Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

23rd June 1934, Page: 394, Column: 1

Stemming Materials

By J. A. S. Ritson And H. Stafford.

Since 1927 field experiments relating to the safe use of mining explosives have been carried out under Professor J. A. S. Ritson, D.S.O., M.C., B.Sc., of Leeds University, with the aid of a grant made by the Safety in Mines Research Board to the Mining Department of the University. Professor Ritson was assisted by an informal advisory committee of mining engineers, which in 1930 was reconstructed and appointed an official committee of the Research Board. Preliminary reports on some of the work on the stemming of explosives have already appeared in the Transactions of the Institution of Mining Engineers and have aroused considerable interest, and a full account of the investigations has now been published as S.M.R.B. Paper No. 84 — "Stemming Materials" by J. A. S. Ritson and H. Stafford (7d. net, H.M, Stationery Office).

It was noticed at an early stage that clay stemming was frequently ejected from the shot-holes not only in "blown-out" shots but also when the explosive had done useful work, and it was soon established that sand was much more effective, and therefore much safer, as a stemming material. Stemming with loose sand was, however, found to be too difficult to be a practical proposition and different methods were tried of binding the sand to form material which could be handled as easily as clay. The mixture of sand and clay eventually adopted has been proved, in actual practice on a large scale, to be more effective in every way than the clay normally used; smaller quantities of stemming are required, the efficacy of the explosives is increased so that the cost of explosives is reduced, and the danger of blown-out shots is practically eliminated. The stemming is strongly recommended for general adoption in the interests of safety. The addition to the stemming of 3 to 5 per cent. of calcium chloride has been found to keep the mixture in good condition for several months even in hot and dry atmospheres.

The notes appended are from Paper No. 84 :—

The Object of Stemming.

Whilst a study was being made of the safe use of explosives in mines, it was observed that clay stemming was frequently ejected from a shot-hole. Attention was drawn to this fact particularly by a shot that was suspected of igniting gas, when it was obvious that the clay stemming had been blown out inasmuch as the sides of the part of the shot-hole which remained were coated with a thin layer of clay. This and other observations made at the time raised the question as to whether clay was the most suitable substance to use as stemming material.

Stemming is used to confine the gaseous products, formed by the combustion of an explosive, to the smallest possible space, until the pressure generated is sufficient to burst the containing strata. Pressure also plays an important part in bringing about complete combustion of the solid explosive and reduces the possibility of the production of dangerous or unpleasant fumes. In other words, the more rigid the stemming the more effective the explosive as a blasting agent. Rigid stemming has therefore the following advantages :—

(1) It prevents blown-out shots and the possible projection of flame and hot gases into the external atmosphere;

(2) It reduces the amount of fumes produced to a minimum;

(3) It decreases the amount of explosive required to do a given amount of work; and

(4) It decreases the number of particles of fine dust in the air after a blast.

Statutory Regulations.

The Explosives in Coal Mines Order, 1934, Part I, Clause 2 (a), requires that: "Every charge shall be placed in a properly drilled and placed shot-hole, and shall have sufficient stemming, and each such charge shall consist of a cartridge or cartridges of not more than one description of explosive. It shall be the duty of the person firing the shot to satisfy himself that these requirements are fulfilled before he fires the shot." Clause 2 (b) enacts that "No iron or steel scraper, charger, tamping rod or stemmer shall be taken into or used in the mine; and only clay or other non-inflammable substances shall be used for stemming, and shall be provided by the owner, agent or manager of the mine."

The French regulations require that the length of stemming shall not be less than 20 centimetres (8 inches) for the first 100 grams (3.6 oz.) of charge, with an extra 5 centimetres (2 inches) for each 50 grams (1.8 oz.) of charge added. The total length of stemming need not exceed 50 centimetres (20 inches).

In Belgium, in mines in which gas may be present in dangerous quantities, "external" stemming in quantity five times the weight of time explosive, with a minimum of 1 kilogram (22 lb.), must be provided except when sheathed explosives are used.

