|
3rd March 1934, Page: 260, Column: 1 November (1933) ExaminationsReport of Central ExaminersThe report of the Central Examiners has been issued on the examinations for certificates of competency as managers and under-managers of mines held in November, 1933. It is proposed in view of their general interest to reproduce (in italics) in this and succeeding issues the comments of the Examiners on the work done by the candidates who attended the examinations, the comments being preceded by the text of the questions. The official Question Papers, containing also the plans and sketches, are obtainable (2s. net) through H.M. Stationery Office. Winning and Working (1st Class). (1) Sketch a lay-out of workings and haulage roads in a coal seam 5 ft. thick, and dipping 1 in 4, to yield approximately 1,000 tons from one shaft in one shift. State the output you could expect from the separate haulage roads, also the type of haulage you would use on each of these roads. (50) Although the dip of the seam was given as 1 in 4 — an important factor — very few candidates took particular note of this. In consequence the layouts were not made to the best advantage. The longwall advancing method of working was generally favoured, as was also the endless rope system of haulage. (2) What arrangements would you suggest to prevent the cage from falling down the shaft in the event of the cage chains breaking owing to a severe overwind? (40) A great majority of the candidates would arrange for automatic catches to be placed in the headgear at a point where the bottom of the cage would be when the detaching hook was in the bell, and a fair number suggested a better way by having a series of catches between the detaching point and the bell. Some candidates suggested safety chains of rather longer length than the ordinary cage chains. (3) Specify the kinds of material that may form the roof and the floor of a coal seam, and indicate how their qualities may affect the working of the seam. What difference would you expect to find in the material immediately below the seam, if the seam had been formed in situ, or if it had been deposited according to the drift theory? (40) On the whole this question was well answered, although only a small number of candidates were definite as to the material immediately below the seam if formed in situ, as opposed to the drift theory. (4) An important read in constant use is 200 yards long, 7 ft. high and 14 ft. wide, and is supported by timber. Above the timber are soft strata 10 ft. thick lying under hard sandstone. As the soft strata are giving considerable trouble, it is decided to lift the road, so that the sandstone becomes the roof of the road. Explain in detail how you would do this. (40) Many candidates missed the point that the roadway was an important one and in constant use, and explained several ways of doing this work which would have been quite satisfactory had it been possible to put the roadway out of use for a considerable period. The best answers were those describing how the soft material was dropped under control into pit tubs until there was sufficient room against the hard roof to set temporary timber, then dropping long sections of the remaining soft material at a convenient time, leaving it on the ground and laying the rails above it. (5) What kind of sinking kibble do you prefer? Explain, with the help of a sketch, how you would empty it on the surface. Also sketch the type of rider you would use for guiding the kibble in the shaft, showing the position of the rope capping, and detaching hook. (40) The first part of the question was well answered; the second part was very badly answered. Almost invariably the sketches showed the rider above the detaching hook, which would prevent the detaching hook from entering the bell. It can only be concluded that the consequences in case of an overwind had not been considered. (6) A seam is to be worked under a cross-measure drift. Anticipating a considerable movement of the strata, it is decided to line the drift with concrete blocks. What shape of block would you use, and how would you carry out the work ? (40) The answers to this question were very unsatisfactory. It was obvious that this class of work is unknown to a great majority of the candidates. (7) Discuss the conditions most suitable for, under-rope, and over-rope, endless haulage respectively. How would you attach the tubs to the rope in each case? (40) The conditions which would affect the choice of haulage were well explained. Practically all the candidates would use ordinary lashing chains in connection with over-rope haulage in preference to clips. In almost every case the type of clip suggested for under-rope haulage was satisfactory. Ventilation (1st Class). (1) The plan which accompanies this Paper is that of a colliery working a fiery seam and employing about 400 workers in the principal shift. Coal is worked only in the downcast shaft. Show how you would arrange the ventilation, marking the direction of each air-current, and the positions of all air-crossings, doors, stoppings, regulators and sheets. Use the signs laid down in the Regulations, and colour the path of the intake air blue and that of the return red. (50) The most noticeable error was that of placing the upcast pit on the dip side, instead of the rise; with the undesirable result that much of the haulage had to be done in the return airways, unnecessarily. There were a few cases of omission of separation doors near the pit bottom, and of neglect to provide the statutory second intake. Several candidates made their main intake and main return enter a longwall face by adjoining roads, which will not function