|
2nd March 1935, Page: 262, Column: 2 SilicosisPaper by Dr. S. W. Fisher Natural Defences Against Inhaled Dust. At the annual meeting on the 1st of February of the Institution of Mining Engineers, Dr. S. W. Fisher, H.M. Medical Inspector of Mines, presented a paper on SILICOSIS IN BRITISH COAL MINES. Regarding our natural defences against inhaled dust he explained that a certain amount of the dust is filtered off by the nose; much of the remainder, as it goes down the trachea and bronchial tubes, settles on them. The bronchial tubes as they branch become more and more narrow, so that it is only the very finest dust (less than 10 microns in diameter) that enters the alveoli, or air sacs, of the lung. The inner part of the bronchial tubes is provided with a lining of tiny finger-like projections (ciliated epithelium) which bend over with a quick whip-like movement, the whole layer acting like an ever-moving conveyor which carries the dust mixed with mucus upwards towards the throat. The fine particles which enter the alveoli are ingested by cells which have the power of movement (phagocytes); these, when laden with dust, make their way to the bronchial tubes and are also carried upwards by the ciliated epithelium, or they may migrate to the lymphatic vessels of the lungs. Coal-dust particles are eagerly taken up by phagocytes, and it is this, together with the fact that a large proportion of coal-dust particles in the atmosphere of a mine are too large to enter the alveoli, that prevents the coal miners' lungs being choked up with dust. It is also generally agreed that silicotic fibrosis is not due to the physical properties of the dust, such as angularity and hardness, but to the fact that the dust-particles dissolve in the lung and the solution thus produced is the harmful substance which initiates the process of fibrosis. Grouping of Silicosis Cases. Giving tables and figures relating to the grouping of silicosis cases, Dr. Fisher showed that out of a total of 144 certificates issued in the period June — December, 1934, 126 were in respect of South Wales miners only, the remainder, namely 18, being sparsely distributed over the rest of the country, including Scotland. The incidence of the disease in South Wales has caused the Mines Department grave concern. The cause is still very obscure ; it is probably a combination of factors. It has been suggested that the stone-dusting in mines might be the cause of the disease. In this connection it is only necessary to point out that many cases come from anthracite mines, where no stone-dusting is done. One's mind naturally turns, the Doctor proceeded to say, to the amount of rock-drilling done, but a glance at the tables he had prepared shows that the amount of drilling done is not by itself any guide without other factors, such as the medical particulars of the men who drill, the nature of the dust, the quality of the ventilation, etc. The tables show, he explained, that while South Wales as a whole accounts for only one-quarter of the total number of picks and drills used for purposes other than getting coal, nearly 90 per cent. of the cases of silicosis occurred in this district. The position in the Swansea Division is even more striking, the corresponding figures being, picks and drills 5 per cent. and silicosis cases 54 per cent. Reference to the figures also shows that even at anthracite mines in the same district, the relation between the use of drills and the incidence of silicosis varies considerably. It is therefore obviously necessary to consider general conditions. Many of the anthracite mines are worked by inclines from the surface, and it has been suggested that the miners become chilled at the end of their shift by being ridden up the slant against the cold intake air, a journey taking 15 to 20 minutes, and that this chilling gives rise to bronchitis, which in turn breaks down the natural mechanism by which dust is eliminated from the bronchial tubes and lungs. Dr. Fisher is inclined to think that the "non-industrial" medical history of a youth who intends to work in dusty parts of a mine such as conveyor ends, hard headings or machine-cut faces, should be considered, as bronchitis and bronchopneumonia may facilitate the entry and obstruct the exit of fine dust-particles. Preventive Measures. As soon as evidence of silicosis among coal miners reached the Mines Department investigations were set on foot to discover the extent of the risk to which miners were exposed, with the object of devising effective preventive measures. As far as dust itself is concerned, when considering the matter with reference to a normally healthy lung, Dr. Fisher thinks the evidence is clear that whatever the action of other dusts may be, that of silicon dioxide (SiO3) in fine division (namely, particles below 10 microns in size) when inhaled may cause fibrosis of the lungs silicotic in type, that is to say, nodular, and in some way renders them very liable to develop tuberculosis. Dr. W. R. Jones, however, gives pride of place to sericite, and his hypothesis, which the lecturer says undoubtedly shook up the "silicotic world," at least rekindled interest in the problem. But whatever the mineral or minerals of which the dangerous dust is composed, the remedy is the same, namely, the suppression of the dust. The relative merits of dust-traps, water-fed drills, water-sprays, the wetting of