|
21st December 1934, Page: 1149, Column: 2 The Gresford ExplosionInquiry AdjournedThe official inquiry into the causes and circumstances of the Gresford Colliery explosion which is being held at Wrexham by Sir Henry Walker, H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines was adjourned sine die on Friday pending the reopening of the mine. Parts I and II of the investigation have now been concluded, 26 days having been occupied in the hearing of evidence. The Rescue Operations. On the previous day Mr. Bonsall, the manager, had given evidence and stated that, in the circumstances, smoke helmets would have been of no use, because the smoke was so dense. He added that it was not possible to make a trunk call from the telephone at the pit bottom. In answer to Mr. W. Frowen (National Federation of Shotfirers), witness said it might be advisable to provide two suits of breathing apparatus, one at the bottom and one at the top of the pit. In re-examination by Mr. Shawcross (for the owners), the manager said' if air was still getting to 20's and 61's the fire at 29's turn would cause smoke and monoxide also to go into the return in those districts. He never dreamt of sending men into 20's airway. In reply to Sir Henry, witness said he thought the doors might have been blown. He thought it very questionable whether the men would have been able to come up by 20's return and on to the main Martin right through the smoke, as the latter was very dense. Sir Henry asked whether if it had been possible to get at 29's junction on witness's first visit, apparatus to throw water 30 ft. or 40 ft. might have put the fire out. Witness said be did not think so. He added that he sent definite instructions that nobody was to go in until he got back, as he thought the airway would be charged with carbon monoxide. There was, however, some miscarriage of the message, and men went through before he got there. He thought it would have been useless to reverse the air, although he did not give the matter a thought at the time. It would have killed many men who happened to be alive beyond the fire. Under-Manager Recalled. Mr. Andrew Williams, under-manager in charge of the Dennis district, then gave his story of the rescue attempts. Davy Jones told him, he said, that he had left some men behind, and then they discussed the way Jones had come out. He was not very sure that Jones had not coma the wrong way, but he did not know at that time there was a fire at 29's junction. However, now that he knew details, he was quits-satisfied that the men did take the better course. There was no sign of fire when they arrived at the clutch. The Martin return was full of dense smoke and there was a smell like burning timber. He sent for the canaries to be brought down, and then, having got over three falls, heard a hissing sound caused by a leakage of compressed air. It was then that he saw the fire. Mr. Williams agreed that it was practicable to send a man with rescue apparatus into an atmosphere containing poisonous gas, but not where the road to he travelled through contained dense smoke over such a distance as on this occasion, namely, 300 yd. They had a smoke helmet at the colliery with a long length of tubing, but it was not of the slightest use in the situation they had to meet. There were three sets of oxygen apparatus at the pit and the first team was available on the surface at 3.15 a.m. Men with rescue apparatus got right up to the fire at 29's through the smoke and tried to smother it with dust from the floor. They made no impression. On the Sunday he heard what resembled falls of roof inbye beyond the fire. When he left, the fire extended over the whole width of the road. There was not, to his knowledge, any suggestion about getting water down the compressed-air pipe. If water had been used it would have drawn the roadways up. The men worked well right up to the last moment. Expert's Evidence. At this point Sir Henry called upon Capt. Frederick Peter Mills, chief officer of the North of England mine rescue stations. He said he would advise rescue workers not to go further than 100 yd. in thick smoke unless there was a chance of doing something a very little distance further on. Capt. Mills agreed that if smoke was seen at the clutch on the return and also by the three doors outbye, he would naturally think the whole roadway was full of smoke. If nothing else could possibly be done, he might allow his men to go to a branch road 170 yd. away through the smoke, but it would have to be really urgent. Mr. Percy George Dominy, H.M. junior inspector, was recalled and testified to receiving a telephone message at 3.30 am. With regard to the rescue operations, he said it was very hot indeed, and the men were working in very short spells. They thought they were near 29's, but could not recognise it. The Stoppings. On Friday, Mr. Thomas R. Boydell, H.M. senior inspector for North Wales, gave evidence. He agreed that until the Sunday afternoon he believed only 104 men were below. He was next questioned about the stopping which was erected across the