|
14th December 1934, Page: 1105, Column: 1 The Gresford ExplosionTechnical EvidenceThe official inquiry into the causes and circumstances of the Gresford Colliery explosion was continued on Friday at Wrexham by Sir Henry Walker, H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines, when it had already lasted 23 days. Inspectors Called. On the previous day evidence had been given by Mr. T. Boydell (H.M. senior inspector of mines). During 2½ years, he said, he went to Gresford on seven occasions-each time the occasion of a fatal accident. He had not been able to make any detailed inspection himself. Mr. Hartley Shawcross (for the owners) questioned Mr. Boydell about a suggestion that had been made to him that the accident rate at Gresford was higher than anywhere else, and the witness agreed that during the years he had been in charge of the district there was only one in which the accident rate at Gresford was higher than elsewhere in North Wales or Great Britain, and on that occasion it was 0.32 per 100,000 man-shifts worked. Taking fatal accidents, the rate per 100,000 man-shifts worked from 1929-33 at Gresford was considerably lower than the average in Great Britain. The percentage of accidents dropped from 71.64 to 61.52 per cent. per 100,000 man-shifts worked and the position at Gresford in comparison with the average over the whole country was very favourable. Mr. William John Charlton (H.M. divisional inspector of mines), who was next called as a witness, said when Mr. Dominy came North Wales was a diminishing coal field, and it was thought wise that he should visit pits in other areas so that he might set against each other. There were 286 pits in the division last year, and about half were large ones. He was full to overflowing. Mr. Charlton agreed that he was entirely dependent upon sub or junior inspectors who visited the pits, drawing his attention to conditions, etc. He had no plans of all the mines in his office, and agreed with Sir Stafford Cripps that it would be of great assistance if he had the plans, but if ever he was concerned about ventilation he would get them. Questions were put about stone dust, special reference being made to the disparity in the analysis of the departmental officials on one side and the colliery company on the other. Witness said he was afraid he did not do anything, as many other things had turned up at the time. Records were quoted about stone-dust samples taken, and it was shown that, in 1932, 19 per cent. of these samples were found not to comply. Questioned as to records of overtime, the witness agreed that the books did not disclose all the overtime and that there had been a breach of the regulations. The Electrical Plant. Evidence was also given by Mr. James Cowan, junior electrical inspector of mines, that shortly after his appointment in 1930 he made his only visit to Gresford Colliery prior to the explosion. He then saw a coal-cutting machine, certain conveyors, and other electrical plant. He suggested to Mr. Bonsall the provision of additional control stages, and the manager agreed. Mr. James Arthur Bennett Horsley, H.M. Chief Electrical Inspector of Mines, said he had only visited Gresford on one occasion before the explosion in October 1920, when they had no electric plant except some pumps. He had reports from the company of their intention to introduce electricity in 1927 and 1929, but at that time he had no assistants so the pit was not visited. Witness had heard all the evidence with respect to the electrical plant and the breakdown had examined the log book kept as required by the regulations, and was generally satisfied that nothing abnormal had occurred at Gresford in the last 13 months. The main supply cable, so far as fire risk was concerned, was undoubtedly safer than other types used in some collieries, and the portable apparatus cables were of suitable character very commonly used throughout the country for similar purposes. They were acceptable both legally and from an engineering point of view. The distribution system was satisfactory. It could be improved, but there were no obvious errors. He would prefer contact breakers at every point where the cable branched off. The leakage-protection system with trips at the pit bottom was a valuable adjunct to the safety of the pit. Questioned as to the mishaps to the electrical plant, which were recorded in the log book, witness said the only thing unusual about them was the frankness with which they were recorded. He could not conceive a sustained arc arising unless the leakage trip system was out of order. With a trailing cable they might get a sustained flash. Stone Dust Supplies. On Friday Mr. W. J. Charlton was recalled by Mr. Hartley Shawcross to deal with a number of technical points on ventilation. After this he was asked if he understood the inspector's reports on dust samples, and said he had no reason to feel satisfied with the condition of the roads at Gresford as revealed by the reports. Mr. Boydell then produced several reports dealing with a discussion about the quantity of stone dust used at Gresford between him, Mr. Bonsall and Mr. Cockin (officials of the pit). This, he said, took place in August 1932. He was given an undertaking