23rd November 1934, Page: 957, Column: 1
Miners' Welfare Fund
Future Policy
The annual conference of the district committees which advise as to the allocation of the Miners' Welfare Fund was held in Lou-doss on Tuesday. Major-Gen. The Rt. Hon. Sir Frederick Sykes, the chairman of the Central committee, presided and opened the
meeting with a discussion of the future policy of the fund. An occasion for reconsideration of policy arises out of the Act which was passed earlier this year, reducing the amount of the welfare levy on the output of coal from 1d. to ½d. per ton and
prolonging its life for another 18 years. The chairman's remarks were followed by general discussion of policy, and the business dealt with also included a number of special problems of administration. The conference was attended by representatives from
24 coal field districts.
In the course of his remarks, the chairman said he felt the need for personal contact with the districts. The revenue of the district funds was much reduced. In some districts it was not much more than a quarter of what it was before the Act. Plans laid
upon the basis of 1d. per ton had been upset and new plans most be made. Every district committee would need to settle a policy, and to arrange a programme for some years ahead, say, the next five years or so. It was necessary, however, to settle what
were to be the future principles of policy. One or two districts had set themselves to provide recreation facilities systematically at one locality after another, using what money was in the Fund for the time being in completing one scheme before dealing
with another. That policy, though it might not be universally acceptable, was economical and had been proved to be capable of achieving excellent results. Some districts, on the other hand, had spread their money over most, if not all, of their mining
communities providing each with a recreation scheme of some form or other, some completed, others in the making. This "colliery quota" basis for allocating money to recreation schemes without reference to what recreation facilities they already
had, had already been abandoned by some districts which adopted it at first, and the Central Committee suggested that this would, as a rule, be the wise course. While not denying that. a large colliery, contributing heavily to the Fond out of its
relative prosperity, had strong claim to liberal welfare provision, the point might come, and in a number of instances had actually been reached, where a local committee found itself with a call upon money for adding luxuries, whilst a less fortunate
community in the same district was wanting for reasonable provision of welfare necessities. Need should be given greater weight than size of contributions. It often happened that a large colliery with practically constant work and near to a town had a
complete welfare scheme, and in addition, all the amenities of the town. It often happened that a small colliery in an isolated spot with irregular work had a poor type of wooden building lit by oil lamps and heated by some inferior type of heating. It
was usually poorly furnished. The fabric needed constant looking after and renewing. He felt sure that when Lord Sankey's Commission visualised the Miners' Welfare Fund, what they had in mind principally was the isolated colliery village, and the need
that such a place has for a good well-built permanent building, nicely furnished, which could serve as a social centre for the district and be inexpensive to keep in good condition and use. The large community could usually secure a reasonable standard
of welfare provision at a lower cost per head than a small community. It cost more per head to provide for the few than to provide for the many, if all were to have an equal standard. Therefore the first principle of policy for the future was deficiency
or need of welfare provision.
The second principle was that fresh capital outlay on recreation schemes should in the main go to supplementing revenue-producing activities and means of attracting interest in the scheme. The work of the immediate future was to consolidate existing
welfare schemes, to see that they were equipped so as to be self-supporting and that they were of such a character as to ensure their permanence. At this stage it seemed, broadly speaking, to be of greater importance to secure the future of the existing
welfare schemes than to set afoot fresh ventures, excepting where an isolated or necessitous locality had been neglected. The Central Committee suggested that the districts should re-examine their welfare schemes from this point of view.
Thirdly, programmes for the future might perhaps be framed so that haphazard development of a scheme would be avoided. The district committee and the local committee might in consultation make up their minds what was a suitable scheme for a given
locality and then plan the whole scheme before making another grant, even though money might. not be immediately available to provide for the whole. It might be possible so to design the scheme that its construction could be carried out in instalments
spread over a period of years as and when money becomes available. In designing any scheme it was desirable to base it on the principle of providing those types of activities that were suitable for use by the greatest numbers.
Sir Frederick, continuing, asked whether it would not be practicable to send in most of the recommendations for the year in one batch, or perhaps, in large districts, two batches. Then if there were any points to clear sip or any suggestions to make,
they could conveniently and expeditiously be dealt with together, perhaps, at a meeting between the central staff and the district committee to which the local committee could, if necessary, be summoned. He also emphasised the moral obligation to do all
they properly could to ensure the permanence of the schemes which had been set afoot. The outlay of five million pounds should not be jeopardised by deficiencies of management or by diminution of their utility. Instances had come to notice where the
schemes are hard up. The Central Committee could not agree to relax its rules against grants for running expenses. The man in charge of an institute or recreation scheme should be of such a standard as to be able to help with the activities. Beyond that
they could help the needy welfare scheme without making maintenance grants by improving their revenue-producing activities or providing new ones, or by reducing expenditure. Proper maintenance work must be carried out by the local management committee
regularly and at the right time, or the property provided out of the Welfare Fond would deteriorate, and the cost of putting things right would be magnified. As indoor schemes depended upon the superintendent, Sir Frederick emphasised the importance to a
welfare scheme of employing a man who was not only keen on the job, but one who had some real experience. District committees might exercise influence to avoid ill-chosen appointments. The ideal was obviously to have someone with special knowledge and
experience visiting the schemes regularly so as to he frequently in contact to give advice to the management committees or their employees upon their maintenance problems before difficulties arose and damage was done. In many districts the central staff
were already doing something in this direction by the desire of the district committees. The Central Committee was so impressed with the value and importance of this work that it had decided to add to the staff so as to enable them to visit snore
systematically and to cover more ground, by arrangement with the district committees and in co-operation with them.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Sykes, Frederick, Sir | | | |