduced as follows :—
It is desirable that the haulage engine should be smooth running
and capable of starting up gradually so as to avoid jerking the rope.
The brakes should be smooth in action for the same reason. The
diameter of the drum and pulleys should be as large as possible,
and should be proportioned to the size of the wires in the rope.
Where a number of pulleys or rollers are used in a group to lead the
rope round a curve so that the angle which the rope bends over
each pulley is small, the diameter of the pulleys may be reduced.
The haulage road or incline should be provided with rollers
wherever the rope would otherwise be likely to rub on the floor,
roof, or sides. In no case should the rope be allowed to rub against
hard rock, or rails or other fixed metal objects. Care must be
taken that pulleys and rollers are so mounted that no gaps are left
between the roller and casing in which the rope may become wedged.
All pulleys and rollers should run freely and must be provided
with reliable means of lubrication. Rollers in which grooves have
been cut by the rope should be replaced at once.
The grooves of pulleys should be smoothly finished to a radius
slightly in excess of the radius of the rope. The pulley grooves
should be carefully inspected at intervals, and, before a new rope is
fitted, should be trued up if reduced below the proper size.
Every effort should be made to keep the haulage rope dry to
reduce the risk of damage to the rope by corrosion. If water is
unavoidably present it should be led to a drain on one side of the
road, and not allowed to run where the rope may dip into it.
A wire rope must be handled in such a way that it is not allowed
to untwist, and great care must be taken to avoid kinking.
When the rope is put to work it is likely to he lively, and special
care should be taken that kinking does not occur when the rope
is allowed to go slack.
Maintenance of Haulage Ropes.
Space is devoted in Paper No. 92 to the maintenance of haulage
ropes, and some of the points to which attention is directed by the
Authors may be briefly noted, as below:
Main ropes used on inclines from the surface can be treated as
follows. The rope should be wound very slowly on to the drum,
the surface being cleaned as it enters the engine house ; cleaning
should be done with wire brushes without using any solvent such
as petrol or paraffin. No solvent (petrol or paraffin) should be
used on the rope because experience has shown that the solvent
readily penetrates into the middle of the rope and rapidly dissolves
out any remaining lubricant. The rope should be allowed to remain
on the drum long enough to allow it to dry as much as possible.
When the rope has been cleaned and dried the lubricant should
be applied by hand with a fairly stiff brush. The successful
lubrication of a haulage rope calls for a good deal of skill and
patience, but unless it is properly done the time and materials
are wasted. It is better to do a portion of the rope well each week
than to waste a lot of grease by applying it to the whole of the rope
without cleaning and drying.
It is not possible to lay down any fixed periods for the lubrication
of haulage ropes because the periods will vary with the working
conditions. A rope which makes a large number of journeys
on a wet incline will need lubrication every week, whereas a rope
which makes only a few journeys on a dry road may be kept in
good condition by less frequent treatment. Excellent results have
been obtained on endless rope haulages where the rope was
lubricated continuously.
The inspection or examination of a man-haulage rope is just as
important as that of a winding rope, since the consequences of a
breakage may be equally serious. In many of the failures described
the report of the rope examiner on the condition before fracture
was mere optimistic than warranted by the facts. Only 3 out of
the 23 ropes had been reported to be otherwise than in good condition,
that is to say 20 ropes broke although they had been
examined and reported to be in good condition. Since many of
these ropes broke in consequence of severe external deterioration
their conditions should have been apparent for some time before
the breakage. This suggests that the methods of examination
practised at the collieries were unsatisfactory. There are good
grounds for urging that a rope should be given a special examination,
at definite intervals, in addition to the regular examination. The
most convenient time for making the special examination is when
the rope has been cleaned preparatory to lubrication.
Haulage ropes are specially liable to deterioration close to the
capel owing to the reflection of the kinetic shocks at that point.
The rope is also liable to deterioration due to bending at the mouth
of the capel. Because of this tendency to deterioration haulage
ropes are recapped at intervals. The Law requires that the rope
should be recapped at intervals not exceeding six months, but in
many cases a shorter interval is desirable. When the rope is recapped
a length should he cut off, sufficient to remove the portion
liable to deterioration near the capel. The removal of this piece
of rope "moves on" the rope at other places liable to deterioration,
as for example, on the pulley at the top of the incline or at
the drum, when the haulage is being started. At many collieries
it is customary to cut off a length of rope equal to one circumference
of the drum, every three months, and it is suggested that not less
than six feet should he cut off in all cases.
Assuming that the examination of the rope has been properly
carried out, the colliery manager is faced with the problem of
deciding when the rope must be removed from service. The
diameter of the rope is the simplest index to its condition, and, if
account be taken of the type of deterioration to which the rope is
subjected, useful conclusions may be drawn from changes in
diameter.
It is suggested that no rope should be allowed to remain in service
after the outer wires at the most worn section have lost 40 per cent.
of their diameter. Whether a rope should he allowed to reach
this fairly advanced stage of deterioration will depend on the initial
margin of safety and on the working conditions. If these are such
as to cause fatigue the rope may be in a dangerous state long before
the outer wires are worn down 40 per cent. Consequently a rope
showing heavy external wear should only be left in service as long
as the outer wires remain free from fatigue, i.e., as long as there are
no broken or cracked outer wires.
The rope failures are dealt with in detail in the Paper, grouped
according to whether the failure of the rope, as judged by the tested
samples and the results of mechanical tests, was found to be due
predominantly to wear, corrosion, or capel failure.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Dixon, S. M., Prof. | | | |
| Rogan, M. A., Dr. | | | |