property. The majority of the plans submitted were good. (2) Assume that you are in charge of a fiery colliery and have to select safety-lamps for use therein. What consideration would you take into account in making your choice? What lamps would you select? In the case of a flame safety-lamp, describe its construction and state the precautions necessary in assembling each component part, so that, when complete, the lamp shall be safe for use in the mine. (30) Very well answered on the whole. (3) State the composition of ordinary atmospheric air (omitting argon and other rare gases) and that of the gases met with in mines, giving the properties and characteristics of each component. In dealing with these gases, state the precautions necessary to ensure safety. What limits are placed to the impurities allowable in the return air of a mine ? (30) A fair knowledge of the gases was shown, but a large number were unable to state correctly whether they were mixtures or chemical combinations. Many were not clear as to the impurities allowed in the return air. The precautions necessary in dealing with the gases were very well given. (4) It is proposed to drive a pair of long parallel cross-measure drifts in a fiery colliery. State what plant you would install for ventilating the drifts, bow you would arrange to drive the plant, giving sizes and arrangements and quantity of air. State the advantages and disadvantages of making air tubes carry (a) the intake air to, (b) the return air from, the face of the drifts. (30) The kind of plant necessary was fairly well stated, but there were many extreme answers as regards sixes. The latter part of the question was well discussed. (5) In what circumstances do you consider it advisable to construct an air-crossing of a temporary character, and in what circumstances should the structure be of a more permanent type? Sketch, and describe, the construction of a permanent air-crossing and give an account of the operations necessary, in proper sequence, in bringing it into use for the first time. (30) The first part of the question was well answered. The sketches were good, except that, where concrete was used, the floor dividing the two currents was often unreasonably thick. The descriptions of the sequence of the operations of bringing the crossing into use, were disappointing. (6) Compare the area and the perimeter of two main roadways — one lined throughout with timber settings 7 ft. high, 7 ft. wide at the top, and 10 ft. wide at the floor — all in the clear; the other lined with standard steel girders of the splayed type, 8 ft. high, 8 ft. wide at springings, 9 ft. 2 in. wide at floor. With a velocity of 600 ft. per min., calculate the quantity of air passing per minute in each road. Discuss the question of the power required to overcome the resistance of each of these roadways, giving your opinion as to the proportionate resistance in each case, assuming an equal length of, say, 800 yards; and state the grounds on which you base your opinion, (30) These answers were very unsatisfactory. A proportion failed in calculating the perimeter of the timbered road. The roadway lined with steel arches was seldom correctly calculated. A few did not recognise perimeter, and gave figures of rubbing surface instead. It was generally (and correctly) stated that K in the second roadway should be less than in the first one. (7) How would you proceed to calculate the weight of 1 cubic foot of atmospheric air under ordinary conditions? State exactly what conditions you assume for this purpose. Calculate the effect of the increase of temperature observed in passing from the downcast at 50 deg. Fah. to the upcast at 74 deg: Fah. respectively. Calculate also that produced by a change of barometric pressure of 1-in, increase from that assumed by you for the first part of your answer. What is the effect of the presence of a high percentage of moisture in the air? (30) Most candidates used a correct method of making these calculations, but a good many of these were in error in assuming a wrong temperature for the standard weight used as a starting point, and this vitiated the results. The effect of the presence of moisture on the state of the air itself was not well answered, but the physiological effect on the men was well understood. Explosions, Etc. (1st Class). (1) Define the conditions under which firedamp and coal dust are explosive. State what has been done by scientific research to make working operations safer with regard to (a) illumination and (b) electrical apparatus. (30) The first part of the question was well answered by most of the candidates, but the answers to the second part were variable, and indicated that the published reports had not been very carefully studied. (2) A dam to withstand a water pressure of 250 lb. per sq. in. is to be constructed in a level roadway, 9 ft. wide by 6 ft. high, driven through strong strata between two inclined seams of coal. Make a sketch, with dimensions, showing the construction of a reinforced-concrete dam suitable for the purpose. (25) The question asks for a sketch with dimensions; the sketches were very crude in many cases, and the dimensions of the dam were sometimes omitted. With this form of dam, cementation is essential, but many candidates neither indicated nor referred to it. (3) Describe conditions under which an occurrence known as a "water-blast" might be expected. (25) The phenomenon was often confused with inundations, and with water-hammer in steam pipes and engine cylinders. (4) Apparatus is to be installed at a colliery to prepare inert dust for the underground roadways. Describe briefly the principal features of suitable machinery. State