|
9th November 1934, Page: 865, Column: 1 Gresford Colliery ExplosionAt Wrexham, on the 2nd inst., Sir Henry Walker, H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines, continued his inquiry into the causes and circumstances of the explosion on September 22 at the Gresford Colliery, Denbighshire, by which 265 men lost their lives. This was the seventh day of the inquiry. Under-manager Further Examined. The under-manager, Mr. Andrew Williams, was again under examination at the hands of Sir Stafford Cripps, acting for the North Wales Miners' Federation. Sir Stafford began by asking Mr. Williams how many hours a day he worked at Gresford, and expressed surprise when he discovered that the witness was on duty for 12½ hours. Asked why he was altering the ventilation when he regarded it as satisfactory, the witness said he was looking forward. He repeated that work was in progress arranging the return from 109's and 14's to enter the Main Martin return without going into 29's. Sir Stafford examined upon a graph giving air measurements for the whole of the mine, and he suggested the figures indicated a shortage of air through the top of the Martin or through the fan drift which would not go down the mine at all. The witness replied that they could have those leakages from several points between the points of measurement. He declined an invitation to account for the difference of 47,000 cu. ft. between the return and the intake. Counsel called attention to a very rapid rise in the intake in October 1933, and witness agreed with his suggestion that it was due to the speeding up of the fan. He would not expect an increase unless the speed of the fan varied. Counsel pressed for the circumstances in which the witness said it was desirable that 75 per cent. of the total quantity of air going into the mine should not reach the face, and witness replied that that would obtain where men and boys were working on the haulage. There were other passages along which the air would travel to the face which they were not measuring. On Sir Henry pointing out that that statement conflicted with evidence previously given by the witness, he said 25 per cent. of the air was going into the split. He answered in the negative a suggestion that he would he content if the 75 per cent. were through the haulage roads hack through the returns. Air Measurements and Temperatures. Witness was next examined as to why no measurements were taken at certain places and faces, and he replied that he could not say. Asked if he had noticed any omission to take measurement, witness said in 109's district only of late he had noticed it. He had not drawn anyone's attention to it. They never had any measurements at the face of 109's, 14's or 29's. He added that perhaps it would have been better if they had. Asked for an estimate of what he considered the suitable quantity of air per man, per minute, at the face, witness said about 95 to 100 cu. ft. per min. He would consider the velocity in the main airway quite all right up to 600 to 700 ft. per mm. Along the face he would want 50 ft. per min. It depended upon the thickness of the seam. Counsel then quoted figures from a work on mining written by Mr. T. H. Cockin, the former agent at Gresford, in which he laid it down that speed in working places should be from 150 to 300 ft. per min. Witness replied that, in his opinion, that was high for a thick seam. Mr. Williams did not agree with counsel's suggestion that it was terribly hot in the pit. Hot conditions were quite usual in a mine of that depth. Witness added that in the foregoing estimates he was speaking not of the minimum velocity but safe velocity for the lamps. The minimum velocity for safety would vary and it was impossible to give a figure. Stone Dust Regulations. When dealing with the stone dusting of the Dennis pit, Sir Stafford and the witness agreed upon 3 lb. as a fair quantity for every shot fired, and this meant 900 lb. a day when 300 shots were fired. If 4,000 lb., roughly, was sent down, that left about 3,000 lb. for the roads, of which there were 80,000 sq. yd. Witness would not give an estimate of how much stone dust per sq. yd. was necessary or was used, and Sir Stafford then said it was apparent that the under-manager did not know from the quantity that was sent down whether it was sufficient to stone dust the mine efficiently. Witness replied that the quantity did not interest him. The samples he saw seemed quite in order. He added that it was the system in this mine to take samples in different parts every month. He was only concerned with the Dennis, and could not be expected to jump to any rash conclusions or interfere with the management. That was the answer to the question why he did not see that the regulations about taking samples every month in his district were carried out. The witness denied that there was gas constantly at the top end of 14's, or that a compressed air pipe had been used to blow the gas away. There was a fall at this point two or three weeks before the explosion, but