|
7th July 1934, Page: 408, Column: 2 Winding Accidents: Their Cause And PreventionBy E. H. Oliver. Excerpts from paper read on 23rd June before the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers. For some years from force of circumstances I have been engaged in the study of winding conditions and problems. This was necessitated by the reconditioning of the shafts at Murton Colliery the stripping of brattice out of the downcast shafts, the introduction of larger cages, and the fitting up of the upcast shaft for the winding of men and material. This was effected without the loss of output and without idle time, and was accomplished only by eliminating any possible stoppages in the winding operations. This led to a further study of the prevention of overspeeding and overwinding on an electric winder, which resulted in an electro-magnetic dual control for men and material being produced which, under the most severe tests, emerged in every case successfully and proved that, even when the human element failed, with either a maximum or minimum load, there was no overwind and the descending cage did not reach the bottom or landing balks. After the Leigh disaster, a further study of this control for steam winders was made, which resulted in a similar device being applied successfully with a further end-of-the-wind control, which has made it impossible for a descending cage to reach the bottom or landing balks at a speed which would be injurious to men riding in the cage. The efficiency of the plant was taken into careful consideration, and actually improved upon. Results showed that the device was just as effective when running at high as at low speeds, and could be set to operate at any speed desired. Adjustment of Brakes. Various types of mechanical overwind appliances have failed on many occasions when called upon to meet abnormal conditions. In most mechanical appliances there is nothing to denote to the winding attendant that the overwind and overspeed appliances are in order and ready to act effectively in case of emergency. They have also failed to give the required protection, and enforced gradually reduced speed conditions in the most dangerous zone of winding operations, i.e., close to the end of the wind. This protection for what might be called a "landing-speed area" has hitherto never been effectively provided for and has always depended upon the human element for safely landing a descending load of men upon the landing balks or bottom. Accidents sometimes occur through incorrect adjustment of brakes. The importance of ensuring that the brakes and their transmission are always in proper working condition cannot be over-estimated, and no matter what protective device is fitted to any winding engine its effect is nullified if the brakes and their transmission are not in perfect condition and adjustment. Often the brake-transmission is beneath the floor of the engine-house and is difficult of access, and illumination for examination purposes is insufficient. This, of course, can be remedied by altering the design of the engine-room. If some means could be adopted whereby the winding attendant could be automatically warned when the transmission and adjustment were not correct, and that unless the adjustment was at once remedied the plant would automatically shut down, this danger would be eliminated. Similarly, if anything could be done to automatically increase the braking power close to the end of the wind, without impairing the efficiency of the engine and to come into operation only if the engine exceeded a predetermined speed in the landing area, the danger of a descending cage crashing on to the bottom due to weight of cage and ropes "slipping through" brakes, the factor of safety would be considerably increased. On any engine where there is a dual control, one for men and one for material or coal, there is always the danger of an accident occurring through the negligence of the winding attendant failing to change over from "COAL" to "MEN" when this, operation is left in his hands. If, however, an arrangement could be made whereby the change-over is made automatically without any interference by the winding attendant it will be at once seen that this danger would be removed. Another phase in winding operations where a number of accidents occur is caused by the winding attendant starting his engine in the wrong direction when either near the beginning or the end of the wind. It is quite a common practice to load material at the surface level, which in many cases is within a revolution of the banking-out level, and unless some means can be adopted at once to check the engine within a few feet if started in the wrong direction, there is always the possibility of the cage being taken into the detaching-hook and the rope being drawn into the engine-house and doing extensive material damage, apart from the possibility of danger to life and limb. There is also the danger of a cage loaded with men being returned on to the bottom or landing balks instead of commencing to ascend when being drawn from an intermediate level near the shaft bottom, and also when men are being loaded and unloaded either at bank or bottom. Prevention of Accidents. Having enumerated the accidents which can occur, it is necessary to consider by what means they can he prevented. The first and greatest danger to he overcome, of course, is failure of the human element, and it will be seen from the foregoing remarks that any device to prevent overwinding and overspeeding should embody the following essential points and be provided with the following attachments so as to make the winding cycle fool-proof :— (1) Two complete and separate controls, one for MEN winding only and the other for COAL or MATERIAL. Men should not be raised or lowered through the same safety margins as coal or materials. (2) Control of the speed of the engine within any predetermined limits throughout the wind. (3) Special landing-speed control for men only, compelling a progressively reduced speed from any prearranged point right to the end of the wind; and in the last few feet, the speed should not exceed 2 ft. per second if necessary, which can only be termed as "Dead Slow." (4) Limit controls beyond which the cage cannot go. (5) Impossibility of engine being started in the wrong direction without limiting the