9th November 1934, Page: 885, Column: 1
The Depressed Areas
Commissioners' Proposals
The Ministry of Labour has issued the reports of the Commissioners appointed to investigate the conditions in certain depressed areas. Mr. J. C. C. Davidson, Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, deals with West Cumberland and Haltwhistle; Capt. D. Euan
Wallace, Civil Lord of the Admiralty, with Durham and Tyneside; Lieut.-Col. Sir Wyndham Portal with South Wales and Monmouthshire; and Lieut-Col. Sir Arthur Rose with Scotland.
Cumberland.
Mr. Davidson finds that no area in Cumberland can he regarded as wholly "derelict," but the Cleator Moor and Maryport areas come nearest to justifying the use of the term. Iron ore mining, he says, is highly unlikely to afford more employment ;
the iron and steel industry offers no prospect of absorbing its surplus labour, but coal mining is likely to provide considerable extra employment in the next few years. Minor industries are few and comparatively unimportant, but gypsum mining offers
possibilities. He considers that there is little prospect of attracting new manufacturing industries to the area. His recommendations include the reconstruction of Whitehaven Harbour ; a development trust company (or companies) to promote agricultural
and horticultural schemes and the development of small local industries ; afforestation schemes special consideration to iron ore miners in connection with coal mining employment ; and the encouragement of industrial transference.
Durham and Tyneside.
Among the recommendations made by Capt. Wallace in regard to Durham and Tyneside are the following Unification of coal mining royalties ; provision of playgrounds and other amenities by a scheme of voluntary work ; the development of the Jarrow Slake
scheme; a road tunnel under the Tyne ; clearance of derelict factory sites; appointment of a Commission to co-ordinate all activities in connection with Government schemes for the rehabilitation of the area ; land settlement and housing schemes ;
formation of on industrial development company for Tyneside ; unification of local government authorities ; appointment of commissioners to administer outdoor relief in Durham; an Exchequer grant to reduce the cost of public assistance in the county.
Capt. Wallace says that just as the really derelict towns and villages cannot be dealt with in isolation, so also it is impossible to promote effective measures for the rehabilitation of any one area without reference to the county as a whole. Having
pointed out the impossibility of isolating those places to which the term "derelict" may properly be applied, he says it is of vital importance to realise that the area as a whole does not answer to this description. Portions of it are up to
the general average of industrial activity and some places are prosperous. The "really derelict" places are Leasington, Butterknowle, Wilton Park and Woodside.
Discussing the possibility of industrial revival, Capt. Wallace makes reference to the utilisation of the purchasing power of Government Departments as an instrument of policy, and suggests that preference to areas of severe unemployment might generally
be followed. Of the coal industry, he says that if it is to make the best of its chances of recovery "it must have a common policy and the means to carry it out; but no reorganisation, having this end in view, appears possible unless unification of
the ownership of royalties has first been accomplished." This, he points out, affects the question of dewatering pits in the West Auckland area. The pits in this area depend for their market upon the steel trade and cannot enter into economical
competition with other coking coal markets. Their reopening would simply increase the stress of uneconomic competition. Under present conditions any company can sink a new pit or acquire an existing pit at a low price, without any questions being asked,
and the cumulative effect of this policy has undoubtedly, he says, been one factor in the creation of the derelict conditions obtaining in the West Auckland area. A common policy such as is suggested would aim at bringing the best pits to full production
and eliminating the least profitable and worst conditioned pits, but the first step would he a unification of royalties.
It is mentioned that Messrs. Dorman, Long and Co. have drafted a dewatering scheme for South-west Durham which appears to be feasible from an engineering point of view and would safeguard existing pits. Capt. Wallace adds, however, that it is difficult
to rebut the theory that all the coal available in Durham should be extracted before new pits are sunk elsewhere.
Among the causes which are inimical to industrial developments, Capt. Wallace mentions high rates, though owing to the Derating Act "the burden is not actually so grievous as might appear at first sight," and the impression that the trade
onions in the area are inflexible and difficult to deal with although "there exists to-day an amount of goodwill in the relationship between employers' and employees' associations which will stand comparison with the conditions obtaining anywhere
else." On the other hand, the fact that the local administration of County Durham is regarded as a stronghold of Socialism is unlikely to prejudice industrialists in its favour. A third psychological factor is the unfortunate reputation which the
area has acquired by reason of five years of dwindling export trade, "in spite of the natural advantages it offers to industry." Capt. Wallace's own impression is that the most formidable difficulty lies in the fact that Durham and Tyneside are
geographically too remote from what was regarded as the largest market for the products of the new light industries.
Transference of men over 35 years of age is very difficult and over 67,000 of the unemployed in the area are above that age, and of these over 52,000 are married. The transference of juveniles is the most urgent problem. Unless the land can be made to
support a larger population, many men who would normally have been attached to the coal mining industry would be condemned to a permanent state of pauperism.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Davidson, J. C. C. | | | |
| Portal, Wyndham, Sir | | | |
| Rose, Arthur, Sir | | | |
| Wallace, D. Euan, Capt. | | | |