|
8th June 1935, Page: 378, Column: 1 November (1934) ExaminationsReport of Central ExaminersThe report of the Central Examiners has been issued on the examinations for certificates of competency as managers and under-managers of mines held in November, 1934. The text of the questions is given below, the comments of the Examiners on the work done by the candidates being reproduced in italics following the setting of each question. The official Question Papers, containing also the plans and diagrams, are obtainable (2s. net) through H.M. Stationery Office. Winning and Working (1st Class). (1) Under what conditions would you decide to work a seam on the pillar and stall system? Sketch a general lay-out to give 600 tons per shift, showing the roads and pillars, and explain how the pillars are extracted. (50) The conditions favourable to this system were well understood, but the layouts generally were not satisfactory — many candidates seemed to think that it was sufficient to illustrate pillar and stall workings by merely filling the page with a number of horizontal and vertical lines at equal distances. The explanations regarding the extraction of the pillars were vague. (2) Describe, with sketches, how you would arrange a pit bottom to load a three-deck cage simultaneously. Assume your own conditions and give important dimensions. (40) The hydraulic system of decking was favoured by most of the candidates; others would use drop cages only, and a few made use of creeper chains for raising or lowering the tubs to the respective cage landings, but omitted to mention that by the use of creeper chains much less ground had to be taken out, which was a great advantage where there was excessive side pressure at the pit bottom. Sketches generally were unfinished. (3) Describe aqueous, igneous and metamorphic rocks. In which rocks do you find stratification? What is meant by the term "cleavage" ? (40) This question was well answered. (4) A 6-foot seam at is depth of 500 yards is to be worked by longwall under an extensive building area. What would you do to minimise the amount of subsidence? What kind of ground near the surface would you expect to cause (a) Serious localised breaks; and (b) a more even subsidence extending over a much larger area ? (40) Many candidates suggested hydraulic stowing, and a few pneumatic stowing, but the application of this latter system was not well understood. It was hoped that more candidates would have suggested better and tighter packing by the ordinary method. The second part of the question, asking for the kind of ground near the surface which causes (a) serious localised breaks and (b) subsidence extending over a much larger area, was welt answered. (5) Describe and sketch for a road where the traffic all goes in one direction an arrangement of switch or turn-out with self-acting points in a 2-foot gauge track whereby one tub takes the left-hand track, and the second takes the right-hand track, and so on — odd numbers to the left and even numbers to the right. (40) The answers were most disappointing. The methods shown in many of the sketches could not possibly work, and a large number of the arrangements were not self-acting but have to be operated by hand. (6) In a dry-sinking pit, 20 feet diameter, explain briefly: (a) How you would place and fire your shots; (b) how you would put in and support a length of brickwork; and (c) the kind of bricking scaffold you would use. (40) Answers were good and showed a knowledge of the work. (7) Near the shaft bottom pumps have to be installed to deal with 150 gallons per minute. Show the relative positions of the pump house and lodge room, and give a cross-section of the latter. The seam is 4 feet thick dipping 1 in 3. There is a hard roof, and under the coal 2 feet of soft shale, then a hard bed. (40) The answers were disappointing, a stereotype answer generally being given without taking into account the thickness and dip of the seam, the fact that there was a hard roof, and also that under the coal there was a thickness of 2 feet of soft shale which should be removed to expose the hard floor for the lodge room. Ventilation (1st Class). (1) On the plan . . . . show how you would arrange for the distribution of the air-currents, using the signs and colours as given in the Regulations. Sheets to be shown thus f. (50) The plans submitted by the candidates showed the ordinary workings on the north-east side, fairly well ventilated, for the most part, but the arrangements for the workings through the fault south-eastwards were not satisfactory in the majority of cases. In addition, there were omissions of the necessary doors at or near the bottom of the shafts, and a few others ignored the statutory requirements of a second intake, although the plan is obviously designed to meet this. (2) Sketch a hygrometer. Give a short account of its construction and method of use. What value do you attach to its indications ? What improvements have been introduced into the construction, and with what object? (30) A large number of answers were good, but several were very hazy, and some others incorrect, in regard to the meaning of the wet bulb reading. Some stated that when both readings are alike, the air is dry, whereas the opposite is true. (3) Give a list of the gases (including air) usually met with in mines. State their composition, specific gravity and