throttle- and reversing-lever movements, as these are essential for perfect winding conditions, particularly with heavy loads. (6) Provision for perfect adjustment of the brakes at all times, which will not allow of alteration under any conditions beyond the working margins prescribed. (7) Give increased braking effects at or near the end of the wind, or under any abnormal conditions where powerful braking is required. (8) Automatic change-over of controls from "COAL" to "MEN," and vice versa, without any interference from the winding attendant. (9) Give immediate warning to the winding attendant of any defects in connection with any of the vital parts of the device, or in the safety appliance, and also when he is operating his engine during dangerous phases of the wind. (10) Automatically adjust itself to varying lengths of rope, such as, recapping and rope stretching, etc. In the automatic electro-magnetic dual-control device which is fitted to both electric and steam winders at Murton Colliery, all these points have been carefully studied and the device designed to meet these essential requirements. The overspending and overwinding device consists of a dynamo which is series wound and is driven from the main shaft of the engine through gearing, the voltage being proportional to the speed of the engine. Its duty is to supply current to the main controlling circuit included in which are (a) the depth indicator; (b) the slow-brake solenoid ; (c) the brake-engine cataract solenoid. The duty of the quick-brake solenoid, which is energised from an entirely separate source from the slow-brake solenoid, is to shadow the slow-brake solenoid throughout the wind and to take supreme control at the end of the wind where quick braking is vital. It is set in operate at a slightly higher speed in mid-shaft, but when approaching the danger zones compels a predetermined progressively reduced speed right to the end of the wind which, if exceeded, immediately closes the plant down. When the quick brake comes into operation, by means of arms, levers, and trips, the reversing lever is automatically brought smartly into the reverse position, after which it finds the neutral position. The object of this is to take advantage of the extra resistance offered by the residual steam in the cylinders at either side of the piston and so indirectly to increase the braking power. If by some means or other the winding-engineman's attention could be focused on what his engine is doing relatively to over-speeding and critical phases during the wind, where the utmost care should be exercised, then the possibility of the overspeed or overwinding protection coming into action except in case of the human element failing may be considered remote. Signs Incorporated. To meet this requirement the following illuminated signs have been incorporated, so that at all times, except in case of failure of the human element, the winding-engineman is cognizant of what his engine is doing and is compelled to obey the dictates of the device. Overspeed Ammeter. — The indication warnings for correct maximum speeds are registered upon what is known as the over-speed ammeter, which clearly defines the speed from the commencement to the end of the wind. The maximum allowed speed for both material and men is clearly indicated by the pointer reaching the illuminated mark "COAL SPEED" (Green) or "MEN SPEED" (Red). Should this maximum point be exceeded there immediately appears a BLUE warning light and a Klaxon horn is sounded, this being the first warning that overspeeding is taking place ; immediately following this, the throttle-lever will commence to be drawn from the hand of the engineman and the pointer of the brake-indicator will commence to move in the onward direction. If these warnings are at once obeyed by him, he can immediately reduce the speed to normal, but if he fails to obey the signals then the slow-braking device takes immediate control. Drum-indicator. — The following illuminated signs are clearly set out as a further guide to the engineman for the particular movements and positions of the rages in the shafts (i) "MEN" or "COAL" is automatically continuously shown when either is being drawn. (ii) The point at which RETARDATION when winding MEN should commence. (iii) LANDING SPEED is automatically flashed on when descending cage reaches the predetermined position from the bottom or landing balks. (iv) DANGER is boldly shown when it is necessary for the cages to be moved in the WRONG DIRECTION towards either bank or bottom. Brake Adjustment and Brake-indicator. — By means of a scale in full view of the engineman the pointer of which indicates every movement of the brake-engine, the PULL OFF and FULL ON positions are clearly set out for both normal and super braking. In addition are shown the steady retardation positions. The PULL ON correct adjustment is specially defined, with markings, showing what the slackening effect of one or two cants on the adjustment-rods equal. When the position of the slackening effect margin is reached a RED warning light shows BEWARE; should this warning be ignored and the brakes allowed to slacken further to only a very small degree, then the whole plant will automatically shut down and may not be allowed to restart until the brakes have been set at correct adjustment. I should like to state in conclusion that, after many years experience with both mechanically- and electrically-controlled overwind devices, an electrically-controlled device is much superior to the mechanical type, both in its application and greater degree of reliability. The most important features in favour of the former device as described are that any defect is immediately brought to the notice of the winding attendant or engineman and all defects tend towards closing down the plant until they are rectified, whereas with the mechanical device it sometimes happens that the defect is found after an overwind or accident has taken place. Further and more important still, the electrically controlled device is instrumental in compelling the essential parts of a winding-engine being kept always in perfect. working condition, and by means of meters and indicators, the engineman sees exactly what the engine is doing and has to follow the dictates of the device.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||