|
16th November 1934, Page: 915, Column: 1 Gresford Colliery ExplosionAt Wrexham, on the 9th inst., Sir Henry Walker, H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines, continued his inquiry into the causes and circumstances of the explosion on September 22 at the Gresford Colliery, Denbighshire, by which 265 men lost their lives. This was the eleventh sitting. Following a demonstration in the morning about firemen's meetings by the miners in the public seats, the president, Sir Henry Walker, called two of his inspectors to refute suggestions that they had conferred with firemen since the inquiry. Firemen's Meetings. Proceedings began with the resumed cross-examination of Robert Thomas Edwards, the afternoon shift fireman of 109's, by Mr. Joseph Hall, of the Miners' Federation. He denied that the place was a "gasometer," but agreed that the faults gave off gas. Witness had just stated that he had never fired three shots together, when Mr. Hall inquired about the alleged meetings of firemen subsequent to the accident. Witness said he did not think that was a question that should he asked, and Sir Henry Walker, agreeing amidst applause, told Mr. Hall that they were not concerned with meetings after the disaster. He also threatened to clear the court. Resuming his questions, Mr. Hall elicited from the witness that his district was a little scattered and could not be called too big. He said the "doggies" would have to account to him for insufficient output of coal from the district, and he would then report to the manager or under-manager. On occasions he had poor production figures, but had not been shifted from his job. Mr. A. T. Miller (representing the owners) said a suggestion had been made that a meeting took place at the colliery on the previous Wednesday week. He wanted to make it quite clear that if such a meeting did take place at the colliery, the owners had nothing to do with it whatever. Sir Henry Walker then intimated that before going any further with the inquiry he desired to clear up the frequent references which had been made to firemen's meetings and the allegations that H.M. inspectors had held such meetings since the inquiry opened. He called into the witness-box Mr. T. Boydell and Mr. P. G. Dominy, the district inspectors. He asked Mr. Boydell whether since the explosion he had called or been present at any meeting of the firemen at Gresford. Mr. Boydell said he had been with firemen to take notes on the state of their districts prior to the explosion. He saw them two at a time in the office, but not since the inquiry started. Mr. Dominy, who was asked if he had seen the firemen since getting their statements, said he told Norman Parry that if he told any lies he would soon be found out. He had not spoken to any of them since the inquiry opened. Mr. W. J. Charlton, the divisional inspector, said as far as he was concerned the inspectors attended the colliery to gather information for this inquiry, and as it was collected it was passed on to the owners', firemen's and miners' representatives. Sir Henry said he hoped everybody was satisfied now. He was personally concerned about questions that had arisen suggesting that inspectors had consulted with firemen. So far as he was concerned if that had been established it would have been the first and last time they ever did it. Sir Henry also asked the witness to state definitely whether he was a member of the firemen's union prior to the explosion. Witness said there had been a break in his membership and agreed that he was a member at one time, dropped out, and was not a member at the time of the explosion. He had been admitted since. Charges of Subornation. The next witness called was Jonathan Harold Thomas, the day foreman of 14's. Witness stated that he had left instructions that only a small amount of coal should be got on the Saturday (the day of the disaster), because the men wanted to get away to the football match. The witness was then closely questioned by Mr. Henderson with regard to a number of falls in his district which obstructed the return airways, and referred to one in particular detail when five men were cut off. Witness said it did not happen in his shift, but he knew about it. He heard that two men were sent by the fireman to help the men cut off through the old return airway and thought it was quite likely that their lamps were put out by gas. Counsel then asked "Would you be surprised to hear that the men had to crawl through that airway for 120 yd.?" "I would not be surprised to hear anything," said witness, "the way many of these men are being paid to give evidence." There was an immediate uproar among the miners at the back of the court. This was immediately suppressed by Sir Henry Walker who said the less they heard about people being paid the better. Mr. Henderson agreed that it was a most improper answer. Sir Henry ordered that