Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

27th July 1934, Page: 158

Law Intelligence

Income Tax: Liberty to Work Coal. — The House of Lords, on July 19, dismissed an appeal by the Crown in the action Elliott (inspector of taxes) v. Messrs. J. H. and F. H. Burn, from an Order of the Court of Appeal, dated July 7, 1933, allowing an appeal by the respondents, Messrs. J. H. and F. H. Burn, from the judgment of Mr. Justice Finlay, dated January 31, 1933, whereby an appeal by the Crown on a case stated by the Commissioners for the general purposes of the income tax for the Division of Chester Ward in the County of Durham was allowed, and the decision of the Commissioners was reversed.

The question which arose in the appeal was whether the respondents were liable to income tax in respect of certain annual payments, made to them by the owners of seams of coal lying beneath the land of which the respondents were surface owners, in return for a liberty to withdraw support from the land for the purpose of mining the coal without hindrance from the respondents or those claiming title under them. The respondents were owners of land at North Follonsby, Durham. By an agreement executed in 1906 they granted to Messrs. John Bowes and Partners the surface liberties required in the working of coal. By a further agreement of December 21, 1922, they granted to Messrs. Bowes and Partners liberty to work coal under the land, the consideration being a rent of £150 a year and a royalty of 1½d. for every ton worked. By the agreement there was full liberty in working the coal to withdraw support from the lands on payment of compensation. The respondents let the surface of the land to a farmer at a rack rent of £296, and that sum was taxed under rule 1 of schedule A of the Income Tax Act, 1918. For the years 1923 to 1929 inclusive the respondents received from Messrs. Bowes and Partners sums amounting to £2,948 16s., which were paid in full, without deduction of income tax, and assessments were made on the respondents for tax on those sums.

The respondents appealed to the General Commissioners, contending (1) That they were not in occupation of the land; (2) that if the sums in question were profits arising from land they were liable to deduction and were not chargeable on the owner; (3) that income tax had been charged on the full value of the land under schedule A (on the £296), and no further charge could be made; (4) that the sums were not annual profits or gains in respect of any trade, profession, employment, or vocation within schedule D; (5) that if the sums were not profits arising from lands they were annual payments made under a contract.

The Crown contended : — (1) That the payments were profits or gains; (2) that they were not a distribution of profits to the owner of the soil or property from which the colliery owner could deduct income tax; (3) that they were not part of the annual value of the land, as already taxed under rule I of schedule A, but that they came under the heading of "all other profits not before enumerated . . . arising from lands . . ." in rule 7 of Part II of schedule A.

The Commissioners held that the sums in question were not liable to assessment either under rule 7 or under case III of schedule D, and discharged the assessments.

Mr. Justice Finlay reversed their decision, holding that they were "other profits ... arising from lands " under rule 7.

The Court of Appeal reversed the decision of Mr. Justice Finlay and held that the land had already paid its tax under schedule A; and that the tonnage rents were merely payments made to the respondents to restrain them from exercising their power of protecting their land and were not profits from the land of the respondents at all.

The Crown now appealed.

Lord Warrington of Clyffe, in giving judgment, said that the Crown contended that the "rents" payable under the "lease" of December 1922, were profits comprised in rule 7 of No. II of schedule A. In his opinion, before the Crown could succeed, it must establish that such alleged profits arose from some hereditament, not being the lands themselves the subject of taxation under schedule A, for those last-mentioned lands were in the actual possession and occupation either of the owner or of his tenant. In a sense they arose from the right of support, for it was the possession of that right which enabled the respondents to obtain the payments in question. But it was now thoroughly well settled that the right of the surface owner to support of that surface by subjacent soil was not an easement, but was a natural incident to the land itself. If, therefore, the payments in question were to be regarded as arising from the right of support, they arose from the ownership of the land itself and would not come within rule II (7), but within rule I, and would be covered by the assessment on the annual value under that rule. Then the Attorney-General insisted that they should be treated as arising from the separate hereditament consisting of an easement alleged to be vested in the colliery company by virtue of the lease of 1922, the alleged easement being a right to let down the surface in the working of their mines without interference on the part of the surface owners. The answer to that seemed to be twofold. In the first place, on the true construction of the lease no such right was in fact conferred on the colliery company, and in the second place such a right, if conferred, would be a detriment to the owners of the surface, and he could not see how sums of money received as the consideration for granting the right to inflict that detriment could be profits or gains arising to the owners of the surface from such right itself. The first answer, however, required further consideration. The lease gave to the colliery company for a limited and uncertain period liberty, in working any adjacent coal which they were entitled to work, to withdraw from the lands of the respondents any support for such lands. That, he thought, merely meant that the respondents during the term would not seek either to recover damages for nuisance or an injunction restraining the colliery company from committing such a nuisance, but there was no actual surrender of the right of support itself. That that was so was, he thought, made plain by the provisions as to compensation, for it was only on the assumption that the right of support continued to exist, though its immediate assertion might be controlled, that any claim to compensation could possibly arise. On the whole he was of opinion that the claim on the part of the Crown that the payments in question constituted profits arising from lands chargeable under schedule A as being profits comprised in rule 7 of No. II of schedule A failed. In strictness that in terms only applied to the payments before 1927-28, but the same result followed as to the subsequent payments because it was common ground that the legal position was not altered by the transfer of the rule to schedule D under the Act of 1926. So far, if at all, as the payments represented a profit of the respondents, it came to them in respect of their property in the lands themselves. Tax in respect of that property had been assessed on the annual value of the lands as ascertained under rule 1, and that assessment covered the present claim. It followed, on the authority of Salisbury House Estate, Ltd., v. Fry ([1930] A.C., 432), that the Crown's alternative claim, that the payments constituted annual payments chargeable under case III of schedule D, also failed. In his opinion the appeal should be dismissed with costs.

The other noble and learned lords concurred.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Burn, Frank Hawthorn      Whos Who Page
Burn, John Henry      Whos Who Page
Finlay, —    Justice  
Warrington, Lord    Justice  


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print