|
26th October 1934, Page: 782, Column: 2 Gresford Colliery ExplosionOfficial Inquiry OpenedThe official inquiry into the causes and circumstances of the explosion on September 22 at the Gresford mine, Denbighshire, by which 265 men lost their lives was opened yesterday by Sir Henry Walker, H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines. The inquest on the bodies of nine men who were among those killed in the Gresford Colliery disaster was again adjourned at Wrexham, on Monday, for three weeks. The coroner proceeded with the inquiry into the death of John George William Brown, 57, who was killed while working on the surface when there was a second explosion three days later. The coroner said that Brown was collecting sandbags which had been used for sealing the pit. He was found lying unconscious after the explosion, and died in hospital. A foreman stated that the explosion occurred without any warning. Brown was 8 yd. from the pit mouth, but after the explosion he was found 12 to 13 yd. away. Mr. E. Jones (North Wales Miners' Federation agent) asked whether it was necessary to close the pit immediately after the explosion. The foreman said they had no instructions otherwise. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death." and added that no blame could be attached to anybody. Managers Evidence. Sir Henry Walker sat with two assessors, Mr. John Brass, of Barnsley, nominated by the Mining Association of Great Britain and Mr. Joseph Jones, president of the Miners' Federation. Sir Stafford Cripps, K.C., and Mr. Arthur Henderson, jun., were present on behalf of the North Wales Miners' Federation, and counsel instructed for the colliery company were Mr. A. T. Miller, K.C., and Mr. Hartley Shawcross. Sir Henry Walker said the efforts to subdue the fire which occurred when the explosion took place on September 22 failed, with the result that on Sunday, September 23, all persons withdrew from the mine and each of the shafts was covered with a seal. By reason of the fire, exploration of the mine was impracticable, and it was not possible to make much progress with the investigation as to the actual cause of the explosion. In these circumstances, the course which for the time being the inquiry could best follow was to take evidence as to the condition of the mine and the operations connected with its working prior to the explosion; to take evidence of the occurrence of the explosion and the events following it; and to take such evidence as to the cause as was now available. Having completed the first and second parts, they might have to consider whether the inquiry should stand adjourned until such time as further evidence as to the cause was available. The calling of witnesses then began. The examination was conducted by Mr. W. J. Charlton, divisional inspector of mines, on behalf of the Ministry of Mines. Mr. William Bonsall, manager of the Gresford Colliery, said he was wholly responsible for the conduct of the mines. He went down the mine almost daily (luring the day shift, but at night only on exceptional occasions. The under-managers occasionally went down on the night shift. The overman, Fred. Davies, had the whole of the mine under his control on the night shift. No inspections had been made on behalf of the workmen since 1921 in the Dennis seam. It could be taken that generally the main Dennis pit was a hand-worked pit with electrical machinery in close proximity. The electrical apparatus used at the face was flameproof. Shotholes were bored by hand and the firing was always done by firemen. The total air circulated in the pit was 144,000 cu. ft. Leakages at certain points were corrected by putting in stoppings. He admitted that there was a good deal of leakage at 29's turn-about 18,000 ft. Asked by Mr. Charlton whether gas had been reported at any time in a district known as 61, where a heading had been made to prove a fault, Mr. Bonsall said about 1 to 2 per cent. had been reported, but it was quickly diluted. He did not think any shots were fired in the haulage roads in the 109's district. The undermanager had told him there would be no shotfiring there. It was possible that shots were fired at 95 -face in a heading between faults. Gas had shown itself owing to falls. He thought he was right in saying there were no shots on the coal face on that night. Witness explained that the lamps used were of the Protector type, burning colzaline, and added that for every lamp issued the lampsman received a tally. In addition, a banksman kept a check at the pithead of the number of men who went down. The men were searched by the fireman at his station in the pit. He searched every man sometimes, but took 20 per cent. as a rule, by taking every fifth man. They did not record it every day, but they did search 20 per cent. of the men of every shift. A long time ago they recorded that they found cigarettes. Mr. Bonsall said the number of men in the Dennis district on the night of the explosion was 261. He did not know where the figure of 100 had come from. He was down the pit at the time, but if the lamp man had been asked he could have given the correct number. In answer to questions, he said he fined two men for damaging their lamps this year-one man for carelessness and the other for putting his pick through the gauze. He added that everybody had a separate exit by the return airway-the smallest section in this airway was 4 ft. 6 in. square. There was a ready means of egress employed in the Martin main. Witness said he had taken one or two samples of air in 1932, but had followed no actual system. He agreed that it would be a very excellent thing to have such a system. Mr. Charlton said he had a record of a shotfirer — Seth Davies — firing in the 14 district on the 21st, fifty shots. Witness said he had an assistant. He admitted that it was more than the majority did. Witness then went on to describe how three tubs a day of stone dust were sent in to this particular area, and he told how he had been present many times when stone dusting had been done. Au assistant had done the stone dusting. Mr. Charlton suggested that if shots were fired in the haulage road, they were fired in contravention of Clause 7 of the regulations. Witness said he had not given permission for shotfiring, but he had not prohibited shots from being fired, and knew that shots were being fired there. Mr. Charlton then commented "Well, you have permitted it by implication." The inquiry then adjourned until to-day. The Relief Fund. The Mansion House Relief Fund now stands at £164,000 and the Denbighshire Fund at £124,741. The former will be closed on November 1 and the Denbighshire Fund on November 15. The following are amongst the additional contributions received Western Mail readers (third contribution), £4,000; Denbighshire County Council, £1,000; Gas