|
3rd May 1934 Unnecessary Inquests?Suspected Silicosis CasesA suggestion that the Coroner's court was being used for the purpose of gathering statistics for some other body was made when the inquests were resumed at Egremont on Thursday on two iron-ore miners who were suspected to be suffering from silicosis. The first inquest concerned Robert Postlethwaite, aged 49, of Beck Cote Cottage, Calderbridge, who died on March 21st. Thomas Cooper, a brother-in-law of the dead man, said Postlethwaite commenced work at Florence Mine in 1921, and had been employed in the mines ever since. Prior to that he had worked at Eskmeals gun range. Replying to Mr. R. Butler, Inspector of Mines, witness said he was not aware that his brother-in-law had worked at Eskmeals quarries. The Coroner said his information was that deceased worked at the Florence Mine from 1921 to 1925, and then for a few months at Eskmeals. He commenced work in the Ullcoats Mine, Egremont, late in 1925, and worked there until 1931. John Stephen Faulds, pathologist at the Cumberland Infirmary, Carlisle, said he made a post-mortem examination on Postlethwaite, and found that death was due to dense fibrosis of both lungs together with hypertrophy and dilatation of the heart. The fibrosis which he found was not characteristic of silicosis. The Coroner: Do you or do you not say that death was caused by silicosis or tuberculosis accompanied by silicosis? I would not say that silicosis alone was the primary cause of the fibrosis. Other Cases Replying to Mr. C. Edmonds (for the relatives), Dr. Faulds agreed that the fibrosis he found was comparable with other cases of fibrosis he had found amongst iron ore miners. Was that fibrosis very dense? You get a similar type amongst coal-miners. A verdict in accordance with the medical evidence was returned. The inquest was then resumed on James Mason Birbeck (60), of St John's Terrace, Bigrigg, whose death occurred a few weeks ago. Dr. Faulds said that in this case he examined the lungs and found 10.8 percent of silica to ash. The percentage of iron to ash was 42.0. This was a higher silica content than he had found in any previous case. "Examined under a microscope the appearance of the lungs more closely resembled silicosis than in the case of any other iron ore miner I have examined," he added. The cause of death was fibrosis of the lungs, pulmonary tuberculosis, with cavitation and acute dilatation of the heart. Percentage Of Silica The Coroner: You do not say that death was due to silicosis although there was a great deal of silica present in the lungs. Was it sufficient to cause death? No, in the case of a South African miner the percentage is 40. The Coroner: I am holding an inquest to see if silicosis is the cause of death. When I come I am simply told that it was fibrosis and not a silicosis case. It is causing a good deal of trouble for nothing. Dr. Faulds said that if he had found over 15 percent of silica he would have certified that death was due to silicosis. "A Lot Of Trouble" A verdict in accordance with the medical evidence was recorded and the Coroner said that the inquiries were causing a lot of trouble and expense and they seemed to be getting no further, but the Home Office had asked him to hold an inquiry in every case in which silicosis was suspected. Mr. J. F. Baxter (for the mining interests): Might I put it this way. Someone else is trying to get statistics from the Coroner's Court. Dr. Faulds: It is the only way they can get the information. Mr. Baxter: The point I am thinking about is that the Coroner holds inquests week after week for getting out statistics that could be got in another way. The Coroner said his duty was simply to find the cause of death and when a certificate was issued by a doctor attending a person as was done in these cases he did not think he ought to be asked to hold an inquest. Dr. A. G. Henderson, Whitehaven, who was present, remarked "It is the Medical Board that wants waking up."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||