In Germany, the regulations are such that the length of stemming must be at least one-third the depth of the shot-hole.

Quantity of Stemming Required.

The term "sufficient stemming" in the British shot-firing regulations at once raises the question as to how much is sufficient.

It has been established at the Safety in Mines Research Station at Buxton that one inch of dry clay stemming placed in front of a maximum allowable charge of any permitted explosive will prevent the ignition of the most sensitive methane-air mixture when the charge is fired from a mortar into it. Such a small amount of stemming is, however, obviously inadequate to hold the charge of explosive and enable it to do its work, and it is usually recommended that the hole should be stemmed to the collar, that is to say, the portion of the hole not occupied by explosive should be filled with stemming. It is well known that blasting explosives produce less fumes and break the greatest amount of rock when they are well confined, and the practice of stemming to the collar has therefore everything to commend it.

Clay as a Stemming Material. — Clay has been almost universally used in coal mines as stemming material, and in the majority of cases the clay found in the mine, or at the surface, has been accepted, without question, as the best material to use. Clay has many important advantages :—

(1) It is found in or about every mine

(2) It can easily be moulded in cartridges for insertion in the shot-hole

(3) It retains its plasticity except in hot and dry mines

(4) It can be stored underground anywhere;

(5) It is incombustible;

(6) It is cheap and needs little preparation before being taken underground or used; and

(7) Shot-firers are familiar with its use.

In some coal mines and nearly all metalliferous mines, stone or rock dust drillings are used as stemming for dipping holes, while in sinking pits water is generally employed.

The use of substances other than clay is not new, for French, German and American investigators have been working with these in recent years. Sand was in fact used and recommended for filling vertical shot-holes in German quarries as long ago as 1807.

Underground Work.

Observations of shot-firing operations in coal having indicated that clay stemming was not blown out to the same extent as quarry experiments suggested, it was decided to conduct a series of experiments in coal. This work was carried out in the Silkstone and Beeston seams of West Yorkshire.

Procedure. — The colliery deputies fired the shots under direct supervision. The coal, which in both seams is about 4 feet thick, was undercut to a depth of 4½ feet and shot-holes, 1 inches in diameter, were drilled where necessary. Several types of permitted explosives were used and the charge in each shot-hole was the amount considered adequate to do the work. No attempt was made deliberately to overcharge or undercharge any of the shots. The first shots were stemmed to the collar and the amount of stemming used was decreased until the stemming was ejected. In order to observe whether the stemming was blown out, brattice sheets were set up in front of the shot-holes. The kinds of stemming used were clay, hard and soft; stone dust (ground shale), wet and dry; and sand, wet and dry. Difficulty was experienced in stemming with sand and with dry stone dust.

Experiments made in the Beeston seam showed that, although much less stemming was required in coal than in hard limestone, the relative lengths of the various materials required to prevent the stemming being blown out were approximately the same.

The results of the preliminary work may now be summarised as follows :—

(1) Minimum amount of stemming required :—

(2) Provided that the charges are well proportioned to the amount of work to be done, the amount of stemming required bears little relation to the weight of explosive used.

(3) The amount of stemming required is proportional to the hardness of the rock.

(4) Slow-acting explosives, such as blasting powder, require more stemming than high explosives, the ratio being 5 to 4.

Advantages of Sand and Clay Stemming.

The efficiency of sand and clay stemming has been demonstrated successfully to mining engineers in the following areas : Castleford, Nuneaton, Swansea, Newcastle, Bolton, Nottingham, Wrexham, Cardiff, and Buxton.

The procedure at these demonstrations has been to drill holes 1½ inches in diameter and 6 to 6½ feet deep in a bench in an open quarry. Holes were charged in pairs with equal amounts of explosive. In one hole the shot was stemmed with ordinary clay, and in the other with the sand and clay mixture. Canisters were placed over the tops of the shot-holes. On firing the shots the clay stemming was ejected and lifted the canister some 50 feet, or more, into the air, while the sand stemming remained in position and the canister simply rolled over. Lengths of clay up to 4½ feet were blown out while a length of 1¾ feet of sand and clay remained in position. As a result of these demonstrations the use of sand and clay stemming has been widely adopted in most of the coalfields and satisfactory results are being obtained.