Light and Coke Co., Ltd. (employees), £821 9s. 1d. ; South Yorkshire Colliery Owners' Association, £820; Denbighshire Schools, £495 13s. 8d. ; Herald and Express readers, £340; Natsopa London chapels, £217 11s.; Presbyterian Church of England (second contribution), £203 13s. 1d.; L.M.S. Headquarters Euston, £176 2s. 7d. ; boys at Eton College, £160 4s.; I.C.I. (Explosives group-workers and staff, Ardeer), £139 12s. ; Cheshire County Council (staffs), £122 5s. 6d.; P.O. Savings Bank (staff), £118 13s. 6d. ; South Metropolitan Gas Co., Ltd. (employees), £115 18s. 10d. ; Lyceum (Liverpool), £109 6s. 6d. ; Merchant Taylors' Company, Mayor of Dorchester, £105; Sydney Bacon's Pictures, Ltd., £102; Drapers' Company, Highfield Tanning Co. and employees, Lord Dysart, Odhams Press Machine Chapel, Miss Margaret S. Davies, Miss Gwendoline E. Davies, Thomas and Evans, Ltd. (principals and staff), £100. The scale of grants adopted by the committee of the Gresford Colliery Disaster Relief Fund is to be continued until the end of the year pending actuarial advices as to the permanent scale. Meanwhile, several widows, whose circumstances are such as to make the weekly allowance of £1 inadequate to their needs, are to be given 27s. 6d. a week. The committee emphasise that the scale affecting widows and their dependants of the victims is only temporary and may have no relation to the permanent scale which must depend upon the actuarial report. Favourable consideration is to be given to the suggestion that additional allowances should be paid out at Christmas. The grants to the Gresford unemployed are also to continue until the end of the year, but single men, and particularly those with dependants, are to be treated more generously. The Yorkshire Miners' Federation wrote intimating that before forwarding their donation of £1,000 they desired an assurance that any surplus from the fund, after meeting all actuarial liabilities, shall be applied to the relief of the dependants in subsequent disasters. Secretary for Mines Replies to His Critics. Mr. Ernest Brown, Secretary for Mines, speaking at Easington, Co. Durham, on Wednesday, referred to the disaster at Gresford, and replied to Mr. Shinwell's recent criticism of the safety measures in mines generally. Mr. Shinwell was reported to have said that there was no need for such disasters to happen; explosions could easily he eliminated if proper precautions were taken. This statement, said Mr. Brown, coming from one who had twice held the office of Secretary for Mines, could not easily be described in measured language. It had no relation to the facts. During the two periods, amounting to some two years, in which Mr. Shinwell was Secretary for Mines in 1924 and in 1930-31-there were 27 explosions involving the death of 97 men. It was not possible to gather from anything which Mr. Shinwell said during his periods of office, either in the House of Commons or outside, that he knew then how to eliminate explosions. Why had not Mr. Shinwell during the past three years, passed on some of the extensive information which he said he had. As Secretary for Mines he intensely resented the grave and completely unjustified reflection on the mines inspectorate implied in Mr. Shinwell's assumption that they willingly permitted unsafe conditions to continue. He had caused a search to be made, and he could find no trace of any demand by Mr. Shinwell for the investigation of any of these many cases which Mr. Shinwell said he had heard of in every coal field. A particularly mean suggestion in Mr. Shinwell's speech was that certain conferences which he initiated in his period of office load been dropped. Mr. Shinwell's programme of divisional conferences was not cut down. It was carried out in full. In general, his feelings on reading Mr. Shinwell's speech were those of unmitigated contempt. Mr. Brown went on to say that in the course of other speeches and in letters and resolutions which he had received there were two other claims made. The first was that if the firemen or deputies underground were appointed and paid by the State, more effective work for safety would be done by them. Every successive Government and every Commission of Inquiry which had investigated this hardy annual had turned it down on the major ground that it would involve divided control and responsibility for the safety of the pit. The other claim made from various quarters, including the president of the Mineworkers' Federation, was that there was an automatic gas alarm which, if universally adopted in the pits, would obviate explosions. It would not, and could not possibly, do anything of the kind. Those — and some of them had no knowledge whatever of the subject — who indicted the National Government for failing (to quote from one of their resolutions) "to compel the colliery owners to put into use the automatic firedamp signal as approved in 1928," had overlooked the fact that Mr. Shinwell, as Secretary for Mines in the Labour Government of 1930-31, firmly refused to do that. The fact was that these electric firedamp detectors were still in a state of development, more particularly as regards use in working conditions, and that their progress had been, and was still, much hampered by exaggerated claims made on their behalf. So far from having held this development up, the Mines Department had done much to assist the inventors, and the alarm in its present state was a very different and much bet-tar instrument than that of 1928. The Government had arranged, with the co-operation of owners, managers, deputies, and men, for an extended large-scale trial of six months in working conditions to be made of an automatic alarm in pits as widely apart as Lancashire, Yorkshire, and South Wales. Reports were made of all these trials by three joint pit committees which carried out the trials, and Mr. Brown asserted that in the light of these reports no Minister who load a responsible regard for the safety of the mines could possibly do more than encourage further trial and development on a voluntary basis. The Mines Department, added Mr. Brown, was on the point of issuing Draft Regulations which he hoped would bring to an end this longstanding controversy. These regulations would provide compulsorily for the workmen to he provided with efficient gas detector in definitely specified number. The number would be that suggested by the Mineworkers' Federation themselves. But the Regulations would also provide an option for the management to make a choice from a list of officially approved detectors; and to use either the flame detector or the automatic detector. Since the safety of the mine was the final responsibility of the manager, it was clearly impossible to give anyone else the power of decision in so vital a matter.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||