it did not block the airway, and he knew nothing of men being imprisoned behind a fall, or anything about lamps continually going out. Sir Stafford then advanced the argument that if the output of coal was got more quickly, gas would be given off more quickly, but the witness would not agree. Questioned about fencing off in 81's and 80's, the witness said it had not been fenced off many times during the six months prior to the explosion on account of gas. In this part of the mine gas was frequently reported, and he could have closed it up in one shift, but did not want to do that for they did not know where it would leak out again. Witness did not agree that there was a very slow current along 81's and down the crossgate. He tested for gas and dust many times, and there was a good velocity of air. Asked whether the crossing at 109's was showing enough to resist an explosion or weak enough to give way, Mr. Williams said it was made to withstand the force. Questioned as to the quantity of compressed air available and the quantity used in the mine, Mr. Williams said the former was 3,000 cu. ft. per min., but he did not know what they were using. This completed Sir Stafford's cross-examination. Questions about Overtime. Mr. Joseph Hall, representing the Miners' Federation, then took up the cross-examination, and went fully into the working conditions at the coal face, with particular reference to the hours worked and the number of shifts. Witness said that overtime had not been worked in 14's district for a very long time, and if evidence was brought that daymen never left 14's until the afternoon shift arrived, it would be news to him. He had had complaints from the men as to the temperature at 14's face after the fall at the top end. It took about a month or five weeks to break through-the fall took place on May 23 and was cleared about the end of June. The first thing they did was to pack an airway up. At the top of the face they could only have two men working. Mr. Hall quoted that 4,971 shots were fired in the Dennis section in 18 days in September, including 1,567 shots in No. 14 district, and asked if witness, who had said that he believed shotfiring should he reduced to a minimum, had ever recommended to his manager or the owners that there was a way of reducing the number of shots fired. Witness replied that he had not, but said he was aware of a method. He added that the economic factor was the cause of these districts being put on machine faces, but the faces were quite safe with even such a large number of shots being fired. He added that if there was a reopening of the Gresford pit, and he was still under-manager, he would have no hesitation in recommending the use of pneumatic picks wherever possible, but should like to make tests first on a small scale. At this point the inquiry was adjourned until the following Tuesday. Counsel's Protest. When the inquiry was resumed on Tuesday. Mr. Joseph Hall continued his cross-examination of Mr. Williams, and, quoting figures which had been got out since the adjournment, mentioned that the tonnage on 14's face in the week ending September 1, 1934, was 61 tons. Mr. Hall remarked that there had been a large increase in 14's face between March 1 and September 1. Mr. Williams explained that the lengths of face increase in the period referred to was from 140 yd. to 178 yd. He denied that the increase was in any way connected with week-end work. After repeating his entire confidence in the firemen, Mr. Williams said the only fear the firemen had was that of being dismissed if they did not report it. There had never to his knowledge been a report about a deputy who had been taken to task for reporting gas. There was a protest by Mr. A. T. Miller, K.C., after Mr. Hall put his next question, which was "If more severe punishment was meted out after a catastrophe such as this, would more care be taken?" Sir Henry Walker asked, "Whom are you going to punish?" Mr. Hall replied, "The persons responsible for the safety of the men." Mr. Miller then jumped to his feet and said "We are engaged in an inquiry, and a good deal of the questions suggest an attack. The last question, for instance, was extremely improper and most unsuited to the nature of this inquiry." Mr. Henderson said he hoped Mr. Miller was not referring to Sir Stafford Cripps's questions. Mr. Miller said he certainly did. As they developed they were in the nature of an attack. On the resumption, witness agreed that there were 54 more men on the Friday night shift compared with the previous week because they wanted to make up lost time. The Firemen's Duties. Mr. Frowen, of the General Federation of Colliery Deputies, began his cross-examination with queries about the advisability of both officials and men being searched on the surface instead of down below, and the witness agreed that it would be better to make the search on top. In addition to the fireman, in the Dennis Main there were four men with firemen's certificates and 16 others, and these men did odd jobs