the whole incident be expunged from the records. Mr. Henderson then pursued a long series of questions regarding the presence of gas in the 14's district. Witness replied that it was as cool down the Dennis as in the Brassey. He denied that there were considerable quantities of gas during the six months preceding the disaster or that the men had complained about gas. He admitted that on occasions one of the shotfirers had refused to fire because of gas. He said he always instructed the shotfirer to carry on at another part of the face and to leave the gas to him. Sir Henry had to reprimand witness again during a discourse on the time it took to fire a shot, for making statements instead of giving simple answers. Witness had replied to Mr. Henderson, "If you say it takes eight minutes, I agree. If you say ten minutes. I agree. The question has been put too many times at this inquiry." Witness agreed that he stemmed as many as six shots before starting to fire and then fired them one after another. He admitted that he had used the compressed air bandjack to shift gas. It might be bad practice, but did not think it was against the Act. A Coal Cutter Accident. Witness gave a description of a scene in the pit three months before the explosion, when they had trouble with a coal cutter and there was a breakage in the electric cable. If there had been a trace of gas in his district that day he would not be at the inquiry that day. Asked for a fuller explanation of the accident, witness said they were lowering the machine to take it away for repairs when it ran away down the track at the side of the belt. It cut the main cable in half about 80 yd. from the face, and caused a flashback. Where it tipped up there had been a tub of stone dust emptied some time before. Thomas, answering further questions, said he had always been perfectly satisfied with the ventilation in 14's, and during the last month it had been better than in June and July. It was as good as he would expect to find in any mine of this depth in the country. Answering Mr. Hall, who suggested that from a health point of view a handgot face is best, witness said that as a young man he preferred the machine face. From a health point of view he did not think there was much in it. Sir Henry asked Mr. Hall if he was going to prove that and on Mr. Hall saying he could Sir Henry said he would give him until the following Tuesday to do it. A Place for Young Men. On Tuesday, Thomas, the day fireman, was again examined by Mr. Hall. He told him that the men on 14's face ranged from 25 to 40 years in age. Most of the men had asked to go there. There was no room at Gresford for old men, he said. As far as 14's district was concerned, all the men there, with the exception of two or three, were of the finest men in Gresford Colliery, and relations between them and him were happy. There was, however, a complaint from the men in June or July when they asked for an allowance. It was hot there. He made them an allowance from July 1. It was owing to the falls that they were allowed this for a matter of six shifts. He did threaten 15 men on the Thursday previous to the explosion because they were working without timber. They had been threatened more than once before. In reply to Mr. Harris, witness said he had never seen a blown. out shot or flames from a shot, and that he considered the condition of his district was better than previously. He would think the conditions were better than 90 per cent. of the collieries in this country. Answering Mr. Hartley Shawcross (for the owners), witness said that when he gave an estimate of twelve minutes for firing a shot he did not take into consideration the fact that in some cases he charged more than one hole at a time, and, therefore, one inspection before charging would do for all those holes. In answer to further questions put by Sir Henry, the witness said he searched the younger men because he thought the older men had more sense than to take prohibited articles into the pit. "I always put one finger into their pockets as well as feeling the outside," added Thomas. "If I put two in they thought I was pinching something out." Sir Henry closely questioned witness as to his reason for not inspecting a fenced off scouring in 14's every day, and the witness answered that he thought it was not necessary because it was an abandoned road and ventilation was not going in. He took the view that the scouting was fully abandoned, but Sir Henry said ha thought it was only temporarily abandoned, as men were working on the other side. Dealing with reports of gas following numerous falls in 14's, witness said it was his practice not to report gas which he found on his first inspection and which had been cleared by the second. This had happened in 14's on various occasions, chiefly at the top end of the face following falls. Next called to the witness-box was Harold