that further quantities of stone dust would be purchased from outside sources Exploders and Coal Dust. Capt. C. B. Platt, superintendent testing officer for the Mines Department at Sheffield, explained how he had made tests with the mining magneto telephone as used in Gresford. He was of opinion that it was an unsafe type of instrument. It was capable of producing a spark which would ignite firedamp, and he was quite sure about this. Later, he said he had learned that there had been discrepancies between the samples analysed in his department and the samples analysed by the colliery company, and he remarked that they were liable to error in the determination of the percentage of stone dust. He would not swear to the result of the analyses of stone dust in 1932, and he would be prepared to find that someone else had got different results On Sir Stafford Cripps suggesting that either the whole of Capt. Platt's results were entirely valueless — and upon them, he said, the whole safety of mines in this country was dependent — or else he should take some means to see whether they were accurate or not. Witness said this inaccuracy might not refer to all the samples. Check analyses which, to his recollection, never varied more than 0.5 per cent. or 1.0 per cent. were taken to test the degree of accuracy. This was the first time he had heard of a difference of 20 per cent. Of course, the other man might be wrong. At this point Sir Henry Walker said, on the Sunday after the explosion he collected a sample of the duet which was lying on a roller about 150 yd. from the top of 142's deep. That was the only sample of dust he knew of which was collected after the explosion. This was the bottle Sir Henry produced to a witness on the previous day. Sir Henry then asked Capt. Platt to announce to the court the result of his analysis, which showed that the dust contained 50.6 per cent. of ash, 3.8 per cent. of moisture, 11.4 of carbon dioxide, and 34.2 of combustible matter. Sir Henry then produced a bottle from his pocket and asked Capt. Platt to identify it as the bottle containing the remains of this sample of stone dust that had been analysed. Capt. Platt said it was the bottle he had returned Owners' Case Opened. Mr. Shawcross now called the first witness on behalf of the colliery company. This was James Morris, who said he had been employed at the colliery for about eight years, and for the last year had been working in 29's. He was a chargeman, and he tested for gas every morning, but found none. The ventilation was good, but he would admit the air was warm. He had seen stonedusting on the face and clay used for stemming. The return airway, he considered, was a very good road. Witness admitted that he had seen gumming used and three or four holes charged together, and then the shots tired one after the other. John Thomas Griffiths, another chargeman in 29's, said it was very rare, he found gas, and there was a special man for the purpose of carrying out stone-dusting. They had plenty of clay for stemming, and they only used gumming when they were short of clay. Similar evidence was given by Frederick Edwards, also a chargeman. He agreed with Sir Stafford that runaways were fairly frequent. He had never seen stone dust used between the shots, but always before. Richard Davies, who described himself as a charter-master, said he had seen stone dust freshly dune in different places on the morning shift. On witness describing how he used a little rubber ball with a hole in it to get into holes where his lamp would not go, Sir Henry congratulated him and said if a few other people adopted that method it would be a very useful thing. Other witnesses testified to the good conditions in 29's district. Robert Dodd, a repairer, described how he was engaged for a long time stone-dusting part of the district. Sir Stafford pressed the witness to give the quantity of stone dust he used each day, and finally, after starting from an estimate of 10 min. to get rid of a half hundredweight bag full, counsel worked it out that Dodd used 36 bags a day, making 5 tons a week for 160's road alone. The witness then said "I never used that much, but I know I was kept very busy stone-dusting." Witness said he was stone-dusting on the haulage road when haulage was in progress, and he added that the workmen at the face made it rather unpleasant for him when he stone-dusted there. The inquiry was adjourned until the following Tuesday. A Question as to Prosecutions. A long succession of witnesses, called on behalf of the owners on Tuesday, testified to the general safety of the mine, such as the adequacy of ventilation and of stone-dusting, care in shot-firing, the comparative absence of gas, and the assiduity with which its dispersal was undertaken. In the course of the proceedings on Tuesday, a suggestion came from Mr. Joseph Hall, for the Mineworkers' Federation of Great Britain, that either Sir Henry Walker, or some other representative of the Mines Department, might occupy the witness stand for the purpose of explaining why no prosecutions followed when it was seen that samples of dust exceeded 50 per cent. of combustible. Sir Henry replied that he would see what the Department had to say in the