9th June 1934, Page: 378, Column: 1
"Quality Coals"
By H. E. Tyson, M.A., M.I.M.E.
From paper prepared for presentation before the North of England
Institute at Mining and Mechanical Engineers (Associates and Students'
Section), 26th May, 1934.
Demand for Big, Clean Coal.
Although the imperative demand of twelve months ago for
large sizes of coal has somewhat abated and a fairly steady market
is now open for smaller sizes, it is still the fact that big coals do
bring better prices, and it is obvious that whereas big coal can be
crushed to small to satisfy an immediate demand the reverse
operation is impossible. So it still behoves every member of the
mining industry to strive for the biggest percentage of large coal
obtainable under any given set of conditions. Also, it is made
manifest by the great progress in coal cleaning installations that
the consumer now insists upon having his coal clean, and we all
know that much can be done in actual mining operations to ensure
that the amount of dirt sent to the surface with the run of mine
coal is a minimum.
Here is a question which I have not yet seen discussed or
answered: Is It cheaper to clean coal at the surface or at the face
Remember the surface has the advantage of better light and
mechanical assistance, and the only form of cleaning done at the
face is hand picking done in a comparatively fair light, and a
filler's output is definitely governed by the time he spends on
cleaning his coal. Extremes must of course be avoided, and when
a seam is clean and has a good roof we must expect clean coal.
The presence of bands of a compact nature (i.e., in slab form)
should also lead us to expect clean coal, but when bands are thin
and friable, or when the roof is of "short" stone, especially when
such foreign matter is dark in colour, I really think it would pay
to allow the face worker to fill everything away and do the cleaning
at the surface.
Methods of cleaning I do not propose to deal with, as the subject
is big enough for a paper of its own, and for each particular case
there will be a particular "best" method. It is with methods
of mining operations that I propose to deal, the object aimed at
being the most economical blending of output, big coal and clean
coal.
Section of Seam.
The seam characteristics will loom most prominently in the
foreground of our effort to produce quality coal. Hardness or
tenderness will largely determine the size of the coal delivered into
the wagons, as will the detailed section of the seam; bands of
dirt will determine one dimension of the pieces as will bands of
fusain which are notorious planes of breakage; cleavages which
are strongly marked will reduce the size of pieces also. Output
of course is also largely determined, for some coals are much more
easily worked than others, although a change of system, or even
so simple a matter as a change of line of face, may sometimes work
seeming miracles when a difficult seam is being worked.
Cleanness of the output is clearly determined by the nature of
roof and floor and the number, thickness and nature of dirt bands —
a light coloured, compact natured stone being readily separated
from the coal as contrasted with the difficulty of distinguishing
and picking out fine, dark coloured dirt. The question of good
illumination is also here very much in evidence, as better cleaning
can be done with a good light.
Method of Working.
Bord and Pillar Working, like the poor, will always be with us
so long as there exist property and sea floors to be supported, and
the forming of pillars is usually carried out by the employment
of arc-wall chain or percussive heading machines.
The nicking of a fast place would seem to be an essential to the
obtaining of a good yield of big coal, and it is only recently that a
satisfactory arc-wall machine has been available which can nick.
The arc-shaped cut is a bad one for satisfactory shot-firing, as many
as three shots being generally necessary, with the expenditure of
about two pounds of explosive — this has its effect on the size of
coal produced, which is in general small; also, bands in the seam
are usually broken up small and intricately mixed with the coal.
The advent of the Universal heading machine which can nick is a
step forward, but the arc-shaped cut still remains. The percussive
machine (electric or compressed air) has a distinct advantage here
as a "place" can be squared back and nicked, and two shots are
usually all that are necessary, the coal produced being of much
better quality than that from the arc-wall cut.
Longwall Working. — Better quality coals are obtained from
longwall working owing to the assistance of roof weight, the straight
cut and the fewer shots generally necessary. One factor tending
to produce small and dirty coal, however, is the amount of casting
having to be done in low seams to get the coal into a gateway to
be filled into a tub. If the tub can be got along the face, however,
this factor does not come in.
The distance apart of the gateways is usually governed by the
labour cost, a balance being struck between paying a filler for
casting and a stoneman for canch work, and the question of better
quality coal from a shorter cast is probably not given the consideration
it may warrant.
Transit is usually indifferent to bad on longwall faces owing to
heaving of the floor, stones falling in from the sides and reef,
leading to distortion of the way and consequent frequent derailments
leading to breakage of coal in the tub.