Amos, the afternoon shift fireman in 14's. He said he doubted whether he had fired 21 shots on September 21, but he would have to be satisfied that he had if this number was in the records book. When he left at midnight on September 21 men in 14's were ripping, packing, and turning the belt over. As far as he knew no shots would be fired that night. Clearing Gas with Compressed Air. Prof. Wheeler, of the Mines Research Board, asked the witness how he used a bandjack to clear gas, and Amos said he put the pipe near the hole. He did not agree that it was a fairly common practice to use this method, and added that be himself had only used it once, and that was on the day before the explosion. He did not think the night man would have occasion to use it. He had never seen any sparks come out of the end of the pipe or anything like a flame. Mr. Henderson asked witness if he knew that Robert Jones, the night fireman, before he went down that night, was issued with 20 detonators, and in addition took 5 lb. of powder, while his assistant also had 5 lb. of powder? Witness said that would not indicate to his mind that Jones did intend to fire shots, as they were always taken down. Witness denied that he had fired four or five shots in succession without any examination between shots. Mr. Henderson asked the usual questions about the firemen's meeting, and witness said he was a look-out man at the colliery now. "He looked out for the bosses coming so as he could give the others the wire." Mr. Shawcross said he was instructed that it was the invariable practice that when a colliery was stopped and there was a prospect of it reopening shortly; to continue in employment not only the firemen who gave evidence, but all the other firemen. If Mr. Henderson said that these men were giving untrue evidence because they were employed, he (Mr. Shawcross) hoped he would say so frankly, and not in this undesirable way. Mr. Henderson objected to the suggestion that some of his questions were improper. Sir Henry said he liked everybody to get everything off their chest. He had let the questions go on in the hope that he would get something out of them. Mr. Shawcross said it would help if he knew to what issue the questions were directed. Answering Mr. Shawcross, the witness said it was a common practice for firemen to take in detonators and powder on every shift, whether they intended to fire or not. The first shot-firer to give evidence then entered the box. He was Seth Davies, who had worked in 14's district for three weeks prior to the explosion. Previously he had been night fireman in 14's, but had been off ill for nine weeks. He told Mr. Charlton that it was his practice to take 50 detonators down, and he had an assistant who stone-dusted for him before shots were fired. He generally charged about five shot-holes at a time in "W" formation. He fired them one after another. When he fired 50 shots in a shift he did not mean that he charged five holes on ten occasions. He moved about the face. Questioned about an occasion when he fired 58 shots in a shift, witness said this would be an exceptional occasion, and he would be working overtime. He used the fire-clay for stemming, which was sent down if it was nearby; if not, he used the under-clay, and, in his opinion, one was almost as good as the other. Mr. Henderson directed his questions to the time occupied by shot-firing, and witness said he was quite willing to accept the estimate of nine to ten minutes which had been given by previous witnesses. When a number of occasions were mentioned where he fired more shots than he himself had stated was possible in a sevenhour shift at the face, witness replied that he was working overtime on all those occasions. Interrogated about the use of compressed air for clearing gas, witness said it was not a desirable practice, but it was one they had to adopt sometimes. Stemming with Dirt. On Wednesday, Mr. Henderson elicited from Seth Davies, shotfirer in 14's, that what he called "under-clay" was bench dirt from directly under the seam. He agreed that when a coal cutter working in the bench dirt touched the coal a certain amount of coal dust would be mixed with the dirt, but asserted that he always made sure there was no coal dust mixed with the material when he used it for stemming. The management did not know he was using "under-clay" and sent supplies of fireclay to his district. Mr. Hall asked witness if it was not an unsafe practice to adopt in machine mining a method of firing shots when men were engaged in filling coal. The reply was that there was nothing to he said against it so long as the men were far enough away. Witness said he had not booked every hour he worked overtime, as he was paid at firemen's rates and did shotfirer's work. The management had never reduced his wages from the firemen's rate. He added that it was possible that two men fired shots