|
13th July 1934, Page: 84, Column: 2 Notes from the Coal FieldsCumberland[Local Correspondence]. A case of considerable interest was heard by Judge G. C. Allsebrooke at Workington County Court recently. The St. Helens Colliery and Brickworks Co. applied for an order that the memoranda of the awards in the cases of three coal hewers against the company, which were sent to the registrar by the Cumberland Coal Trades Joint Compensation Committee, be recorded. The hewers concerned were Thomas Fee, William Kilgour and Thomas Clark. Their cases had previously been considered by the committee when they contracted miners' nystagmus. Compensation had been paid according to the award of the committee, and it was to prevent the men applying for further compensation that the application was made. The cases were taken together. — Mr. C. H. Spafford, who appeared for the company, said there were only two such committees, he thought, in England. It was the intention of the legislators that all cases arising under the Act should be decided by a representative committee of the employers and workmen, by an arbitrator specifically appointed, or by the county court judge of the district, as provided under s. 21. If the committee existed, the matter automatically went before them. But if the workman or the employer gave notice in writing before the committee met to consider the matter, then the jurisdiction of the committee was ousted. The question of recording the agreements was provided for in s. 23, s.s. 1, of the Act. The only ground on which a memorandum could be disputed was as to its genuineness. The committee dealt with between 300 and 400 cases in a year, but only those in which any question was likely to arise were sent to the Registrar for recording. The decisions were so numerous that they were not all sent. These three workmen all objected to the memoranda being recorded, Clark and Kilgour on the grounds that they had been refused the right to see the report of the medical referee. — His honour read the two reports which were issued to the committee in 1931 by Dr. Ross, of Carlisle, stating that both men had recovered from miners' nystagmus and were fit for their work. After listening to the men's submissions, he said he had had a great deal of experience of such cases as these, and had never yet come across one in which a committee was concerned. It was very far from being the most frequent form of procedure. Cases were far more frequently looked into by a judge of the county court, and he was not sure that it was not the best method. In these cases the registrar was satisfied, and he (the judge) was satisfied, that these were three genuine memoranda, and he was satisfied that he must order that they should be recorded.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||