|
30th November 1934, Page: 1011, Column: 1 Gresford Colliery ExplosionResumed InquiryAfter a week's adjournment, the inquiry into the cause of the Gresford Colliery disaster, in which 265 lives were lost, was resumed on Tuesday at Wrexham by Sir Henry Walker, H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines. It was the sixteenth day of the proceedings. Relighting of Lamps. The first witnesses called were men engaged on the main haulage roads, directing the tubs going to and from the face. They were all closely questioned about the amount of stone dust they saw passing them, sad those whose duty it was to relight lamps gave estimates of the number of occasions they were called upon to perform this task. Arthur Pickering said that the number depended upon "how awkward the men were." Very often he had lit as many as five lamps before the men even started work. Boys generally brought the lamps for him to light, and there had been occasions when night men who had stayed late came to him with a dark lamp to he relighted so that it was possible for them to go out. In reply to Mr. W. J. Charlton (H.M. divisional inspector of mines), witness said he used to light more lamps for men who were near him than for men who were further in. He was teaching a boy to light lamps at the finish. He kept the relighter locked because he found one or two broken glasses coming out, but it was now two years since he had had a broken glass. Dealing with the conditions of the roads, witness said he would rather stop down there when the men were going out. "It was choking, and you had to let the dust settle before you could get up." He had been down the Deep, and previous to the order about stone dusting it was "a treat to walk on." Nobody liked to walk from the bottom of the Dennis to the Deep with three boys in front of them. During the examination of John Ankers, who unlashed tubs at the topside of the clutch, he told Mr. Joseph Hall, of the Miners' Federation, that sometimes the tubs came off the rails and the chains were twisted. He used a piece of rail to straighten the chain. He never noticed sparks. Conditions at the Shaft Bottom. Another description of the scene in the pit at the moment of the explosion was given by one of the rescued men, Henry Swift, who was employed near the pit bottom lashing the empty tubs. Witness said that on the night of the explosion the haulage was stopped for about 10 min. when some tubs came off the road. The first he knew that something was wrong was that the electric lights went out, after which dust came up in the air. — About 20 sec. later the air came the reverse way, but he would not say it was very strong. They bad had a flame lamp hanging up on a hook about 5 yd. away, and it gave just a faint glow. He went to the telephone and tried to phone the clutch to see what was wrong, but the line was dead. Witness, answering further queries, stated that two electricians and a boy were near to him at the time. The last he saw of Chesters, the night fireman, before the explosion was when Chesters passed him going down towards the clutch about 11.15 p.m. A seventeen-year-old boy, Harold Platt, whose duty it was to open and shut the middle door in 29's district in order to let "journeys" through, told the court that he was on the afternoon shift prior to the disaster. The door he was in charge of was difficult to open, and it was necessary for him to put his foot against the posts and pull with both hands on account of the pressure of air. When he opened the door a lot of wind went through. Stone Dusting Practice. Mr. Charlton intimated at this juncture that a number of men who were responsible for stone dusting in the Martin pit would be called to explain their practice. They were unable to get positive evidence about stone dusting in the Dennis section, as unfortunately all the men who did it in the Dennis were now dead. The Electrical Apparatus. A long examination on the electrical appliances in the pit was made by Mr. Horsley, Chief Electrical Inspector of Mines, when Josiah E. Hague, chief electrician at Gresford, was called. He said all the electrical apparatus was safe from firedamp throughout the pit as far as he knew. He agreed that in many cases when a cable was cut a flash would occur, but commented that immediately the cable became earthed, the switch dropped out at the pit bottom. Dealing with the occurrence on June 29 in 14's district, when a coal cutter which was being loaded on a trolley got out of hand, witness said the jib of the cutter severed the main cable. This resulted in the pit bottom circuit breaker coming out and shorting the whole length. Sir Stafford Cripps quoted several electrical mishaps from the log book to witness, and Hague agreed that they were typical examples of the dangerous trouble experienced in a pit