on the face at the same time and he saw nothing against this practice. Mr. Hall interposed with a remark that if shotfiring as done at Gresford became a general thing then the country might expect bigger blows and explosions in time future than it had had in the past. In conclusion, Mr. Hall asked witness if he would rather be paid by the State or by a colliery company. Witness said it would not affect his duties, but perhaps it would be a safer job. The question of stemming was carried further by Mr. W. Frowen, and when witness had said that he used what was known as "gumming" pretty often, Sir Henry interposed with the remark, "It was a regular practice?" The witness agreed, and went on to say that he would use it again after the inquiry because in his opinion it was quite suitable and safe. Whatever name was used in describing the substance for stemming, it was the same throughout the North Wales coal field. He was perfectly satisfied it was incombustible. The Working of Overtime. Sir Henry said he would like to have proof that this man was working overtime on the occasions when he fired more than 45 shots. If he did so, his name should appear in the Eight Hours Register. Mr. Andrew Williams, the undermanager in charge of the Dennis district, was then recalled to prove two documents which had been prepared showing the number of men and boys who worked a double shift on the night of the explosion. In reply to Mr. Peter Lee, who asked if it was customary to allow firemen the power to let men go in on an extra shift without them being out of the pit the proper length of time, witness said it was the first time it had happened to his knowledge. In most cases the firemen consulted with him and he had already explained that this was aim exceptional occurrence because of the amount of absenteeism during the week of the Wrexham Carnival. Sir Henry said it was unnecessary to labour the point. He had already made a remark about the Eight Hours Act in this pit. Mr. Lee pointed out that 37 men and boys went in after being on the day shift contrary to the Act of Parliament and witness agreed. Simultaneous Charging. Another shotfirer from 14's district, Arthur Jones, said, in answer to Mr. Charlton, that he worked stripped to the waist. He usually charged six shots at a time, and ha got his stemming from underneath the coal. On September 21 he could not fire a shot at the top end of 14's face because there was gas in a cavity. Some time after fireman Amos and he had cleared it by using a bandjack and altering the ventilation, he did fire the shot and every. timing was all right. He denied that he had ever been present when it was not fit to fire and firing had taken place under the direction of fireman Amos. The day-shift fireman in 19's, Herbert Thomas, was next called. He is the brother of the other fireman Thomas, who made allegations about payment for evidence. He said, "That brother of mine has bullied me now and again about the two doors which were taking air from his district." Witness mentioned that the electrical cutter had been in his district for only about a fortnight, and that he would say his district was very well ventilated. Asked why he had not made a report of finding gas, witness said "Well, gas shifted is better than gas reported." Questions About Shotfiring. Next to be called to give evidence was Walter Davies, afternoon fireman in 29's, who told how he took 40 detonators but no explosives into the pit on September 21. Witness went on to declare that in the course of his shift on this Friday he found no gas anywhere, in spite of careful tests in the rippings, in the waste, and on the face. He regarded his district as well ventilated. The number of shots he fired that day was 38. He left the pit towards 10.15, having completed his inspection 10 min. previously. When he left the pit the cutter was across 158's road, but that was going to cut up as far as possible. 161's had got about 30 tubs to clear on the Saturday afternoon. But it was essential that they should have it clear to turn the conveyors over and get the places secure for the week-end. On the Friday night they would be filling on the conveyers and machine cutting with compressed air and electrical cutters. There would be no shots fired in any rippings, but there would be no coal. Cross-examined by Mr. Henderson, witness said his inspection would take roughly two hours, but on the other one, as he did no firing, it would take only an hour. The second inspection was bigger, and the two averaged a little over three hours. His time on the shift, starting from the fireman's cabin and finishing there, would be 7½ hours, and he agreed that this left him with about 4½ hours for other duties. He did not agree with Seth Davies that doing nothing but shotfiring would not average more than 40 to 45 shots in a shift. He would take 10 min. over one, but 15 min. over three, having