properties. How are the noxious gases detected, and how is each rendered harmless to the workers ? (30) Fully one-third of the candidates, while enumerating the properties of gases, in the case of CH4 (methane or firedamp) omitted to state that it is explosive when mixed with air in certain proportions. In most other respects the answers generally call for little comment. (4) What investigations would you conduct at a mine, to obtain the information necessary to ascertain the characteristics required in a new ventilating fan, about to be installed, so as to ensure that the fan would be suitable for the conditions ot the mine? (30) This question was not attempted by the great majority, and the few who did, treated the question from the point of view of the number of men vend horses employed. Only two or three thought it also necessary to compare the characteristics of any new fan with the resistance of the mine itself. (5) What do you understand by the terms "resistance" and "perimeter" as used in ventilation? Compare the resistances of two roadways, each 1,000 yards long, one of them, heavily timbered, 8 feet high, 6 feet wide near the roof and 9 feet wide at the floor; the other lined with standard steel arches, splayed type, 8 feet high, 8 feet wide at springings, and 9 feet wide at the floor — all measurements taken in the clear. If a quantity of 30,000 cubic feet per minute is passing along each of these roads, calculate the air horse-power in each case, using your own estimate of the coefficient of friction. (30) Most answers were unsatisfactory the explanation of resistance was often not good, and perimeter was wrongly defined in the majority of cases. The calculations in regard to the area, etc., on the timbered road were usually correct; but many of the candidates did not calculate the area of the arched road even approximately correctly. Very few attempted to arrive at the air horsepower, and of these, most were quite uncertain about the coefficient of friction K (expressed in lb. per square foot, or in inches of water-gauge) and also in the calculations generally. (6) Calculate the weight of 1,000 cubic feet of air at a temperature of 50°F. and that of a similar quantity at 72°F. Barometer reading is 30 inches. In the ease of a pair of shafts, each 600 yards deep and 21 feet diameter, what is the weight of air in each if one is at 50°F. and the other at 72°F. ? From this deduce the pressure available to produce ventilation if these shafts are connected at the bottom, and what is the maximum water-gauge under these conditions ? (30) This was a favourite question, and well answered in the majority of cases. Many candidates wasted their time in working out the motive column, which was not asked for — and in the process of doing so usually fell into error, A proportion of incorrect answers were founded on the actual readings of the Fahrenheit thermometer instead of using the absolute temperature. (7) In driving cross-measure drifts in strata containing proportion of silica, state what arrangements you would adopt as to ventilation. Give an account of any special apparatus you would install to prevent the dust getting into the air. (30) A majority favoured exhaust ventilation, as opposed to forcing fan, and this is desirable in the case given. The description of the dust traps was good, except that a few suggested an air-tight bag for the dust, instead of a dust-tight one. Explosions, Etc. (1st Class). (1) Give a short account of the investigations carried out under the auspices of the Safety in Mines Research Board in connection with: (a) Explosions in mines; (b) spontaneous heating; (c) coal dust. What are the principal conclusions arrived at with regard to the explosibility of coal dust, also with regard to the efficacy of stone dust as a means of preventing the propagation of an explosion? (30) There were some good answers, but many of them indicated that the published reports had not been carefully studied. The latter part of the question with regard to the explosibility of coal dust and the efficacy of stone dust was generally well answered. (2) Describe a hypothetical case of an underground fire where a reversal of the ventilation would be advisable. When and by whom, should the order for the reversal of the ventilation be given? (25) Only a small proportion of the candidates gave full and satisfactory answers. Reversal of the ventilation was suggested even where the fire was between the intake and return airways and quite near to the pit bottom, obviously wrong in the conditions stated in some of the answers. (3) At a depth of 200 yards from the surface there are extensive old workings containing water lying 100 yards above a seam of coal which is about to be worked. What precautions should be taken in working the seam below the old workings, the strata being intersected by a fault? (25) Most candidates attempted to answer this question and there were many good answers, the fault being looked upon, and quite properly, as a point of danger. (4) It is proposed to construct a dam in a vertical shaft, which is 14 feet diameter within a lining of 9-inch brickwork, to prevent water passing down the shaft to lower seams. Sketch and describe the construction of a dam capable of withstanding the pressure due to 120 yards' head of water. (25) The sketches were generally crude, and the construction in many cases was