Conveyor Working is undoubtedly the best for the achievement
of all three of our objects : output per man and per district is
greater, coal is bigger and, ceteris paribus, cleaner than in any
other system of working. Roof weight is definitely controlled
by systematic timbering, falls of ramble and stone being fewer
than on longwall faces (where the gateway brow is a prolific source
of dirt getting into the coal). There is little or no fear of goaf
stone or packing material getting mixed with the coal as it is put
straight on to the conveyor and rapidly carried away, and the
conveyor itself forms a definite line of distinction between the
goaf and the working face. Bigger coal is filled as pieces can be
rolled on to a conveyer which could not be lifted into a tub. Coal
can be better cleaned as band, stone kirvings or ramble can be
thrown over the belt clear of the coal got down.
Transport.
Underground transport principally consists of tubs on a rope
haulage system, and the age-old controversy between fast main
and tail, or slow endless rope, crops up. Slow endless rope, I
think, wins hands down when good quality coal is wanted.
Conveyor transport causes much less breakage than tub transport,
the coal being carried smoothly, especially on a rubber belt,
without any of the jars encountered on rolleyways, and it is
noticeable that in modernised collieries conveyors are being used
to carry coal over longer and longer distances. Chutes or spouts
should be fixed to conveyor ends where tubs are loaded to enable
the coal to slide into the tub instead of dropping.
Working Detail.
Position of Cut. — There is a great variance of opinion as to the
best place in which to kirve the seam. Undercutting is generally
preferred to overcutting, but whether the cut shall be in the coal
or the stone is a most debatable point.
When there is a band near the floor — up to one foot, say, in a
low seam, or two feet in a thick seam — it is general practice to cut
this hand out, and general practice is probably correct, as the
stone kirvings can be cast back or filled away separately and kept
clear of the coal. Trouble of course arises, and that not infrequently,
when the cutter, whether arc-wall or longwall, owing to some
irregularity in the floor or carelessness or inexperience of the
cutter-men, does not cut the band out cleanly, but cuts half coal
and half stone, and it most often happens that kirvings which look
black are filled away as coal although there may be present as
much as 60 or 70 per cent. of stone.
Cutting in the thill presents much the same problem, especially
in longwall working, owing to the fact that packs are generally
within 6 feet of the face, and the problem of disposing of stone
kirvings is a very real one. What often happens is that an attempt
is made to fill them away from the gateway and to cast some back
into the goaf between the packs, and I am afraid that a goodly
proportion remains and gets mixed up with the coal and is filled
away with it. Working on a conveyor face is not so bad, as there
is a definite line beyond which the kirvings must be cast, C.P. the
conveyor, which also serves as a barrier between kirvings and loose
coal.
Even on a conveyor face, however, a great deal of kirvings get
on to the conveyor and are filled away with the coal. Another
very real objection to stone kirvings on a conveyor face is that they
are very liable to choke up the belt rollers, wheels or slides causing
breakages, especially when the roof is broken off too close behind
the belt, there being thus no room for kirvings which become piled
up and run in below.
The alternative to stone cutting, cutting in the coal, most
definitely means that cleaner coal is produced, all the coal kirvings
being filled away and the place cleaned up. Cutter-men generally
prefer cutting in the coal, and it is rarely that they get into the
stone to produce dirty kirvings. More often indeed coal is cropped
and lost, and this is one of the big disadvantages of cutting in the
coal. Cropping coal cannot be avoided sometimes, although we
never admit this to cutter-men, of course, especially when the
bottom few inches of the seam is harder than that above or than
the floor.
For obtaining big coal we are at an immediate disadvantage
when cutting in the coal, for it is clear that in a Yard seam we
sacrifice 14 per cent. by a 5-inch cut. The kirvings, however,
will by no means be all fines, especially if sharp picks are employed
on a suitable chain. The seven or nine position chain is probably
best, and there are now several varieties of hard steel tipped picks
to choose from which remain sharp for a long time and reduce the
labour of changing picks which is always a fertile source of delay
and neglect, cutter-men frequently neglecting to change picks
when they should do. Sharp picks produce a fair proportion of
big kirvings of the "doubles" size, while the product of blunt
picks, which have a grinding action, is invariably dust of differing
degrees of fineness.
