25th May 1935, Page: 363, Column: 1
Colliery Officials And Safety In Mines
By Arthur Roberts.
Extracts from the Year Book (1985) of the Lancashire and Cheshire
Colliery Under-managers' and Underlookers' Association. Mr. Roberts
is President of the Association.
Many would claim, and I think the claim would be allowed
in most quarters, that a goodly number of accidents in and about
mines occur by reason of the simple (act that many men's thoughts
are primarily focused on the problem of making the beet living
they can in given circumstances. They neglect, or forget, to look
as carefully as they could, and should, for dangers actual or
possible.
If this fundamental notion be agreed upon, it logically follows
as a moral right that the same latitude or excuse must be allowed
to owners. They, too, have a living to get.
There is another body — the coal consumers — who enter into
the safety problem, but only indirectly. A buyer of coal wants
the cost to be as low as possible. He says he cannot afford to
pay more than he does, and could very well do with paying less.
In short, he also has his living to get.
Thus, we have Worker, Employer, and Consumer, each with
an economic interest to maintain under competitive conditions.
Each of the three parties recognises that there is this economic
basis, common to them all.
These "three persons" have another common basis, this time
regarded from the social aspect. They are agreed that "We have
too many accidents in mines, and many of them are preventable."
This agreement has always been as sincere as it is clear. The
consolidation of much piece-meal legislation in the Coal Mines
Act of 1911, and the extensions and amendments to this Act — all
making greater effort to save life and limb — testify to this
agreement as to policy. The Regulations are posted up on the pit bank
of every colliery in the country, and society as a whole decrees
that they shall be obeyed.
We thus reach a remarkable paradox. The three bodies, the
very people who call for and make binding our safety regulations,
are the people who, in their private capacities, either break them,
or force on the coal industry economic conditions which cause
them to be broken.
There is a fourth party in the foregoing arrangements — those
responsible for carrying out the laws in practice, the executive
branch of the industry, for whom this article is mainly intended.
I refer, of course, to the colliery officials appointed under the
Regulations — Managers, Under-managers, Deputies, Firemen and
Shot-lighters.
Those who take up the baton of a colliery official under the
Coal Mines Act have a great responsibility on their shoulders.
They are the folk to whom the aforesaid three bodies look for
good and healthy conditions in and about the mines. If disaster
occurs, they are put up for trial by the other three bodies at an
enquiry — as much recent history shows — and the outcome may
be a Public Report which will demonstrate, or try to demonstrate,
just where the "fourth party" fails in his duties under the Acts.
It would seem, therefore, that we must ever keep in the forefront
of our minds the idea that we are live safety valves, put
into our positions by law, and responsible to it. Our duties are
concerned with that which we see, and also that which we know,
to be contrary to safety in and about our pits; and those duties
only end when we are certain that everything possible has been
done to ensure that no accidents occur which might have been
prevented by reasonable foresight, coupled with our technical
ability. That is a bare minimum; our individual consciences
should, and in most cases will, carry us even further, once we have
thoroughly appreciated our jobs.
We are not primarily producing units — we are safety units.
The big bulk of our energies should be absorbed by the safety
question — the carrying out faithfully of regulations laid down
to minimise risks — and the solving of problems still unsolved
which have that end in view.
Some may say, "That is idealism." It is; but why not?
The chief ingredient of commonsense applied in any direction is
idealism. Regulations represent idealism interpreted in the
light of commonsense. They can and will be altered where
experience shows that they need revision and modification. The
important fact remains that the Acts serve an essential purpose,
and are a constant reminder to colliery officials of the social aspect
of coal-getting, and of their prime obligation, namely, that of
trying to bring about a condition where there are fewer deaths.
and accidents.
Let us remember then, the duties we have undertaken — the
responsibility which the owners, by consent of the other two
interested parties, have placed upon us. Let us remember, too,
that "safety first" is worth while if only because of the truth that
dead and injured men produce no output. They are a heavy loss
and a great sorrow to those near and dear to them. They are an
economic loss to industry and commerce.
Each of us can profitably think of himself as a fulcrum where
economic forces and the safety urge may pull in opposite directions.
Alter more than thirty years as an official I can give it as my
considered opinion that the full weight of our effort must be
always on the side of safety. If we look after this, then output
will look after itself in the long run. A disciple of safety has no
need to fear cost sheets and output returns.
We have a good, reasonable body of men to deal with as workers,
and we have men with right ideals as officials, both under and over
us. No matter what destiny has in store for us as to who controls
us, whether it be owner, agent, director, or the State — the points
I have tried to establish will have to be raised, discussed, and
answered.
The earnestness and sincerity which we put into our daily task
will bring its own reward in the form of fewer accidents and a
smaller number of fatalities. Ponder the matter carefully. Can
you imagine a more dignified and noble calling?
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Roberts, Arthur | | President | |