unsuitable. (5) A sample of air has been taken from the pipe leading through the stopping of a district which has been sealed off in consequence of recent spontaneous heating. Give approximately the figures of an analysis of such a sample, and state in what way further samples and analyses would indicate an increase, or diminution of the beatings. (25) The figures of an analysis of an air sample were often wrongly stated and not representative of the conditions generally found in such cases; a high percentage of firedamp is generally present, and a number of candidates did not refer to this gas. (6) A large fall of roof in the intake haulage road near to the coal face has caused an accumulation of firedamp on the return side of a working place in which several men are employed. The place can only be approached by passing through the gas by way of the return with rescue apparatus. How would you proceed to rescue the men? (25) The question states that the place can only be approached by way of the return with rescue apparatus, and the answer should indicate how this may be done. Several candidates ignored the rescue apparatus and suggested bratticing along the return to remove the gas. Time is the important factor; the men would keep as near to the fall as possible where some fresh air would be scaling through, and it might reasonably be assumed that they would be found there. A team of men wearing rescue apparatus and taking stretchers and oxygen reviving sets with them, whilst another team stood by at the fresh air base, was the answer required, but the limitations of the oxygen reviving sets must not be overlooked, and in no case was this referred to. Machinery (1st Class). (1) Draw a diagram of connections showing an electrical 3-phase circuit from a 3-core cable through high-tension switch-gear, step-down transformer, medium tension switchgear and stator reversing switch to the motor. The reversing switch is combined with a liquid starter for the rotor circuit. Show automatic overload trips and low-volt releases where appropriate. Show ammeter and voltmeter on the medium tension (step-down) side of the transformer. (28) Only a few attempted this question and the answers in general were not good. The arrangement of the liquid starter in the rotor circuit and the inter-locking with the reversing switch puzzled many candidates. (2) Discuss the supply of electric power to a moving coal-cutter. Deal with the questions of switchgear, trailing cable and protection from danger to men and from damage to plant. (28) This question was attempted by most candidates and many good answers were given. Considerable knowledge of modern protective types of switch gear was shown. (3) Direct-current motors may be wound: "Series," "shunt," or "compound." Show by simple diagrams what these terms mean and state briefly the characteristics of the three types of motor as applied to mining plant. (28) Most candidates attempted this question and there were many excellent answers. (4) An ordinary headgear pulley with shaft and bearings is wanted for carrying a 1-inch diameter steel wire winding rope. Draw up a specification to be sent to makers when inviting tenders. Assume your own conditions and include the chief dimensions and particulars. Do not deal with the headgear nor the rope. (28) About half the candidates attempted this question, but few showed any real knowledge of the design of this simple piece of colliery plant. Many read the question as requiring only a description of the size of the winding engine, shaft and cages, etc., leaving the manufacturer to do the whole of the designing of the pulley. (5) Describe the construction of a 3-deck cage and chains to carry men or six tubs each to hold 10 cwts. of coal. Give the chief dimensions and state the materials used. An outline drawing of the whole cage and chains or a detail drawing of a part should be included. (28) Most candidates attempted this question and the majority had a goad idea as to the size of cage required. The sketches of the whole cage showed much uncertainty as to the method of construction. (6) Show by part plan and sectional cross-elevation a butt joint for the longitudinal seam of a Lancashire boiler shell with inside and outside cover plates and four rows of rivets, the shell plate being ¾ in. thick. The working steam pressure is 150 lb. per square inch. Show the dimensions of the cover plates and the size and spacing of the rivets. Draw to a scale of a quarter full size. Rivet holes can be indicated in plan by crosses. The ends of the cover plates where the shell rings overlap need not be shown. (28) Few attempted this question, and of this number only a small proportion had any idea of designing such a joint. (7) Describe the construction and working of one type of steam turbine and condenser, say for an output of 1,500 h.p., using steam at about 250 lb. per square inch, at an inlet temperature of about 600°F. (28) Very few candidates had a clear idea as to the general design and layout of a steam turbine with a condenser. (8) Describe the action of a centrifugal, or turbine, multi-stage pump. Draw typical curves connecting the head, rate of flow, power and efficiency of such a pump. (28) Many good descriptions were given, but few candidates had more than a vague idea of the characteristic curves of such a pump.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||