Shot-firing. — The question of the position and number of shots
to be fired, and the best type of explosive to use, is one that has
been a prolific source of experiments and arguments by everybody
interested, from University professors to deputies and shot-firers,
and I doubt very much whether any definite results of a general
nature have been, or ever will be, arrived at. One thing, however,
should, I think, be insisted upon, that is, that the manager must
have control over the number and size of shots fired, for fillers are
naturally apt to err on the side of too many and too big shots,
and we all know of some men in particular who would blow everything
to small if allowed their own way. This control is easily
exercised when the shots are fired by a shot-firer and, I think,
could be extended with benefit to seams where the men fire their
own shots.
Type of Explosive. — High density and low density explosives
both have their supporters with many arguments and experiences
to back their views. The main difference can be readily summed
up. A high density explosive produces more small coal at the
shothole, but the effect of the shot is only local, whereas a low
density explosive has an action more akin to the mechanical one
of wedging and affects the coal over a much more extended area.
To choose between the two in a general way would be impossible.
Mechanical Methods.
The total abolition of shot-firing is a very popular bee in the
Mines Inspectors' bonnet, and without a doubt accidents caused
by shot-firing, including the big explosions which are such spectacular
accidents, are very much to be regretted, and every effort
must be, and is being, made to reduce them, and where a reduction
in the number of shots fired can be made it most certainly should
be, if in the interest of safety only. Except in special favourable
circumstances, however, I cannot see how any purely mechanical
method of winning coal can compete in cost with the practice of
using explosives. There is little doubt, though, that the use of
physical as opposed to chemical methods of working coal will lead
to an increase in the output of the larger sizes of coal, and the
extra cost of "getting" can be sometimes overbalanced by the
increased value of the coal got.
Cardox is, I maintain, not a true explosive, although included as
such in the Coal Mines Act and Regulations, for the action is a
purely physical one of expansion of a highly compressed gas, no
chemical action taking place and no formation of a gas occurring.
Its one advantage is that there is no danger of explosion of gas
resulting from its use.
Another substitute for shot-firing is the Hydraulic Burster
which requires oversize shot-holes to be drilled for it as well. The
coal is cut and may be nicked as well. The Burster consists of a
cylinder of suitable length round the sides of which are plungers
forced out by means of hydraulic pressure applied by a portable
high-pressure pump. A neat hole is drilled to receive the cylinder
and liners are placed over the plungers to spread the force over a
bigger surface. The cylinder end is now connected by a semi-flexible
copper tube to the portable pump, which is readily trailed
along the face, and the pressure is pumped up by working a lever.
The plungers being forced out exert a wedging action and break
down the coal. The effect depends on the nature of the coal — if
the coal is friable, or of an elastic nature, the expansion is taken
up by the immediate layers of coal, and the effect of the Burster
is neutralised and inoperative in breaking down the coal for filling.
The action can be made to operate vertically or horizontally, or
at an angle in between, the cylinder being placed in the hole to
suit the conditions.
When we come to consider the question of mechanical tools we
think immediately of the pneumatic pick, and no doubt this is one
of the most useful appliances ever devised for the use of the coal
filler or hewer. The only factor operating against its use is our
old bugbear the cost of installation. To be really effective the pick
requires a working pressure up to 80 lb., and it is not easy to obtain
this pressure on a coal face, even if a really efficient system of pipe
lines is maintained.
The mall and wedge and pinchbar are among the most useful
tools to employ to assist the filler to get big coals. The form of
pinchbar favoured at Ashington is made from 1" square bar, some
4' 6" long, one end rounded for about a foot for convenience in
handling, and the other end turned up considerably and having a
sharp chisel point. Considerable leverage can be exerted by
sensible use of the turned up point, and the tool is most efficient
for breaking down coal.
Conclusion.
If any particular quality of coal is required other than that which
is obtained most easily, it has to be paid for. By this I mean that
if attempts are made to increase the quality by a method of
"getting," as distinct from a method of working, generally speaking
some mechanical aid must be used to reduce shot-firing, and it is
my experience that such aid is bound to increase the cost. Whether
the cost is worth it remains for the individual to decide.
Speaking from general observation only — I have no figures to
confirm my views — I am of the opinion that the best balance is
struck between our three desires by the conveyor system of
working, and the use of high explosive shots for breaking into the
face, the rest of the coal being got down by use of wedge, pinchbar
and pneumatic picks, it the cost of the latter can be borne.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Tyson, H. E. | | | |