previously rammed the bottom holes. In compliance with counsel's request, the witness detailed every movement in connection with this work, giving the approximate period for each, but pointing out that he had an assistant. When hue had concluded, Mr. Henderson said the whole time totalled up to 16½ min. Witness added that sometimes he fired more than three shots, in which case the rate per charge became reduced in proportion. Asked what was the largest number of shots he had charged at one time, witness said eight. He further stated that he gave only one warning to the men before firing a series of shots. He always told them, however, how many shots were going to be fired. The manager and under-manager did not know that he was adopting this practice. When he fired 53 shots he worked a double shift of 17 hours, spending four hours shotfiring without stopping. In most cases he charged groups of six or eight at a time. Further Evidence of Shotfiring. Yesterday, Walter Davis, a fireman in 29's district, was questioned by Mr. Henderson regarding his method of shotfiring, and said that on some shifts he had fired as many as 40 shots. His district was a small one. Mr. Hall pointed out that from September 1 to the day of the disaster 17 shifts had been worked in No. 29 district, and a total of 2,143 shots had been fired. He asked Sir Henry Walker to get from the colliery company the tonnage produced in No. 29 district since September 1 with a view to comparing, if possible, the percentage of explosives used for every ton of coal. Also a record of the overtime worked by the firemen and shotfirers, so that they could ascertain the cost of explosives per ton of coal. Story of an Escape. The next witness was David Jones, night fireman at No. 29, who with five others escaped from the pit by means of a return airway. Questioned by Mr. Charlton, Jones said he started work about 9.40 on the night of the explosion. He made a tour of his district and tested for gas. The tests were negative. He fired ensue shots to dress down the face, and before each shot was fired made a careful inspection for gas. He used under-clay for stemming, and his assistant stone dusted the road before the shots were fired. Shortly before 2 o'clock he was engaged in booking the men time. His assistant held a lamp while he did so. He continued "Suddenly I heard a loud blast like the sound of a bursting air pipe which threw me off my feet. I lost my light and the boy lost his." Some stones and dust were flying about. They went to the end of the roadway and witness to d the men there to make their way to 158. He thought there was a possibility of shutting off the compressed air, which he believed was blowing the dust about owing to the burst. Shortly afterwards Jones met another man, Collins, and they decided to try to get the men out through a return airway. There was a smell of burning wood and the atmosphere was warm. Six of them made their way to the airway. They got near the entrance of the airway and they saw a man lying on the ground a few yards away. They formed a chain and pulled him out. They tried to bring him round with artificial respiration, but he was dead. Jones continued "There was gas about. I could feel it in my head. We could not get to a door because of it. I told the men, 'We are in a trap. We have to get out of it,' and one suggested that we should bide the time because things might quieten down. I said I was going to open a door on the bottom side in the hope of getting some fresh sir and break down the gas. I opened the door for three or four minutes, and the men shouted, 'There's a move.' I shut the door." A Red-hot Cable. Continuing, Jones said he hoped they would be able to get up the Martin return airway. Fisher went in front wafting his shirt, and they came to a ladder. Witness's legs were beginning to go because of the gas, but on going up the ladder in the air shaft he revived a little. They went on towards the main Dennis and on the way stumbled over the body of a horse Jones added that he saw what appeared to be a red-hot electric cable. He also noticed a smell. Sir Henry Walker Was it like a smell you get after the firing of explosives ? — No. They cause to a big fall and saw a number of wagons turned over and twisted girders. They climbed through the fall and then in the distance saw the lights of a rescue party headed by Mr. Williams, the under-manager. Sir Henry Walker said Jones made a statement to him on flue Monday following the disaster, and the first he (Sir Henry) had heard of the red-hot cable was now. Jones I made one or two slips in my statement, but many things happened, and when one contemplates and looks back they come to mind. Sir Henry Walker It was a very harrowing time for you. No doubt you were confused easily afterwards. The inquiry was adjourned until to-day.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||