|
14th December 1933 Big Fall In Florence MineTwo Killed; One InjuredPopular Footballer Trapped By LegsSaved From Suffocation By Workmate's Action A roof fall of 40 tons of ore fatally crushed two men and injured a third in Florence iron ore mine, Egremont, on Tuesday. The rescued man, John Earl, a former footballer, had a marvellous escape from death. Struck and flung to one side by falling timber, he was buried with the exception of his face. Unable to move, he would have suffocated had not a workmate found him and provided breathing space until he was liberated an hour later. At the inquest yesterday afternoon, Earl, along with other witnesses could advance no theory regarding the cause of the accident. According to them the working appeared perfectly safe, and all said they would be prepared to work under similar conditions again. The men who lost their lives in the accident, the worst since the mine was opened in 1920, were :— John Wilkinson (47), Bigrigg, married with family of five. Robert Marr (35), Vale View, Egremont, married with a family of two. The rescued man, John Earl (30) of North Road, Egremont, is married and has a family of three. He escaped with lacerated hands and bruised legs. The three men had just entered the working about 2.30 p.m. when the fall occurred. Earl, who was struck and hurled to one side and almost completely buried never saw or heard the other two. He found himself trapped by timber across his legs and then to his horror he found the opening through which he was breathing being filled up by small pieces of ore which were trickling from the top of the fall. At the opportune moment a workman William Kelly, of Frizington, who had heard the fall, appeared, and created a breathing space for Earl. Rescue parties were then formed under Major A. Hibbert, the general manager, and Mr. C. Weatherall, the manager, but Earl was not released until 90 minutes had elapsed, and even then the timber pinning him down had to be sawn through. Continuing their work, the rescue parties, among whom was Mr. R. Butler, H.M. Inspector of Mines, came across the two bodies about 11.15 p.m., but it was not until the early hours of Wednesday morning that they were got clear of the fall. County Soccer Back In an interview on Tuesday night, Earl, who played full-back for Cumberland at soccer a few seasons ago, graphically described how the timber which fell across him probably saved his life. He paid a tribute to Kelly's promptitude in saving him from smothering, and added that the voices of the rescue party were very cheering. For Earl this was the completion of an amazing cycle of coincidence. He had been involved in two previous accidents in Egremont mines in which he had been hurt. Both occurred on Tuesday's date, December 12, in 1925 and 1928. The family of the dead men are both well known in the district. Wilkinson was a workman governor of Whitehaven Hospital. Within the past 12 months two other members of the Wilkinson family have died. The sympathy of the whole district has been extended to them. The Inquest The inquest was conducted by Mr. G. A. L. Skerry at Egremont Police Station yesterday. There were present Mr. W. B. Brown and Mr. R. Butler, H.M. Inspectors of Mines: Mr. T. A. Morgan, of Ulverston, representing the Millom and Askam Hematite Iron Company; Major A. Hibbert, D.S.O, M.C, general manager, and Mr. C. Edmonds, representing the relatives. Mr. J. R. Gilbertson was elected foreman of the jury. Alfred Marr, iron ore miner, Cringlethwaite, Egremont identified the body of his brother Robert Marr, who had worked at Florence mine for three or four years; and William Wilkinson, Moor Row, miners labourer, said James Wilkinson, his father, had worked at Florence for nearly ten years. Andrew Nesbitt, Egremont, a surveyor, submitted a plan of the site of the accident. The survivor, John Earl, said Wilkinson, Marr, and he formed No. 25 Company and were working in No. 6 West District. They entered their working place and on examining the place found it apparently all "nice and snug," with the roof completely timbered. Two sets of timber had been put in - one on Saturday and one on Monday. It was good timber. Above the timber there was loose ore and at one point a cavity of about seven feet between the ore and the roof. They were not going to work under this cavity. Collapsed all at Once While witness and Wilkinson were examining the place "it seemed to collapse all at once." Witness knew no more until he came to in the dark and felt himself covered with falling debris. He shouted and William Kelly came in from an adjoining working and uncovered his head. He was pinned down by timber but got out eventually. He did not see what happened to his mates. There had been some shot firing that morning. The Coroner: Have you any idea what happened? - No, my only thought was to get out. Do you consider the timber in the place safe? - In my estimation it was. How do you account for your escape? - Just a bit of luck. That's all I can think. I was knocked aside by the timber. They were knocked one way and I was knocked the other. By Mr. Edmonds: The overman examined the places every shift, and if anything was wrong they were notified. William Kelly, miner, Winder Gate, Frizington, said he was working on the opposite side of the pillar about 40 yards from No. 25 company. He had only been in his place a few minutes when he heard a fall and knew where it was. On going into Earl's place he found a big fall. He also heard a voice but could not tell exactly where it came from. He got some other men to bring timber and after hunting about for sometime he found Earl buried up to the head in debris. With the assistance of a man named Ashbridge he cleared Earl's head and eventually got him out. He saw nothing of the other two men. Mr. Butler: Do you think any movement could have taken place between the two shifts? - It might be possible. Do you think any other methods could be employed to prevent such an accident? - No. By Mr. Edmonds: He thought the middling had collapsed. Would Work There Again Joseph W. Adams, Trumpet Terrace, Cleator, who was working in the same place as Wilkinson and Marr on the morning shift, said they worked throughout the shift without any trouble and left the place safe. He saw Wilkinson on the pit top and told him things in the working place were "pretty good." There was about four feet of middling above the timber, and it seemed quite safe. The accident, in his opinion, was quite unusual. He considered it was unavoidable, and no one was to blame. He was quite prepared to work there again under similar conditions. By Mr. Butler: There was no cavity above the place where they were working: It would be about 20 yards away. Benjamin Beattie, Dent Road, Thornhill, said he examined the places in No. 6 West District. He visited No. 25 Company at 12.40 p.m. on Tuesday. He examined the place and found it satisfactory, both as regards timbering and working. He was very surprised that an accident had happened. From what he had seen since the middling had apparently collapsed. This was very unusual, and he could not explain why the timber had not supported the middling: the place was well timbered. By Mr. Butler: The piece that came down was a big one and might easily weigh 40 tons. Addressing the jury, the Coroner said if they could make any suggestion, or they thought anybody was to blame they could mention it. They must realise that mining was a dangerous occupation when a thing like that happened and nobody seemed to know how to take precautions against it happening again. There, were a lot of occurrences in mining which could not be foreseen. Undoubtedly some of the metal which was above the timbering had given way and had pushed the timber away and come down. A verdict of "Accidentally killed by a fall of roof" was returned.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||