debris, respirators, and ventilation, were studied, and this study has gone on ever since. In 1925 Captain Hay, who is now an Inspector of Mines specially appointed to deal with the question of dust prevention, devised his first dust-trap. As well as the Hay dust-trap there are about six others which have been approved as efficient, and at the present time there are about 800 dust-traps in use at the mines. All of them act in very much the same way, that is, by drawing all the dust from the borehole as drilling takes place and depositing it in a filter device. The problem of wetting fine dust particles when drilling with water-fed drills is being investigated, and experiments are being conducted to find out if some chemical reagent, when added in small quantities to the water supply, will completely suppress all the dust produced. As a spray playing on a borehole, Dr. Fisher considers water is quite ineffective. As there are many processes in coal mines in which the use of dust-traps is not practicable, the use of respirators is of great importance, and as the Doctor stated, it is reassuring to know that a respirator which may be considered as generally satisfactory has recently been evolved. This appliance is ingenious in design, quite comfortable to wear for long periods, and light in weight (2 oz.). It has a low resistance to breathing and a remarkably high filtering efficiency when dealing with dust particles of a dangerous size, that is to say, the very fine particles. Ventilation must always be kept in mind as an essentially preventive measure, especially, as the lecturer said, in dead-ends where boring in rock is so often done and where the fumes and dust following shot-firing operations may remain in suspension for a very long period, — unless adequate ventilation methods are adopted for their rapid removal. In no case, he added, should men be allowed to return to the working place where shot-firing has been carried out until the atmosphere has been completely cleared of all dust and fumes. As regards determining the dust concentration in the atmosphere in coal mines, for routine examinations the Kotze konimeter is used. A Zeiss konimeter, which is essentially the same as a Kotze, is also often used on account of its having a microscope attached which permits the observer to count the dust spots then and there. These konimeters draw in 5 c.c. of the air, which impinges on a sticky glass slide, and the particles of dust in this small volume of air may then be counted. The chief use of the konimeter is in testing the efficacy of any suggested preventive measure or device where the dust is considered to be dangerous. In dry drilling without a dust-trap the particles in a spot are always too numerous to count. Conclusions and Recommendations. At the close of his paper Dr. Fisher submitted conclusions to the number of four, namely :— 1. In the short space of 15-90 years, the known incidence amongst workers in coal mines of the disease diagnosed as silicosis has grown from a few cases to over 700. 2. By far the greater number of these cases are found in the South Wales coalfield, with more in the west than in the east, but the incidence does not affect all the collieries in this area, even though conditions appear to be similar. The remainder of the cases are very sparsely distributed over England and Scotland. 3. Although the original cases were those of drill workers in silicosis rock, many cases have been certified in which it has not been possible to trace a history of such work. 4. Explanations of the peculiar distribution and the occurrence of the disease among non-drillers have not yet been determined. The fact that many of the cases come from mines where no stone-dusting is done shows that this is not in itself the cause. The Doctor also offered six recommendations, these being :— 1. In view of the fact that damage to the respiratory system through bronchitis interferes with the dust-eliminating function of the lungs, men who suffer from chronic cough or acute bronchitis should consult their doctor before taking up or resuming work in high concentrations of dust. This is particularly important in areas where many cases of silicosis occur. 2. Where machine boring in rock is being done, dust-traps or other efficient preventive measures should be made use of and kept in good repair. 3. Ventilation should be such that all fumes and dust in suspension in the atmosphere are quickly and thoroughly removed. 4. In places where there are heavy concentrations of dust, and means for suppressing this dust are not practicable, respirators should be worn. 5. In mines where the men are brought out in spakes, provision should be made for their protection from the cold intake air. 6. In view of the distressing nature of dust fibrosis of the lungs, in coal-miners, and its grave prognosis, I am of the opinion that research work should be done by experts on the treatment of pulmonary diseases, with the object of outlining medical treatment and how much treatment could best be administered. For instance, in an area such as South Wales, where there are so many cases, special institutions might be established, which are neither sanatoria on the one hand nor simply convalescent homes on the other, but which would have an adequate well-trained staff to deal with cases needing prolonged care.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||