the kind of material you would select for the dust, and if the output; of coal is 2,000 tons per day from a dry and dusty seam 6 ft. thick, state the approximate quantity of inert dust required to maintain the roadways in a safe condition. (25) Principal features of suitable machinery well explained, and selection of suitable material was right, but the estimated quantities required varied from 1 ton to 50 tons per day, mere guesswork. (5) Make a sectional sketch, with dimensions, of a seam of coal in which spontaneous heating might occur. Sketch and describe a method of working the seam to reduce the danger of spontaneous heating, and in the event of heating taking place, explain how you would deal with it. (25) The question asks for a sectional sketch; this was often omitted. Some of the suggested layouts of panel workings were very incomplete and impracticable; this has been previously commented upon. The suggestions for dealing with a case of heating indicated lack of knowledge and experience in many of the answers. (6) How is carbon monoxide usually formed in coal mines? What are the characteristics of this gas? How is it usually detected, and what precautions should be taken when its presence is suspected? (25) The characteristics of the gas, and the usual methods of detection are well known, and candidates generally gave very good answers. Some confused gas-masks with self-contained breathing apparatus, and overlooked the danger of using gas-masks where there is an insufficiency of oxygen. Machinery (1st Class). (1) In the case of electric motors for three-phase current, distinguish briefly between the following types: (a) Squirrel-cage or short-circuited rotor; (b) slip-ring or wound rotor; (c) synchronous with salient poles; (d) synchronous induction. Which types would you use for: (a) A 100-h.p. direct haulage; (b) a 10-h.p. centrifugal pump; (c) a large continuous-running fan; (d) a large air compressor. (28) Most candidates are familiar with motors with short-circuited and wound rotors, but a common mistake is to say that current is introduced to a wound rotor through the slip rings, The types of synchronous motors are not welt known. (2) A single-drum direct haulage gear is driven by a 120-b.h.p. motor taking three-phase, 50-cycle, 3,000-volt current, the full-load power factor being 0.8 The haulage is situated 1,000 yards from the switchboard at the pit bottom, where the voltage is 3,300. Detail the plant that you would install between the pit bottom switchboard and the motor. It must be possible to run the motor at a creeping speed and at full-load torque for, say, 15 min. Take the resistance of 1,000 yds. of copper wire 0.1 sq. in. section as 0.258 ohm. (28) The size of conductors for the cable was sometimes calculated correctly, but there were numerous mistakes in arithmetic, and some candidates treated the problem as one of direct current, The motor of the haulage was to be able to run at a creeping speed for 15 minutes. The implications of this requirement were seldom realised. (3) Describe a three-phase transformer stepping down from high tension to medium tension at the rate of, say, 200 k.v.a. What tests would you apply to such a transformer to discover if it is in correct working order? (28) There was a good proportion of satisfactory descriptions of a transformer. The tests to be applied to a transformer were not well known. (4) Set out the information that should be given to a manufacturer to enable him to offer a centrifugal, or turbine, pump coupled direct to an electric motor for placing at the bottom of a shaft to raise water up the shaft. Deal with both the pump and the motor, but not with switchgear. (28) Most candidates referred to the rate of pumping, the hours, the static head, and the size of pipes, also the electric current conditions. It was frequently stated that the power factor would be specified, as if this were a function of the supply at choice, like frequency. (5) Discuss the use of electric welding in connection with machinery used in and about mines, giving instances of parts now commonly made of mild steel welded, that formerly were riveted or were castings. (28) This question was often chosen and was dealt with better on the side of repairing colliery plant than on the side of the manufacture of new plant for collieries, although a number of candidates were able to mention items of new plant in which welding has a part. (6) Describe an apparatus for attachment to a winding engine for preventing overwinds. State also how it works, how it controls the speed of the cages, and how it brings the engine to rest when the up-coming cage would go too far. (28) Generally the descriptions of an overwind preventer were not clear. The fine points of these devices are not well known. (7) A horizontal steam pipe 6½ in. outside diameter is to be supported from a vertical joist 8 in. by 5 in: Design and draw a sling support for the pipe from the joist, showing enough dimensions and particulars to enable the support to be made. (38) Answers showed a great variety of design of pipe support, few of which, however, came under the description of a sling. The designs were mostly unpractical, and the dimensions were insufficient. (8) Give a list of typical wire-rope constructions and describe them briefly. Indicate the particular purposes for which each construction is most suitable. (28). The descriptions of locked coil ropes were poor. A common mistake was to confuse the difference between a stranded rope of ordinary, and one of Langs lay. The answers gave evidence of superficial knowledge of rope constructions. [To be Continued.]
|
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||