matter. One witness, when confronted with Sir Henry's bottle of dust, said the dust in the mine was lighter in colour. Another chiefly employed in stone-dusting, said he did about 300 yd. in a shift. A good deal of the stone dust floated in the air, and in some cases it was higher than the rails. A repairer in 109's district said there was no gas except in a cavity, and it was cleared as made. Another stone-duster declared that he dusted from 23's face down up to the Thursday before the explosion, and used the dust even when the haulage was going and men were cutting coal. A doggie in 109's said the bandjack was never used in 80's place before the accident, as he was boring with it in 23's. It was also stated by an elderly witness that two tubs of stone dust and two tubs of clay were sent down each week in 80's and 81's. Another witness admitted it was "hellish hot" in the very bottom of 109's. A Hosepipe Incident. On Wednesday further witnesses were called by Mr. Shawcross to testify to the underground conditions in the Dennis section. Sir Henry closely examined a witness named Owens about the date of an incident when he, together with his mate, Lloyd, and Fireman Harold Thomas, crawled on their hands and knees through the old road with an electric lamp in order to get a hosepipe out. Lloyd, recalled, said their flame lamps never went out, but were on the point of going out when Owens went for an electric lamp. Witness could not give the exact date, but said there were two different occasions when they tried to get out a hosepipe when using an electric lamp. One was shortly before the September fall, and the other some time previously. Fireman Harold Thomas said both witnesses were mistaken. They were mixing up two occasions. The time that he with Lloyd and Owens crawled through to get out the pipe was on the day after the fall at the beginning of September. Owens, recalled, said, he thought it might be a mistake on his part. Edward Daniel Roberts, Ponciau, who had been engaged in ripping and strapping in 14's, said he saw plenty of stone-dusting. On the day of his arrival at Gresford Colliery he noticed that the men who were coming up from the pit had white dust on their boots, and he remarked to his brother who was with him, "I think we are going to work in a flour mill." The Last Men Out. Samuel Wright, a shot-firer's assistant, who said he was the last man to leave 14's before the night shift came on, declared that the conditions at. that time, a quarter to midnight, were no different from those on any other day. The method of cleaning up and stone dusting the main haulage road in the Dennis district was described by William Pritchard, who was responsible for the section from the pit bottom to the clutch. He said it took him two shifts to clean up 140 yd. and another shift to stone-dust the portion he had cleaned up. In cross-examination he said he completed the whole section of the roadway from the shaft to the clutch in four weeks. It later appeared that witness was only working three days a week, and he then admitted that if it took him a week on half-time to do 140 yd., the complete job stretched over seven weeks. Wright, who was recalled, said he was at the top end of 14's for about two hours on the Friday night-between 9.45 p.m. and 11.46 p.m., and he was not affected in any way. The next witness, Ellis Davies, of Wrexham, deposed to cleaning and stone-dusting in the Dennis deep from the clutch to 20's junction, and said some of the men used to complain about the stone-dusting. It would take six weeks to clean up the road and stone-dust. Henry Tomlinson, a rope-splicer, said the first news of disaster was when the engine driver came and said, " Come on up, or you'll be suffocated." This was close upon 1.30 in the morning. When he was up the Martin the fumes were proper thick, and he put his hat over his face to run for stretchers. The electric light at the pit bottom had not gone out. The visibility was thick with fumes, and one could smell burning like timber on fire. He smelt burning rubber later on when he went down by the clutch. Witness went on to say that he was the first down with Mr. Davies to Bates's road. Their eyes were smarting, but one could see. Further evidence in regard to the rescue operations was given yesterday. Fred Davies, overman, described the efforts made to extinguish the fire under the top side of 29's district. Questioned by Mr. Shawcross, he said that there might have been further fires beyond and if there were fumes they would go round the 29's junction 20's and 61's airways. Mr. William Bonsall, the manager, said that there were three falls which he and others had to climb over before getting to the point where they smiw the fire. They could see very little because of the smoke. The witness told how efforts to subdue the fire were made persistently, described time rescue work, and said a suspicion of his that 20's return airway was charged with poisonous gas was proved to be well founded. In reply to Sir Henry Walker he said that it would have been impossible, even if smoke helmets had been used down the Dennis Deep, to get at the fire. The inquiry was adjourned until to-day.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||