2nd November 1934, Page: 832, Column: 2
Law Intelligence
Subsidence Claim against Ecclesiastical Commissioners
An action by Hugh Nicholas Snowdon, of Merrington Grange Farm, Ferryhill, claiming a declaration that he was entitled to recover from the Ecclesiastical Commissioners damages for injury to his farm resulting from the working of the underlying minerals,
whether the injury was the result of acts done before or after the conveyance of the farm to him in June 1921, was dismissed in the Chancery Division last week.
Mr. Justice Luxmoore giving judgment said there was no dispute of fact in the case, and it was really a preliminary point of the law which arose. It was admitted by the Commissioners that any damage resulting to the land by reason of workings after June
1921, would be recoverable by Mr. Snowdon, but they challenged his right to damages in respect of injuries which had occurred before June 1921. It was plain that the benefit of the covenant to pay compensation for damage ran with the land, but the
question was as to the position of damage which had accrued before the date of the conveyance to Mr. Snowdon. That damage was something to which the then owner was entitled to. and Mr. Justice Luxmoore was of the opinion that without the express
assignment of that right it was difficult to see how Mr. Snowdon could claim to have any right to it. So far as this action was concerned he thought the only declaration he could make was that Mr. Snowdon was entitled to recover damages for injury to
Merrington Grange Farm resulting from working of the underlying minerals after the date of the conveyance to him, and not before. He granted that declaration for what it was worth, but Mr. Snowdon's action failed, and must be dismissed with costs.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Luxmoore, — | | Judge | |
| Snowdon, Hugh Nicholas | | Farmer | |