Main Dennis on the Saturday. Mr. Henderson said it had been stated that the object was to diminish the amount of air because of the fire past the clutch. An aperture had been left so that people could go through. Mr. Boydell said he was present at a conference in the offices when Mr. Dennis, Mr. Harris and representatives of the miners were present. They discussed the plans of the Dennis and tried to trace where the explosion had occurred. He was not prepared to say there was no mention of the desirability of sealing the pit. The stopping was some yards in thickness. He agreed that if the main purpose was to cut off the supply of air going to the clutch, it would have been possible to obtain the same result by erecting brattices, but the sealing-up question was present in some minds. Witness did not think a reversal of ventilation would have brought any chance of going up 20's. There was always a possibility of the reversal of air driving some explosive mixture on to the fire. Witness said there were between 150 to 200 rescue men down the pit. It was necessary to have a large number of men in the pit, and fortunately a great many people were prepared to volunteer for this dangerous work. He added that he did not think it would have made any difference whatever to the conditions in 20's had the end of the return been within 100 yd. of the fresh air base. Rescue Men's Evidence. A graphic description was then given by John Charles Williams, captain of the rescue party, of how three members of his team lost their lives in a vain effort to reach their entombed comrades. Williams told how he and his team were summoned from Llay Main Colliery, where they are employed, between 5.30 and 6 o'clock on the morning of the great explosion. Upon arriving at Gresford Colliery he saw rescue apparatus on the floor of the pitmen's cabin on the pit bank, and it was afterwards transferred to a room in the colliery offices, where he took the opportunity of examining and testing each outfit He rejected one owing to its condition. He did not put the box under water as there were no facilities for doing so. His team of four men descended the mine and travelled from the pit bottom about 200 yd., turning left, when they came to two doors, one of which was a sliding door. On reaching there he received instructions from Harold Thomas, a fireman, to ascertain the conditions of the airway. He asked for a plan, but there was none available. He had a fellow with him named Bill Hughes, belonging to the Gresford team, who said he knew the way. He was handed a bird in a cage, but they hadn't gone a matter of 5 or 6 yd. when the bird dropped dead to the bottom of the cage. He got down about 40 or 50 yd. and stopped. He was afraid that, assuming his party got to 20's, they might not be able to get the men out. He frequently tested for gas and found 2½ per cent. to 3 per cent. of firedamp. Eventually the four men decided to go on. One man bad been left behind because his apparatus was not functioning. Witness went on until it was impossible to get any further on account of the size of the road. He got on his bands and knees and shoved his lamp forward. There was no room for him to turn round with the apparatus, and he had to come out backwards. They had been approximately half an hour in this road. Ha talked to the other men by pushing his mouthpiece on one side. Bill Hughes and Jack Lewis seemed to get alarmed and jostled for supremacy of leadership out. He saw one, who bad got about 40 yd., fall. This turned out to be Lewis. His mouthpiece was on and the nosepiece was on, and the apparatus was working, but he was dead. Proceeding, he got close to Bill Hughes, who was lying down. His nose-clip was off and he was apparently dead. The other man, Dan Hughes, was in front, very unsteady on his feet. Witness assisted Dan Hughes out for a matter of 45 to 50 yd., when he fell on top of him. When he examined the apparatus he found that the feed pipe from the oxygen had become disconnected off the bite. Dan Hughes was alive on his knees, crumpled up. Witness made his way out to within 10 or 12 yd., when he was met by two men who dragged him out neck and crop. Asked how he thought the joint of the breathing apparatus came undone, Williams said he thought it was in wrestling with Dan Hughes. Sir Henry suggested to witness that his instructions were only to find out the conditions of the air in the airway. Witness said they were told there was the probability of men being alive in 20's place. Medical Evidence. Dr. S. W. Fisher, of the Mines Department, who examined the bodies which were recovered from the pit, said the cause of death in each case was carbon monoxide poisoning. Death was only a matter of minutes. He came to that conclusion not only from blood tests, but from the fact that when the explosion occurred and the air was reversed so that fresh air reached the clutch, the men were already dead. Five of the bodies at the clutch showed effects which indicated that they had met with the greatest force of the explosion at that part. He found no indication at