26th May 1934, Page: 361, Column: 2
Human Factor In Rescue Work
In a written contribution to the discussion before the South
Staffordshire and Warwickshire Institute of Mining Engineers, on
Dr. W. Hancock's paper on "The Time Factor and Other Points
of Importance in the Use of Breathing Apparatus,"
Mr. A. W. Winborn, of the Monmouthshire Collieries Rescue Station, said
that in real work underground the mine rescuer was exposed to
many "external" dangers, and in such an emergency the "entrapped
procedure" was the only logical course of action to be
taken, and it had been a frequent subject of discussion at rescue
training stations, the value of economising oxygen supply having
been diligently taught and practised. In the main, and apart
from "external" dangers, the safety of wearers of self-contained
breathing apparatus depended very largely upon three things,
viz. The constant air tightness of the apparatus, keeping strictly
within the limitations of the apparatus, and lastly (and, perhaps
the most important of all), being master of one's own self. The
trouble was in getting men to behave sensibly in sudden, grave
emergencies. Nothing short of the actual behaviour of men in
the face of real danger, in unexpected situations, would give any
real guide as to their temperamental suitability. This "temperamental
suitability" was the most important safety factor in such
work. One of the dangers to which men were liable was that of
being suddenly deprived of oxygen reserve. In the Midlands, the
pressure-gauge valve was usually kept in the "on" position, which
meant that in the event of damage to the flexible gauge-tubing a
considerable amount of oxygen could be lost in a very short time.
Men were of course taught how to act in such emergencies and at
some stations they were taught and practised an emergency method
of oxygen supply to one another, either from a small cylinder
which the brigade carry, or from their own cylinders. This worked
out very well in practice, but, in real emergencies, would the system
work successfully ? It would depend upon the human element.
The trouble about this temperamental side of the business was the
fact that it was difficult to locate in the individual. Something
might be done to inculate a temperamental suitability by exposing
men to sudden and unexpected situations or even shocks, apart
from which, the only other method or process of forming anything
like an accurate idea of men's suitability was by watching their
behaviour in real work. The data relating to the use of the
"Novita" and "Novox" apparatus as a means of enabling a man
to walk through, or be carried through, an irrespirable atmosphere
was valuable. There was no doubt that the potential value of
these appliances in this direction was realised by all trained rescue
men, who regarded them as a kind of emergency rescue apparatus.
Everyone would agree, added Mr. Winborn, that pressure-gauges
as at present supplied were somewhat unreliable and that it was
extremely difficult to maintain uniformity in their registrations.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Hancock, W., Dr. | | | |
| Winborn, A. W. | | | |