to help the firemen. None of the districts were so extensive that a fireman could not control them in a proper manner. Asked whether he would favour legislation for a maximum number of shots on a coal face, witness said it was a very awkward question, because circumstances varied so largely. He was quite satisfied that, having regard to the extra number who were working on the night before the explosion there was no rushing to accomplish the work, nor were people getting in each other's way. Examined by Mr. W. T. Millar, of the Lancashire and Cheshire Firemen's and Shotfirers' Association, witness said he knew that shots were fired on a haulage road, hue his consent was never asked. The high number of shots spoken about were fired by a fireman who was working a double shift because his mate did not turn up. Witness added that be believed it was part of the deputy's duty to teach workmen all he could. Questioned by Mr. H. P. Harris, for the National Association of Colliery Managers, witness agreed that if any of the districts were in the condition suggested by previous questions they could not be remedied very quickly. The Pit Committee. Witness later stated there was a miners' committee elected by the men at Gresford every twelve months. It was comprised of men working down the mine, and occasionally be bad deputations from them on different matters. No mention of complaint was ever made to witness. Mr. Williams was next examined at length by Mr. A. T. Miller, for the owners. With reference to the pit committee, witness said it was composed of about a dozen men. Apart from official meetings he saw the officials frequently and he believed that if the mine had been in a condition such as was suggested by some of the questions, the committee would have said something to him. As it was, he had received complaints from no one. The witness continued that the Main coal in which the accident occurred was the principal seam worked in North Wales, and he himself had had many years experience in working it at Hafod Colliery. There was gas in Main coal just as there was in any other coal, and it compared favourably with other seams. He was absolutely satisfied that there was adequate ventilation at all the coal faces. Asked about the capacity of the fan, witness said that while they produced 150,000 cu. ft. of air per min. with a 3.7 to 3.8 in. water gauge, the capacity of the fan was 300,000 in. ft. with about a 5 in. gauge, if it was required. In regard to the statutory prohibition of shotfiring in the main haulage roads and main intake airways, Mr. Williams denied that there was any breach of the regulations, contending that the road in question was a temporary or auxiliary haulage road, in which there was not the slightest danger from shotfiring. Witness further told Mr. A. T. Miller, K.C., that he had three sons, aged 26, 22 and 16 in the pit. It was his custom to examine the general body of the air current when he visited the coal faces, and the only time he found gas was about three months ago, when there was a slight trace, and it received immediate and personal attention. This concluded the evidence of Mr. Williams. He had been on the witness stand for over 14½ hours and had answered something like 4,500 questions. Another Under-manager Called. The new witness was Edward Alun Roberts, of Greenfield, Rhosddu, Wrexham, another under-manager, who said he was appointed to the position in January 1934. He had been employed at Gresford since August 1914 as an overman. Mr. Charlton questioned the witness closely about the development of the pit since he came there, with particular reference to the time he was in charge of the Dennis district in 1933. He said he was chiefly concerned with the supervision of other districts in the mine, and only occasionally visited the Dennis. The last time he was on the night shift was on the night before the explosion. He had information that something was wrong in the south-east district. Before then it must have been some years since he had been down on the night shift. He remembered an occasion in 1933 when the speed of the fan was increased, butt it had nothing to do with his side of the pit. The ventilation on his side was satisfactory. Asked if men in 14's ever complained about the heat, witness said he remembered that they said it was warmer there than in the previous place they bad been working. Pressed about a fireman having fired 53 shots in a shift, witness said he thought he had firemen who fired as many on his side. He did not think the number excessive. He later agreed that possibly it took longer than one shift of 9½ hours for a fireman to fire 53 shots. Answering Mr. A. T. Miller, witness said that when certain men complained that they had been shifted to a district that was hotter than another place, it was because they had gone to a deeper part of the mine. The fact that they were given more favourable wage terms after this was not unusual. Overman's Evidence. Frederick John Davies, of Rhosrobin, Wrexham, night overman in