The chief advantage claimed for the sand and clay mixture is that, provided sufficient is used, the stemming will stay in position until the work of the explosive is completed. The minimum amount of stemming required must depend upon the hardness, or toughness, of the rock blasted but 24 inches of sand and clay stemming is sufficient to prevent ejection from the hardest rock likely to be met with in coal mining practice. A length of from 12 to 15 inches of stemming of this type has been found to be sufficient in coal of average character.

A second advantage is convenience in use. The mixture can be moulded into cartridges with the same ease as clay, but, unlike clay, it does not adhere to the rod during the process of stemming. If treated with calcium chloride it can be stored either on the surface or underground for an indefinite time without deterioration, and all the stemming sent underground can be usefully employed.

The cost of the mixture is comparable with that of clay, and, in some cases, a saving has been effected. The reason is that all the stemming material has been used, and, unlike with clay, none has been washed through its becoming too hard to use. The saving of time otherwise spent in breaking and wetting dried clay underground decreases the cost of shot-firing.

Examples are to hand which show that reductions of as much as 33 per cent. in the amounts of explosive used have been effected by the use of sand and clay stemming.

It is generally recognised that blown-out shots are a potential source of danger. Blown-out shots can be avoided by the use of sand and clay stemming. In this respect the stemming is particularly useful when applied in conjunction with low-density explosives which frequently occupy more than half the length of the shot-hole and so leave little space for stemming.

The reduction in the volume of fumes from shots is of great advantage. The fumes are in themselves unpleasant and they delay a proper examination of the ground which may have been loosened due to blasting.

General Considerations.

There are several minor difficulties associated with the use of sand and clay stemming which can only be solved at the collieries concerned. For example, the amount of calcium chloride to be added will depend upon the conditions of the mine and the length of time the material is likely to be stored before use. The correct amount can readily be found by experiment.

As to the best way to prepare the stemming, a mixture of three parts of sand to one of clay is generally the most efficient. Wet methods of mixing may be adopted and have indeed been quite satisfactory when care is taken not to grind the sand or to add too much water.

The amount of water present in properly prepared sand and clay stemming is between 8 and 10 per cent. by weight.

The quality of the clay or binding material used must determine the proportions of the mixture. It is of more importance to have a cartridge which can be pushed to the back of a shot-hole without breaking than to have the maximum amount of sand in the mixture. Theme is no great advantage to be gained by making a mixture containing more than three parts of sand to one of clay, but, on the other hand, if the local clay is so poor that it will only bind in the proportion of one part of sand to one part of clay, it may be worth while to import a better quality clay for the purpose.

Houghton Sand-bag Stemming. — The Houghton system of stemming consists essentially of using cotton bags as containers for the sand stemming. The bags, which are about 10 inches long, are loosely filled with sand anti tied at the neck, sufficient string being left to lead to the mouth of the shot-hole.

The advantages claimed for this kind of stemming include greater efficiency of blasting due to the greater resisting power of the sand. Another claim, probably the most important, is the ease with which a misfired charge could be recovered. In the event of a misfire, all that would be necessary would be to pull the string attached to the sand-bag anti withdraw the stemming.

This method of stemming was first of all compared with loose sand in a limestone quarry under conditions where 1¾ feet of sand would always remain in the shot-hole after firing. Three sandbags were sometimes ejected. When the sand-bags were slightly smaller than the diameter of the shot-hole three were always ejected. The results indicated that, though this type of stemming is not as efficient as loose sand, it is better than clay. The stemming of a shot with sand-bags is an easy operation, and the claim as to ease of recovery of the charge in the event of a misfire is justified. Sandbags without the string attached can be withdrawn by means of a copper rod fitted with a corkscrew-end. In practice the diameter of a shot-hole varies along its length, the more so as the drills become worn. Further, in order to comply with the shot-firing regulations, it is necessary to fireproof the bags, and, though it is comparatively easy to render cotton fireproof, it is difficult to prevent it from smouldering.

