13th October 1934, Page: 101, Column: 2
Open Fire Advantages
At the Glasgow conference of the Smoke Abatement Society
the question of the abolition of the coal fire was referred to in the
discussion by Medical Officers of Health. Of course it is well
known that even doctors differ, and anyway the smoke nuisance
is an old friend, often serving the purpose of providing publicity.
In view of the recent indictments against the coal fire the YORKSHIRE
POST interviewed Mr. Kenneth Hargreaves, who said :—
"I agree that we must do all we can to abate the smoke nuisance,
but we shall probably make much more headway by improving
the technique of the use of coal than by indiscriminate condemnation
of coal itself. We know that great advances have been made
in the design of industrial furnaces, as well as in the methods of
firing them, which is the more important as mill chimneys bear a
heavy share of responsibility in this matter.
"As to the domestic hearth, the old Yorkshire range has now
very few friends. It is old-fashioned and wasteful . . . the modern
domestic cooking range, under proper management, produces very
little smoke at all; in fact, some types consume their own smoke.
In any case, we are a long way from abolishing the open coal fire,
even if its abolition were desirable on the score of health. And
about that scientists have serious doubts. They say that in our
humid and variable climate the coal fire, with its slight variations
in temperature, is a positive stimulus to health; the occupants
of a house so heated are much less susceptible to sudden cold when
going outdoors than those living in rooms kept at a uniform dry
heat. Again, it must be obvious that the open fireplace is a more
efficient ventilator for a room, and this is perhaps one of the chief
things to be said in its favour. There is, of course, the alternative
of coke fires, but the coke fire has some way to go yet.
"The truth is that all forms of heat — gas and electricity, coal
and coke — have their uses and are complementary one with the
other. Electricity and gas have the great advantage of convenience
and cleanliness, just as coal and coke cannot be beaten for cheapness,
always assuming reasonable uses. In fact, it will always be difficult
to find a manufactured substitute for coal, which, with proper
preparation and selection and with modern plant, can be used
efficiently in the raw state."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Hargreaves, Kenneth | | | |