|
28th September 1934, Page: 601 Bilsthorpe Colliery ExplosionInquest at MansfieldThe inquest on the nine victims of the explosion at the Stanton Ironworks Co.'s pit at Bilsthorpe was opened by the Notts district coroner (Lieut.-Col. H. Bradwell) at the Mansfield Police Station on Tuesday morning, and although considerable time was occupied with taking evidence of witnesses who identified the bodies and in hearing the medical evidence of the hospital surgeons from Nottingham, Chesterfield and Mansfield in which institutions the men died, considerable headway was made with the inquiry by half-past five when the coroner adjourned the proceedings until the following morning. Four deaths took place at Nottingham General Hospital, three at Mansfield and two at Chesterfield hospitals respectively. On July 26, in the early part of the day, there were two explosions at the colliery and over 40 men were injured, including several members of the rescue brigades called from Mansfield and Chesterfield. The following is a list of the men who lost their lives Edward Warsop (41), John Wm. Jones (32), Tom Wm. Crowder (29), Arthur Woodcock (35), Walter Hardy (33), Enoch Reeves (44), William Burrows (24), William Preater (38) and William Wright (30). The coroner had the assistance of the deputy-coroner (Mr. W. S. Marshall), along with Mr. J. R. Felton (divisional inspector of mines), Mr. A. H. Steele (senior inspector) and Mr. T. E. Pickering (junior inspector). Mr. F. H. Jessop represented the Stanton Ironworks Co., the pit officials and Mr. N. D. Todd, colliery general manager of the company, and Mr. T. L. Linley, the manager of the mine, was also in court. Representatives of the Miners' Industrial Union and the Notts Miners' Association were also in attendance. Before opening the inquest the coroner made sympathetic reference to the appalling disaster at Wrexham, and the court rose and stood in silence as a mark of sympathy and respect. The medical witnesses were next called and spoke of the nature of the men's injuries when admitted at the hospital. They were all suffering from extensive burns. They had received very efficient attention before they were conveyed to hospital. George Stanley Knight, surveyor for the colliery, explained plans of the workings underground and a model he had prepared for the benefit of the court. He stated that prior to the explosion, shots were fired into the ripping lip, where the road was increased in height, right at the top of the loader gate. That was 18 ft. from the coal face. Joseph Wm. Sutton stated that he was the day deputy on duty on July 26 and he tested for gas but found none. Eight or nine weeks ago after a fall in the waste he found gas had been released by the fall, but that was a considerable distance from the waste where the explosion occurred. He was up and down his district until after 3 o'clock and found nothing unusual. The roof was a very safe one. Ventilation was good. He had nothing to report to the afternoon deputy when he went out of the pit. In reply to Mr. Jessop, the witness said he examined the men for matches before they went into the workings, and also their lamps, and had a conversation with the night deputy as to the condition of the place, and everything so far as he could see was safe. He received a statutory report from the previous deputy. There was nothing in it to indicate danger, and his men went into the working places. He had never at any time found such a quantity of gas as might be termed dangerous. The first explosion occurred about 6.30 on the night of July 26, but he had then left the pit. The surface of the road was a good travelling road. The next witness, Bertram Weaking, who was the deputy on the afternoon shift on July 26, said that he examined his district — men were working on the lip at the time. At 4.30 he examined the main lip and it was clear of gas. There was nothing in the conditions to cause him to make a special examination for gas. He fired a shot at the bottom of the airway about 5.30. He knew more shots were to be fired, but he did not hear them fired. He had instructed Bradshaw to fire three shots. This was to get the ripping down. The shotfirer or the deputy fired shots after an examination of the place. Before another shot was fired a further examination was made. Shots were usually 8 or 9 ft. apart. As he was returning to the loader gate he saw the place well lit up. He was knocked down by the rush of wind and was burned by the flame. Replying to the divisional inspector, witness said he found no trace of gas when he examined the waste or in any other part of his district. He examined the waste going in 8 ft. There was a distance of 5 ft. beyond. He saw no timber in the waste beyond that which was used for support. There was nothing of an inflammable nature left in the waste. When he saw the coal face lit up he was hurrying towards it. Although he was knocked down and burned he saw no flame. In answer to Mr. Jessop, he said all the duties required of him by the Act were properly carried out. He held an under-manager's certificate. From the time he saw the red glow he ran a distance of 10 or 40 yd. and then felt