13th April 1935, Page: 312, Column: 2
Correlation Of Coal Seams
By Arthur Bray, M.Sc., Assoc.Inst.M.M.
From paper read on 21st March, In the Wigan Mining and
Technical College, before the Lancashire and Cheshire branch of the
Institute of Mine Surveyors. The numbers in brackets refer to the
list of references at the end of the paper.
The Carboniferous System as developed in Britain can be
divided into two fairly distinct divisions, the Lower Carboniferous
and the Upper Carboniferous, which includes the Millstone Grit
and the Coal Measures. In some areas, as in the Ciltheroe (1)
and Colne (2) districts, there is a perfectly uniform passage from
the Lower to the Upper Carboniferous, but in Derbyshire (3)
there is a break between the two, the Edale Shales of Middle
Millstone Grit age resting on the Upper Carboniferous Limestone.
The type development of the limestone faces of the Lower
Carboniferous is in the Bristol area. Here it consists of limestones
of various types and is over 2,000 feet thick, but northwards it
thins, until along the north border of the South Wales coalfield
the Lower Carboniferous is very attenuated. The deposit continues
to thin northwards into Shropshire. In Derbyshire only
the upper part of the Carboniferous Limestone is exposed, and
there is evidence of a southerly overlap. Thus, during Lower
Carboniferous times a land area stretched across central England.
In Lancashire the succession is more complete, but in the upper
part is shaly. In Northumberland and Durham the Lower
Carboniferous takes on a different aspect and consists of bands
of limestone, shale, sandstone and thin coals. In the Central
Valley of Scotland this tendency is continued, and well developed
coals are present in the sequence.
When traced over different parts of Britain, the Lower Carboniferous
is seen to change its lithological characters and correlation
on a small scale becomes very difficult over large areas.
The Carboniferous Limestone gave place to the deltaic deposits
of the Millstone Grit. As is to be expected sediments of this
type are very variable, both lithologically and in the thickness
of the individual beds. At frequent intervais the sea encroached
the Millstone Grit area leading to the deposition of marine shales,
containing the remains of goniatites and marine lamellebranchs.
The fauna of these marine bands was studied by Mr. Bisat (3)
and others, and a zonal succession made out which has been
invaluable in the correlation of the various areas of Millstone
Grits.
The deposition of the Coal Measures followed on that of the
Millstone Grit. The basins were filled up and conditions became
very uniform. Marine encroachments occurred, as is shown by
the Coal Measure marine bands, but they were much less frequent
and the fauna less characteristic.
Mapping and correlation previous to the revision of the Upper
Carboniferous fauna were based chiefly on the lithology of the
strata, but whilst this may be, and often is, quite satisfactory
over small areas, it is open to grave doubt when applied to
scattered or distant localities. Whilst some easily recognised
sandstone beds may keep to one horizon over considerable tracts
of country, others wedge out suddenly or may cross the stratigraphy,
as does the Pennant Sandstone of the South Wales
coalfield.
On the other hand certain thicknesses of strata may contain
fossil assemblages which are characteristic of particular sections
of the measures, and which differ in a recognisable manner from
the assemblages found above and below. In this way life zones
are made out which can be put into a definite sequence one above
the other. When worked out in an area where the stratigraphical
succession is undisputed, the zonal scheme can be applied to other
areas. Slight differences in individual organisms may occur
from place to place, but usually the assemblage taken as a whole
can be recognised in different areas and be correlated one with
another.
For zonal purposes the ideal type of organism is one undergoing
a rapid evolution and from which new forms are springing off at
frequent time intervals, but which meet an early extinction.
Their remains are thus only found in small thicknesses of strata,
and are succeeded by others of a slightly different type. In the
Millstone Grit, for example, numerous marine bands are present,
each with a characteristic fauna easily distinguished from that
of earlier and succeeding bands. These marine bands have a
wide distribution, and can usually be fairly easily mapped. The
measures between two marine bands are probably the time equivalents
of the measures in another area situated between two
similar marine bands.
In the Millstone Grit these marine bands are numerous, but
they show a marked diminution above the base of the Lower
Coal Measures. The fauna of the Coal Measures consist chiefly
of freshwater shells, such as Carbonicola and Anthracornya or
brackish, long-lived lingulids. They are widespread, and often
occur in considerable numbers in mussel hands above or below
coal seams. The faunal assemblages of the mussel bands may
differ as they are followed upwards through the measures, and
it is on these differences that the Coal Measures may be zoned.
Occasional inroads of the sea occurred in Coal Measure times,
resulting in the deposition of a marine band amongst the fresh-
water sediments. These bands are often widespread and cover
considerable areas, as does the marine horizon above the Mountain
Mine of Lancashire;
The fossil plants of the Coal Measures are used extensively in
large scale zoning. They are abundant in the shales associated
with the coal seams. The flora do not appear to have evolved
as rapidly as the fauna, and identification of the strata depends
largely on the relative abundance of certain plants rather than
on the presence in the measures of a particular species. Plants
are very sensitive to water supply and climatic conditions, and
their vegetative parts may vary from place to place. The
reproductive bodies of plants such as spores are less susceptible,
and are abundant in the coal seams themselves. The work of
Dr. Raistrick on the spore content of the seams shows that
differences exist between the different seams in Northumberland
with possibilities of correlation of the seams themselves. There
appears to be a steady change in the percentage constituents
of the flora making up the seams as they are examined in ascending
order. This method probably has a future in the correlation of
seams rather than correlation of the measures enclosing the seams.