all of coal dust pitting. Sir Henry pointed out that a curious thing about the bodies found was that one which was close to some of the others was neither burned nor injured at all. Dr. Fisher said in his opinion that man at the time the flame went up the drift was seated behind a tub which diverted the flame right and left. He fell unconscious immediately, and never moved again. At this point Sir Henry Walker mentioned that between the present sitting and the next he would hold a conference with the pit surveyor and others in order that a new chart could be made showing the exact position of the bodies, etc., after the explosion. He was not satisfied with the present one. A Special Investigation Promised. Following some evidence from a brick-setter who was in the Martin shaft at the time of the explosion, Mr. Peter Lee, for the Miners' Federation, asked whether, in view of what they had heard that day, it was intended to call the chief man of the rescue brigades. Sir Henry said he hoped to hold a separate inquiry about the rescue operations at this pit and throughout North Wales generally. It would be entirely separate, because the rescue operations had nothing to do with the cause of the explosion. Mr. Shawcross concurred, and said he apprehended that a number of parties interested in the matter were not present at the inquiry. Escape from the Workings. The court now heard the story of how the six survivors made their way out of the pit, four of them being called to the witness stand together. The narrative was chiefly left to John Edward Samuels. Samuels related how the first hint of disaster was a violent thud followed by dust. His brother said "What the Hell's up ?" and he replied; "The bloody bottom's gone." The dust was like a wall. They found a lot of men standing at the road end, men who were quite excited, and he told them to keep calm and make for the wind road. They got to the top end of the face and on an old road. They started going down this old wind road and some men turned back saying that they could not get down as there was too much gas. Witness related how they found the dead body of Wally Hughes and how Andrews was almost overcome through trying to get the body out of an airway. The fireman opened a door a matter of a few inches and there was a small puff of wind. They shouted to the fireman to close it, as they could smell burning. A man named Crump came up and told them there were some doors further along, and he (witness) said if they could get beyond the doors they would be all right. They called on the other men and told thorn to get whatever they could-rags, caps, shirts, singlets, etc-and to fan themselves and follow. They carried on until they came to the ladders. The fireman said he was done, but they got him to the ladders. When they all got up the ladders, the air was fresher. Just as they got up the bye-end there came a big rush of wind. Presently they got to the clutch and after passing falls and overturned tubs met Mr. Andrew Williams the under-manager and later Mr. Bonsall. Witness explained to Sir Henry that the only way to get the fireman out was on his hands and knees and they fanned around him for most of the way. They saw something smouldering, but he was not sure it was a red-hot cable. Fisher said that it would be about two o'clock when they had the first warning, and that it was about 3.30 a.m. when they met Mr. Williams. The Adjournment. Sir Henry Walker then addressed the court. He said he did not think they could get much further until there was an opportunity to go underground and try to find by exploration the cause of the disaster. He went on to say that he and his colleagues were well satisfied with the way the inquiry had gone and the behaviour of those who had attended. They must adjourn without date. Mr. Henderson prefaced his tribute to Sir Henry and his two colleagues with a reference to the question of sealing-up the pit and an interim report. He said those who had been instructing him had been very much concerned because a suggestion had been made that it was contemplated sealing-off, or advising the sealing-off, of the Main Dennis district. Their strong and unanimous view was that it was undesirable that anything in the way of an interim report should be published. Sir Henry said he did not know how far his authority as Commissioner ran in connection with the sealing-off. He thought it was a matter he must report to the Secretary for Mines. Mr. Cyril Jones, legal adviser to the North Wales Miners' Association, said he had not been consulted with regard to an interim report, and he would like to express his own personal opinion that there should be a time limit. If no interim report were issued and an investigation of the mine could not be made for many months, it meant that they would get out of touch with the details. Sir Henry said he would discuss the matter with the Secretary for Mines, and remarked that Mr. Ernest Brown, the Secretary for Mines, had disclosed intentions of having an interim report.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||