using electric machinery. He added that since the electrification of 29's and 14's there had been no inspection by the inspectors. Mr. Joseph Hall asked if there were any men at Gresford who were cutters, but who had experience of electricity, and witness replied that some of them had — probably one in every gang. In his opinion Gresford was a very safe pit and the ventilation was good. He had never heard of gas in Gresford at all until the explosion. Miners' Evidence. On Wednesday Sir Stafford Cripps called his miner witnesses to give their account of conditions in the pit prior to the explosion. Each witness in turn complained of the excessive heat, and quoted instance after instance of shots being stemmed with coal dust, of firemen firing shots without intermediate examinations for gas, of complaints that were ignored. It was alleged that stone dust was rarely used on the coal face in certain districts. John Taylor, a ripper on the night shift, who was absent on the night of the explosion, described how on the Tuesday before the explosion he drove a hole through into 24's road and his lamp went out. He told Sam Matthias, the fireman, and he said he would get some brattice from 81's. Witness never got the brattice, so he covered the hole where the gas was coming from with some old sleepers and dirt. On Thursday when he was told to enlarge the hole, he suggested to the firemen that it would be dangerous. Witness bored a hole a little further up and Matthias fired a shot there. He told the fireman he did not like the smell or the heat. His lamp then went out with a puff, and Matthias shouted for another light, but afterwards went away and did not return until four o'clock, when he asked witness and his mate to clean out the manholes on another road as the inspector was coming down owing to a lad having his leg broken. In cross-examination by Mr. Hartley Shawcross (for the owners), witness said he was reopening a ventilation road which had been closed for two or three weeks prior to the explosion. He was not surprised to find gas coming out, and he always considered the conditions at that place very dangerous. Asked if he had reported the matter to anyone who was alive, witness said he had told his wife. He did not report to the pit committee. Fears of Victimisation. When Mr. Frowen, of the National Federation of Colliery Deputies, suggested that one of the roads could be travelled according to a fireman's report, the witness said "Well, if the fireman says that, I would say he would be a liar." Mr. Frowen mentioned the names of several workmen's officials to whom witness could have complained. Taylor said he was afraid of victimisation from the colliery company if he made complaints. He told Sir Henry Walker that he had never seen reports posted at the pithead. In further cross-examination by Mr. W. T. Miller, Taylor stated that on the Tuesday before the disaster he found firedamp after a shot had been fired. He knew it was firedamp by the blue flash shooting up into the flame shield. In reply to Mr. Charlton witness said he first became uneasy when he was ordered to split the air in the heading going up towards the fault. It was so hot down there that he could not go into the heading at all. A long argument ensued as to the propriety of complaints by workmen to the inspectors and Sir Henry said they always had instructions to attend to anonymous complaints. Examined by Sir Henry, the witness admitted that after he had gone inbye and the fireman outbye, he (witness) landed out a shot after it was fired before the fireman. William Davies, employed in the 14's district doing repair work on the return airway, in answer to Mr. Arthur Henderson, jun., said the conditions of the road got so bad as they got further in that progress was very slow. At one place they could only get through on their knees. Witness referred to a number of occasions when he found gas in scourings, and said he reported the matter to the fireman. Holes were charged six at a time, and stemmed with gumming taken from the face. He did not see any inspection for gas between the shots and had never seen stone dust used at the face. Asked by Mr. Shawcross if he did not think these practices were improper and dangerous, witness said it was a question of closing one a mouth or being victimised. He did not know there was a pit committee. There were cases where they knew inspectors were coming in the day before they arrived, and everything was got ready for them, but he admitted that that was in another colliery some years ago. Miners and Firemen. Ralph James Rogers, who had been employed in 14's district from February until September 13, when he met with an accident, was asked about the conditions, and replied, "It was very hot there. There wasn't a breath of air and no draught at all. I worked in a