Stemming in Wet Shot-holes.

Experiments were made to find an efficient stemming material for use in wet vertical shot-holes in sinking pits.

The experimental work was carried out in a hard limestone bench where shot-holes 1½ inches in diameter were drilled vertically downwards 5½ feet to 6½ feet deep. The holes were loaded with charges of Polar Saxonite which varied between 20 and 32 oz. and submarine detonators were employed. The holes were filled with water which was displaced by whatever stemming material was used. Metal canisters were placed over the shot-holes to show whether the stemming material was ejected or not.

Sand and clay stemming was net very effective in wet shot-holes. The holes were difficult to stem and by the time the hole was filled the stemming had the consistency of thin mud.

Water is not a good stemming material. Canisters placed over shot-holes with 4 feet of water stemming were blown to a height of about 100 feet when the shots were fired.

However, water may be displaced by coarse sand poured into the holes and gently tamped. In hard limestone a length of 2¾ feet of wet sand is sufficient to prevent the stemming being ejected, while in a dry hole 1¾ feet would be sufficient in similar circumstances.

This work was extended and experiments were carried out during actual sinking operations. The procedure adopted was to fire three complete rounds of shots in a sinking pit, using three different kinds of stemming material, and to compare the results obtained. The strata sunk through were ordinary coal measure rocks, and the shaft was 16 feet in diameter. The types of stemming tried were water, sand and clay, and sand alone.

When water stemming was employed, 23¼ lb. of Antifrost Gelignite were used in the sumping holes and 11 lb. of Alluminite in the trimming holes. The results were considered to be satisfactory, but several sockets were left.

The next round was in slightly harder rock and sand and clay was used as stemming. In the sumping holes 21 lb. of Antifrost Gelignite were used, with 10¾ lb. of Alluminite in the trimming holes. The results were satisfactory and there was a marked diminution of fumes and noise. Also, less material was thrown on to the shaft walls and no sockets were left.

The third trial with sand alone as stemming material was carried out in rocks similar to those encountered during the test with sand and clay. The charges of explosive were similar to those used in the previous test. The results were good and, in addition, there was a diminution of noise and smoke, no sockets being left and fewer stones being thrown on to the shaft walls.

The tests showed the value of sand and sand and clay as stemming, but the use of the latter is not recommended owing to the difficulty in getting it down the holes, which had to be unwatered before the stemming was inserted. The mixture tends to disintegrate in water, forming a sandy mud. On the other hand, stemming with sand alone is a simple matter as the sand can be poured directly into the shot-hole, and displaces the water.

Summary.

1. It has been found experimentally and in practice that the clay commonly used for stemming shots is relatively inefficient when compared with other materials.

2. Sand is the most efficient stemming material.

3. The best sand for the purpose is graded in size between 5 and 50 I.M.M. standard mesh (1/10 inch to 1/100 inch).

4. Stemming a horizontal shot-hole with sand is a long and difficult process.

5. Sand and clay can be bound together to form an excellent stemming material.

6. A three-to-one mixture of sand and clay makes a stemming material which is as efficient for practical purposes as sand alone.

7. In addition to calcium chloride, 3 to 5 per cent. depending on mine conditions, enables the stemming material to be stored without deterioration.

8. The best method of preparing the mixture is to dry and grind the clay, and mix all the ingredients dry; water is added afterwards to give the mixture the right consistency.

9. A reduction of as much as 33 per cent. in the cost of explosives has been effected by the use of sand and clay stemming.

10. The use of sand and clay stemming will reduce the risks of shot-firing by preventing blown-out shots and reducing the amount of fumes produced.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ritson, John Anthony Sydney, Prof.      Whos Who Page
Stafford, H.      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print