|
4th August 1934, Page: 27, Column: 1 An Experimental Gob-Fire ExplosionBy T. N. Mason and F. V. Tideswell. From paper presented on the 13th July at the Buxton Meeting of the Institution of Mining Engineers. Concluded from No. 1, page 5. Several observations of especial interest arise from the experiment on methods of detecting a heating during its early stages of development, which terminated in an explosion. The first is the rapidity with which fire ultimately developed in the pack, in agreement with underground experiences which have frequently been described. Thus, analysis of samples of the return air revealed the presence of carbon monoxide in abnormal amount roughly twenty-four hours only before gob-stink was detected; the carbon-monoxide content of the air was then, however, only 0.01 per cent., which is too small to be detected with certainty in situ by any detector at present available. After the first production of gob-stink the heating developed rapidly, the atmosphere becoming charged with smoke within another twenty-four hours. Possibly the time-interval between the first indication of heating and the development of active fire might have been somewhat longer had the heating been developed using a more normal temperature for the inleaking air. As it was, the fire developed so rapidly that insufficient observations were made to determine whether the carbon monoxide in the atmosphere reached the minimum concentration to which a detector would respond, say 0.05 per cent., before gob-stink became noticeable. On the other hand, the general conditions were more favourable to the detection of carbon monoxide than they would normally be underground, since the return air from the heating was not diluted by the main volume of ventilation passing round the pack, nor by any additional air-leakage. A second observation of interest is the rapidity with which an inflammable atmosphere was formed in the goaf chamber after sealing-off, even in the absence of firedamp issuing from the strata. The atmosphere became inflammable within two hours, and three hours later ignition occurred. It is of interest to compare the result of this experiment with that of a previous experiment (No. 14, Safety in Mines Research Board Paper No. 75, p. 21) in which a heating was started in a dirt-pack with the aid of an electric heater. The conditions after sealing-off were almost identical in the two experiments. In experiment No. 14, the chamber was sealed off three times during the development of the fire, and on each occasion an inflammable atmosphere was formed, but no ignition occurred. For ignition to have taken place, the incandescent material within the pack had to be brought into contact with the inflammable atmosphere. This could occur most simply by a crumbling of the pack exposing the inner glowing material. If the pack remained unbroken, it was necessary for the glowing material to communicate with the outer atmosphere through channels or breaks, and for those breaks to be filled with an inflammable gas mixture capable of propagating flame through them. Such breaks are almost certain to arise during the heating up of the pack, if not before. Whether such breaks would readily allow flame to pass through them is not so certain. However, since combustion within the heated zone would vitiate the outgoing gas and render it less inflammable or non-inflammable, only breaks which feed air into the fire need be considered, and even then it is likely that under most conditions dilution by products of combustion will occur before the zone of active fire is reached. Nevertheless, we believe that it was by some such process that ignition was caused in the present experiment, though the possibility of a fall of part of the pack having preceded and caused the ignition, by exposure of glowing material, cannot be entirely ruled out. Experiment No. 15 has served to illustrate the risk of explosion during the period after sealing-off when the atmosphere in the sealed-off area still contains more than 10 per cent. of oxygen. It strengthens our belief that the obtaining of an inflammable atmosphere under such conditions is more probable than not, but that the obtaining of ignition of that inflammable atmosphere is mainly fortuitous and decided by factors not altogether under control. We suggest that the chance of ignition is less the earlier the fire is tackled, and that it may be lessened by maintaining quiescent conditions. The precautions of erecting stoppings rapidly, restricting the ventilation only at the last possible moment, and then withdrawing in anticipation of a possible explosion, are now commonly adopted. Whether precautions can be taken to avoid losing ground through the wrecking of more than one stopping is a matter for further thought. If one stopping only is wrecked, air is unlikely to leak into the affected area in sufficient quantity to re-establish dangerous conditions. It might not be far-fetched, therefore, to suggest that the most readily replaceable stopping should deliberately be made the weakest. The analyses of the return air during the six months that preceded the development of a heating were made by members of the staff of the Mines Department Testing Station through the courtesy of the Testing Officer, Captain C. B. Platt. The determinations of the small percentages of carbon monoxide involved were carried out on a modified form of the iodine-pentoxide apparatus designed by Mr. J. Ivon Graham. For assistance in the carrying out of the experiment we owe much to Messrs. S. Jones and W. Fryer of the staff of the Safety in Mines Research Board. We desire to thank the Safety in Mines Research Board for permission to publish this paper.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||