the explosion and was bowled over. He could not account for this rapid accumulation of gas, neither could he offer any explanation of how the ignition took place. He was satisfied that there was no gas there when he made his examination. The seam of coal was about 6 ft. thick. Answering the foreman of the jury, witness said if he saw a break in a shothole he would not allow that hole to be used. Wm. Henry Bradshaw, another deputy at the colliery, said it had been his duty to fire shots in the No. 6 district. He had been a pit deputy 16 years but had not worked long at Bilsthorpe. On the day of the explosion he arrived at the coal face in the district mentioned and he received instructions to fire three shots into the ripping. There was no break in the shot holes. After each shot it was his duty to examine the place and he found nothing wrong after the first and second shots had been fired. He proceeded to fire the third shot and almost immediately after he saw a flash. He could not form any idea as to where the accumulated gas that ignited was secreted. The fire seemed to originate in the No. 1 waste. He at once telephoned to the pit top to inform them what had happened. He then went forward and found the men had all gone. He could not get near the fire for smoke. Asked by the coroner what was done to put the fire out, witness said they could not get near it. There was plenty of sand. Witness went on to state that when the rescue brigades arrived they had no extinguishers so far as he knew. They had equipment, however, and went forward to find there was a fire in the No. 1 waste and they made efforts to put it out. A second party of rescuers arrived and went forward with extinguishers. Directly after that he saw smoke coming through the roof from the No. 1 waste and it almost immediately burst into flame and he remembered no more. In reply to the inspector, he said the floor was thoroughly stone dusted and a proper examination made too before the third shot was fired. There was no sign of gas anywhere, all three shots did their work as was expected; there was no blown out shot. There was no over-charging either. Replying further to Mr. Felton, witness said his idea was that there must have been an ignition of gas due to a break which he did not find. He was satisfied that the first explosion took place in the No. 1 waste. Mr. Felton: There must have been a fairly large amount of gas to have caused such an explosion. Nothing was really done to put out the fire until the rescue men arrived and very valuable time lost. Witness: We could not get to the fire. We stopped the ventilation because we felt it was feeding the fire. Further questioned by Mr. Felton, witness said he was satisfied the shots did their work and that there was no break in the holes fired. Asked as to what was done when the rescue brigades arrived, witness said he was afraid some of the men might have got down into the smoke and he decided to put up a brattice cloth in the intake, the effect of which was to stop the air getting to the fire and diverting it towards the loader gate. The rescue team went forward to the left bank and reported that the fire was in the first waste. They started to deal with the outbreak with sand and stone dust. Some time later the Chesterfield rescue team came on the scene and they were followed by ambulance men and others who were carrying extinguishers. On Wednesday, Bradshaw was recalled and further questioned by Mr. Felton. He said that he saw no coal dust before he fired his shots. It was approximately 20 min. after he fired the shots that he saw the fire in the waste. Mr. Jessop obtained from the witness an opinion that it was not fair to suggest nothing was done to put out the fire because their whole attention was concentrated on the safety of the men. He himself went along the right bank to see if the men were clear of danger. Besides, he could not get near the fire without apparatus. The communication between the shot and the crack in the waste might have been the result of the shot firing. It was not possible to see the crack in the roof, presuming it was there. He put the brattice cloth in such a position that would prevent the ventilation getting to the fire. That tended to check the fire. When the rescue brigades arrived he handed over his authority to the man in charge. In reply to the foreman of the jury, witness said the lip in which he fired the shots was about 5 ft. to 5 ft. 6 in. thick. Wood in the waste seen to be on fire was probably pieces that had been missed by the men when drawing off. The next witness was Arthur Caldwell, a contractor in the North-West District. He was responsible, he said, for the withdrawal of timber from the waste. Ten per cent. of the men were searched that day at the pit bottom. He had not heard of gas being found after a fall some weeks before the disaster. After the shot was fired there was a fire almost immediately and the flame ran along the road. He was satisfied that Weaking made a very thorough examination of the coal face and he went into the waste with the deputy. There was no small timber in the waste so far as he knew. When Mr. Wheatcroft arrived