The characteristic marine fossils of the Upper Carboniferous
are the goniatites, and they are the chief fossils of most of the
marine bands of the Millstone Grit. Mr. Bisat (3) establishes the
following zones in descending order :—
@
The division between the Upper and Lower Carboniferous is
taken as the base of the E. zone where the genus Goniatites becomes
extinct and is replaced by Eumorphoccras. The zones E. to R.
and the lower part of the G. zone are included in the Millstone
Grit, but there is, in Lancashire at least, no break between the
Grit and the Lower Coal Measures, and the goniatites of the top
Millstone Grit pass up into the base of the Coal Measures.
Similarly, the freshwater shells of the Coal Measures make an
appearance well below the base of the Coal Measures.
The marine bands may be of great use in conjunction with the
mussel beds and the lithology of the measures in identifying
seams in different areas. Thus the Lower Mountain Mine of
Lancashire has dolomitic bullions in the roof containing Gastrioceras
and Pterinopecten and a ganister floor. Similar features are seen
in the Alton Coal of Derbyshire, the Crabtree Coal of North
Staffordshire, and the Halifax Hard Bed of Yorkshire, and all
the seams are in the lower part of the Lower Coal Measures and
are correlated with each other. In some areas, between the
Six Inch Mine and its associated marine band, is a mussel bed
containing Anthracemya bellula. A similar association is found
in various parts of Lancashire and at the base of the Coal Measures
of Yorkshire (5).
The bulk of the fauna of the Coal Measures is of the freshwater
or brackish type, consisting chiefly of the genera Carbonicola,
Anthracomya and Naiadites. These shells are present occasionally
in enormous numbers in some of the mussel beds. The groups
are connected by intermediate forms, and many different species
of shells may occur together on the same horizon. A great variety
of forms belonging to one species may be present, and these can
be grouped together into one species group. At different horizons
the group may show various stages of evolution, and correlation
can be based on the stage of advancement of the species group.
Intense collecting may show that individual mussel bands may
have characteristics enabling them to be identified, when they
become of great use in correlation.
An order of superposition can be made out, and large collections
made from the mussel bands. Many types of mussels may be
present in the same band, but it may be possible to divide them
into species groups, the percentages of which are characteristic
of each particular band. Davis (6) found in South Wales that
C. Aquilina ranged from close above the Millstone Grit towards
the top of the Coal Measures, but that the shells were different
at different horizons in the measures. In the Penny Pieces Vein
C. aquilina was elongated, and those of the Stwrin Vein were more
robust and larger, whilst those at the base were intermediate
between aquilina and acuta. The Lower Vein has 50-per cent.
of the mussels belonging to C. cf subconstricta whilst
Anthracomya
and Naiadites are absent. In the Brass Vein Carbonicola,
Anthracomya
and Naiadites are present, whilst about 50 per cent, of the
species resembled C. turgida, and A. modiolaris formed about
25 per cent. of the fauna of the shales associated with the coal.
In the Red Vein the carbonicolas are small and occur in
diminishing numbers, whilst in the upper measures A. phillipsii
comes in. The careful working over of large accurately located
collections is of undoubted help in small scale correlation, and
Davis has drawn up a scheme of correlation based on his researches.
In like manner Hopkins (7) using both the mussel beds and the
thickness of measures between the seams, has revised the correlation
of part of the succession of the North of England. The
table given below is taken from his paper :—
@
It will be noticed that the Hutton seam was used as a base.
Above it is a mussel bed associated with Spirorbis, distinguishing
it from the mussel bed above the Five Quarter seam in which
Spirorbis is absent. The thickness of measures between the
seams is closely paralleled in the three areas, and taken with
the mussel beds makes the correlation very acceptable.
The Coal Measures have been divided into a number of zones
based on the freshwater shells as under (8) :—
| 8. | Zone of Anthracomya
tennis. |
| 7. | Zone of Anthracomya
phillipsii. |
| 6. | Zone of Anthracomya
pulchra. |
| 5. | Zone of Carbonicola
similis. |
| 4. | Zone of Anthracomya
modiolaris. |
| 3. | Zone of Carbonicola
ovalis. |
| 2. | Zone of Carbonicola
fallax. |
| 1. | Zone of Anthracomya bellula.
|
These zones may include a considerable thickness of strata,
but for correlation of individual seams there may he differences
in the mussel band associated with each seam by which they
can be distinguished. It would be of considerable value to
collieries if they made as full a collection of shells as possible
with accurate localities.
[To be Concluded.)
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bisat, — | | | |
| Bray, Arthur | | | |
| Davis, — | | | |
| Hopkins, — | | | |