charge of the whole mine on the night shift, was the next witness. He stated that hoe started as a collier at Gresford 23 years ago; he was a fireman for 11 years and had been overman 11 years. He visited all the districts occasionally, but had not been in the Dennis except on the main haulage road since August 21. He only went into the Dennis when something particular needed his attention. He found gas on the night shift on the Thursday prior to the explosion. It was in the slant at the bottom end of 2's. The gas was on the face of a fall on the return side and was in the general body of the air for a few yards. He understood the men were withdrawn in the afternoon. The fence had been removed when he came on. There was still a little gas coming from the foot of the fall on the return side. He added that he had nothing to do with ventilation. Asked by Mr. Henderson if he kept any records of what he did down the mine, the witness replied, "I did, but I lost my notebook." Witness said he did not regard the number of shots fired by Davey Jones, one of his firemen, as excessive, because he was satisfied that Davey Jones carried out his duties thoroughly. Referring again to the gas on the slant on September 20, witness said there was 2½ per cent. on the edge of the fall, and he only withdrew the men when it was diluted with brattice cloths at once. Counsels' Passage at Arms. Sir Stafford Cripps opened the proceedings on Wednesday by referring to Mr. Miller's "attack" allegation on the previous day, and asked Mr. Miller to elaborate his charges. Mr. Miller said an improper question had been asked, and he saw no reason to qualify what he had said. It was not his intention to make any observation about his learned friend's conduct of the case, but he did regard the extreme length and the manner of the cross-examination of Sir Stafford as a direct attack-an attack, no doubt, on the instructions of the Miners' Federation-upon the two witnesses who had given their evidence. Sir Stafford Cripps said he had yet to learn that, if questions themselves were not objectionable, there could be an objection to the totality of the question. He resented the suggestion that he had sought to make an attack. Mr. Miller said what he objected to was that the witnesses should be subjected to hours and hours of questions, many of which seemed to he directed to rubbing in breaches of statutory obligations which were only connected in the remotest manner with the investigation. The Overtime Issue. Sir Henry Walker said it was his desire, even though things might appear to be irrelevant, to allow everybody to let everything out that they thought ought to come out. At the end everything should be made public. He thought that, so far as he could see from the evidence, the Eight Hours Act, as far as this pit was concerned, did not run. In his mind, the only bearing that overtime had on this explosion would be the overtime worked by firemen and shotfirers-whether they were too fatigued to carry out their duties properly because they had worked so much time. It might be that, if they could restrict the question of overtime to shotfirer or firemen witnesses, they might be able to shorten this inquiry a little. The two assessors both agreed that he should make this announcement. Sir Stafford Cripps replied that he did not intend returning to the general question of overtime, and Mr. Miller also said he thought it could be a useful limitation to the proceedings. He added "Men at various times have acted in contravention of the Eight Hours Act, but it would appear to be very remote from this explosion." Firemen Give Evidence. The first fireman from the Dennis district to be examined was Richard Owen, who was in charge of 20's district on the day shift. He said that on September 21, the day before the explosion, he could not travel right through the faces on 20's because of a fall in 102's. It had been there for three weeks, and they had got 10 yd. in on the top side and 9 yd. on the bottom. The temperature at the face was warm, but not hot, and the men worked stripped to the waist. The witness said he had always beets satisfied with the amount of air coating into his district. The return airways were in good condition a week before the explosion. Answering Prof. R. V. Wheeler, of the Safety in Mines Research Board, witness said coal dust fell chiefly in the haulage roads, and he tested whether they needed stone dusting by the blackness of the road. Witness was afterwards asked to judge samples of dust produced in court. Answering Sir Stafford Cripps, witness denied that it was difficult for him to see a cap of gas on his lamp without his glasses. He had not seen a cap of gas in his present district. When witness told Sir Stafford that materials from the clod were used for packing, Sir Stafford suggested that this was dangerous, because the material was combustible, but witness said he did not think so. Sir Stafford then inquired into the time it took a fireman to perform statutory duties. Witness at first said