with the rescue men it would be about an hour after the explosion. The rescue men carried fire extinguishers. There was an interval of probably three hours before the second explosion followed. Caldwell, further questioned by Mr. Felton, said he saw a yellow blaze and red spots of fire came along the bank where he was standing after the first explosion. He next saw the waste burst into flame. He could give no opinion as to the cause of the second explosion. Wm. Storer, a ripping contractor on the North-West road, said on the evening in question he felt a backdraught and saw flames approaching him. He called for help and asked for a rescue party. The ventilation was good. Later he went up the coal face and a test was made for gas but none was found. The flame seemed to travel a distance of 40 yd. He did not at first realise there was a fire following an explosion. Francis Wheatcroft, overman at the pit, questioned as to the use of fire extinguishers at the outset said there were none in the pit — they were kept on the top. There used to be some underground but he understood they had been removed. Having dealt with the arrival of the rescue men, witness said 20 min. after the brigades had gone up into the workings a second explosion occurred. He gave instructions to cut off all current immediately the first explosion occurred. The injured men were attended to, all being able to walk out. Mr. Felton: Do you know that it is very important that men suffering from burns should not exert themselves and should be carried out of the pit ? — Witness Yes, but we could not stop the men; they went rushing out. Mr. Jessop pointed out that there was nothing in the Act requiring that chemical extinguishers should be provided. Frank Pemberton, captain of the colliery rescue team was next called and said on going up to the place where the fire was they put it out in the waste. He had a canary with him and it showed that there was no carbon monoxide present. He accompanied the Mansfield Rescue Brigade on their arrival into the fire zone. He threw pieces of stone and stone dust on to the fire to try and smother it. Gas was alight in the waste. He did not see any break. Where the gas was coming from he could not say. He telephoned for fire extinguishers to be sent into the pit and he thought if they had had a few they could have put the fire out. When the Mansfield Rescue Brigade arrived on the scene of the fire they had no extinguishers with them. That was probably due to the fact that the telephone message to Mansfield did not convey the information that there was a fire. They were told there had been an explosion. John C. P. Taylor, superintendent of the Chesterfield Rescue Team said the brigade received notice of an explosion at Bilsthorpe at 6.38 and were off two minutes later. They reached the pit at 6.57 and descended the mine at 7.1. He did not know there was a fire in the pit till they got down. John C. P. Taylor, superintendent, of Chesterfield Rescue Brigade, said they were equipped with chemical extinguishers, which they used on getting into the mine. As the men came out they were treated for burns and supplied with oxygen. Arthur Holmes, the under-manager at the pit, said they had all proper equipment for dealing with the men injured. Asked if he could express any opinion as to the cause of the first explosion, he replied that ignition took place after the firing of the third shot, the gas probably having accumulated in the waste. There must have been gas in the roof. Later gas again accumulated probably from a feeder at the back of the waste. It was unlikely that a second explosion would have occurred if the fire had been put out after the first explosion. He was satisfied that all concerned did everything possible to deal with the situation and to assist the injured. Mr. Felton: Would it be possible to withdraw the men when a shot is fired ? — If you ask me what distance they should be withdrawn to I might give you an answer. It is men on the face that are burned every time. The roads are quite safe, as is shown in this case. If you can withdraw your men they will be safe. Is it possible to do that ? — I think so. Mr. Felton said in many places they were doing that now. The coroner, in a brief summing-up, said the jury would have no difficulty in coming to a conclusion as to the cause of death, but they must be satisfied that every precaution was taken by everyone concerned for the safety of the men employed. If they could suggest anything that would tend to prevent such happenings in the future, they would say so. Six men lost their lives in the first explosion and three in the second, and the latter were all rescue men. The jury's unanimous verdict was that the death of the six men was accidental in the first explosion and, whilst they were of the same opinion in regard to the three rescue workers who perished in the second, they desired to state that they were of opinion that the colliery company should have more chemical fire extinguishers accessible to cope with a situation of this character. The coroner said he entirely agreed with the verdict.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||