bathing costume with the top cut off." Witness went on to state that their lamps were continually going out 20 to 30 yd. from the top end of the face, and he had seen the fireman's lamp go out. Shortly before his (witness's) accident three men refused to go up the face because of gas, and the fireman said "If the afternoon men can work up there our men can." The bandjack was continually disconnected and the air blowing out to provide ventilation. Gumming was used for stemming all the shots. It was slack off the ground, and he had thrown it in himself. He had never seen stone dusting at all at the face, the nearest place being 250 yd. away. Witness told how he bad never seen regular tests for gas by firemen or a test even after the fireman's lamp went out. The fireman used to fetch the pipe to clear the gas. As in the case of previous witnesses, Rogers said he had made no complaints about conditions beyond mentioning it to the firemen. In reply to Sir Henry Walker, he said that Seth Davies, one of the firemen, rammed five or six holes at a time, fired one after another, made no examination between shots, and in many cases the chaps went up to couple their own shots, and Davies remained at his battery. On the other hand, Richard Jones would only ram one shot at a time. They tried to get him to do more but he wouldn't. A "Red Hot" Mine. Yet another series of allegations came from William Melling, who said he had been a miner since he was eleven years of age, and was now forty-eight. He had worked in Kent, Lancashire, Yorkshire and Shropshire. He had been at Gresford since February, and when asked what the temperature was like, exclaimed tersely "Red hot!" He had complained to firemen Thomas and Amos about gas, and had never seen stone dust applied except on one occasion when he understood an inspector was coming round. Witness went on to allege that a quarter of a tub of stone dust had been 200 yd. from the face since last February. He also stated that gumming was tried for stemming, and he had seen as many as seven holes charged at once. At one time T. H. Davies, shot-firer, tested for gas and refused to fire shots. It was at snapping time, and Harold Thomas, the fireman, brought a battery and cable, asked where the two holes were, told witness to fetch the compressed air pipe and blow on the holes, and then fired the shots when witness had gone for his snapping. Cross-examined by Mr. Shawcross, Melling said 14's face was often packed with gas from floor to roof. The only man he knew who had refused to fire shots was Davies. Sir Stafford observed that Davies was the only fireman they had not seen so far. Asked why he did not report to the management, witness said he had been told by Harold Amos to shot his mouth or else get out of it. He afterwards declared that the management did know that the situation was dangerous. He admitted that the conditions were improving slightly about the last three weeks before the explosion but added that the compressed air pipes were being used practically all the time. On one occasion Mr. Williams, the under-manager, told him to put his air pipe in and bring the men oust. Witness did not bother to take any further steps to complain after his first intimation to the fireman had gone no further. Evidence of Gassing. Other miners gave evidence yesterday. Edward Matthews, a collier, said that on the night of this explosion he said to a cutter going on the night shift, "God help you, Tom: you have got a hell of a place to go to to-night." Alfred Tomlinson, another collier, said there was a gully in the coal face, and when he put his head rip he got a dose of gas. The fireman, to whom he suggested the inadvisability of firing a shot there "dabbed his hand across my mouth and told me to shut up." Witness said sickness from the gas was a general complaint ; men were always complaining. Asked if he took any steps to bring this to the notice of the management. Tomlinson said "I told the fireman, who was our boss. Seven of us wanted to go home the Friday before the disaster happened, but we did not; we were afraid of losing our jobs." Questioned by Sir Henry Walker, Tomlinson replied that on one occasion when a fireman proposed firing two shotholes, he said to the fireman, "If you fire those you will blow us to hell." That was in the last six weeks before the disaster. Sir Henry observed that the fireman had previously told the court that that conversation never took place. Thomas Gibson, a collier, said that it was so hot in the part of the pit in which he worked that he wore shorts and sometimes nothing except stockings and shoes. He had known shotfirers refuse to fire shots, and shortly afterwards a fireman would come along and fire the shots. The inquiry was adjourned until to-day.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||