it would be possible for a fireman to fire 25 shots in a shift, but later agreed that perhaps it would he more correct to say from 10 to 20. Answering Mr. H. P. Harris, witness said that neither Mr. Bonsall nor Mr. Williams ever interfered with the work of safety on the grounds of expense. Questioned by Mr. Miller, witness said nit the morning before the explosion the ventilation was very good, as it was free from gas. His last report recorded "district free from gas." Sir Henry Walker asked witness how he tested for gas and reminded him that in some places the roof was 9 to 12 ft. high. Witness, who is 5 ft. 7 in. in height, said he stood on a 3 ft. bench used by colliers for setting props. He placed his lamp against the roof of the ripping every day. When being questioned about the fact that he had not reported gas in his district for more than two years, the witness remarked "I durst take a naked light through." After the luncheon adjournment Sir Henry Walker informed the court that the result of the measurement showed that Owen could reach to a height of 7 ft. 6 in. with his lamp standing on a specified height, and that his eyesight was better than anticipated. In reply to Sir Henry's question as to what happened when he was testing the highest ripping of 9 ft., witness said hoe stood on coal to test for the gas close to the roof. Thomas Bramley Tune was the second fireman called to the stand. He explained that he had been a shot-firer since July 1914, and a fireman for the past 14 years-all the time at Gresford. As the afternoon shift fireman, he made a point of inspecting close to the roof for gas, and when he could not reach, he stood on tubs or wagons. The last time he found gas was in May. A test with the bottles of dust was put to this witness also by Prof. Wheeler. He said little stone-dusting was done on the afternoon shift. He did not know that some coal dusts needed more than 50 per cent. of stone dust to make them non-combustible. The Commissioner examined this witness also with a foot rule and announced that he was 5 ft. 2 in., and could reach 6 ft. 10 in. He was closely questioned with regard to the reports of gas found in 37's heading, which was fenced off after the men had been withdrawn in May. As to the time it took to fire a shot, the witness agreed with the estimate of previous witnesses. Sir Henry put a number of questions about 37's, and witness related how he went up this district day by day. It was certainly clear on the afternoon before the explosion. When there was gas there he thought it was coming out of the coal. The last examination made in 20's district was about eight o'clock on the night before the explosion, when there was no sign which might lead to an explosion. Mr. Charlton inquired again about shot-firing on a haulage road on the Friday night, and witness said he thought there might be shot-firing in the coal. Sir Henry asked witness if shot-firing on a haulage road was ever done on his shift, and witness did admit that there had been some on Saturdays. He never had written permission to do it, but the management would know it was going on because of the holes which had been prepared there in the week. Josiah Thomas Jones, fireman in charge of 61's district on the day shift, said he had been a fireman for 14 years. On September 21 he got to the pit about 5.30 am, and left again about 2.15 p.m. He agreed that gas was persistent in 61's heading over long periods, but not to such an extent that he had to withdraw men. He never saw samples of dust, air, or measurements of air taken on 61's road. He agreed it was impossible to tell by mere inspection whether the dust on the roads complied with the regulations. Yesterday's Hearing. Further evidence by firemen was given yesterday. Josiah Thomas Jones said he had never found gas on the coal faces of the district in which he had been fireman for the last three years. He denied that Gresford was "a hot mine," and said he used to he able to carry out each inspection of his district easily in 1½ hours. He had never seen the manager in his district, and he had seen the under-manager there only five or six times. Norman Parry, a day-shift fireman said a fireman named Mathias, who was killed in the explosion, did not report to him an incident said to have occurred on the night of September 20-21. He denied having committed breaches of the Explosives Order. The day before the disaster they load a peculiar smell down 142 deep, like a smell of dead mice. Robert Thomas Edwards, afternoon-shift fireman in the same district as that in which Mr. Parry was day-shift fireman, said he heard rumours about it, but never smelt it himself. Sir Stafford Cripps asked the witness if he made a practice of making several shotholes and firing them one after the other Edwards replied "No, very rarely." He added in reply to further questions that he had on occasions stemmed two shotholes and possibly three, but not more. The inquiry was adjourned until to-day.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||