|
8th June 1935, Page: 377, Column: 1 Coal Mines FusionsHaving regard to the recent judgment of the Railway and Canal Commission, disapproving the West Yorkshire scheme, questions have been asked in the House of Commons and Mr. Ernest Brown, the Secretary for Mines, in reply said he understood that the Coal Mines Reorganisation Commission is considering a scheme for total amalgamation for submission to the Court in the near future. It will be recalled that Mr. Justice MacKinnon, in his judgment, said the scheme was not really the work of the Coal Mines Reorganisation Commission. The Commission had adopted a scheme voluntarily agreed upon by a majority of the West Yorkshire coalowners. In effect, their proposal was that the scheme of the majority should be made binding on the minority, whose assent to it could not be obtained voluntarily. It was the duty of the Court, under the Acts of Parliament, not to confirm the scheme unless it was in the national interest and would result in lower costs of production or disposal of coal, and would not be financially injurious to any undertakings proposed to be amalgamated. The Court also had to be satisfied that the terms of the scheme were fair and reasonable to all the persons affected by it. What was contemplated by the Acts of Parliament was total or partial amalgamation. The scheme concerned some sixty undertakings which varied very greatly in size, and, in regard to their annual production, from over a million tons to less than a thousand tons. Under the scheme, or so-called scheme, there was no fusion or rolling together of any of these entities ; nor was there any creation of a new corporation which should own the shares of these undertakings. All that was proposed was that an authority should be created which should have power to control the independent actions of the separate entities, with voting power by the separate entities according to tonnage rate and power to refer decisions to arbitration. Part of the machinery of the scheme provided for the constitution of a joint committee. The Judge said he could not agree that by providing for a joint committee to control the affairs of separate entities, there was created a partial amalgamation scheme. He thought the scheme did not satisfy that preliminary requirement of the Acts of Parliament. In effect, the scheme was to empower some arbitrator in the future to create a scheme.
|
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||