|
7th September 1933 Youth Killed In PitCaught By A Full Set Of TubsVerbal Duels Between Inspector And Mr. CapeCoroner And Regulations There were several verbal duels between Mr. W. B. Brown, H.M Inspector of Mines, and Mr. T. Cape, M.P, at the adjourned inquest held at Whitehaven, on Friday, on William Lowe Bruce (18), haulage hand, who was killed at Haig Pit, Whitehaven, on 24th August last, when he was caught by a full set of tubs. Mr. R. W. Marley (deputy coroner for West Cumberland) conducted the inquiry; Mr. J. McGuffie was appointed foreman of the jury; and there were also present Mr. J. Martin (Whitehaven miners' agent); Mr. T. Banks (agent, for Priestman's Whitehaven Collieries), and Mr. W. Morgan (manager of Haig Pit). Mr. R. Garside, colliery surveyor, produced and explained a plan of the place where the accident occurred. Edward Woodburn, Central Road, Arrowthwaite, shifthand at Haig Pit, said he was at work, on the back shift on Thursday and left work about 8.30. He saw Bruce shortly before he left. Bruce left work just before witness, but returned for his cap. When he was passing No.1 junction someone who was with a full set asked him if he was going out. He thought it was Bruce, who was with the set. A few seconds later he heard men shouting and someone was ordered to go for a stretcher. Mr. Cape: You don't know whether Bruce was on the set or not? — No; I just knew him by his voice. Men On The Set James Parks, 21, Central Road, shifthand at Haig Pit, stated that he left his work about eight o'clock. He caught up with Bruce on the night of the accident on the middle of the brow. When he went on the road he noticed a riding set which was provided for conveying men to the pit bottom, but he did not wait for it. He knew it was wrong to go on the haulage road, while the rope was in motion. He did not wait for a ride because he was in a hurry. As he was walking outbye he caught up with a full set. He noticed one person — Bruce — sitting on the set. The Inspector: Did you get on the set? — Yes. Mr. Cape objected to Mr. Brown putting leading questions to the witness, and pointed out that there might be a Court case arising out of the accident, and witness might be put in a false position. That was a Court simply to inquire into the cause of death. The Coroner ruled the question out. Replying further to the Inspector as to whether he saw anyone else sitting beside Bruce, witness said "No." The Inspector said this was contradictory to a statement made previously, and which was to the effect that Moffat was sitting on the first tub. Pressed by the Coroner, witness said it was Moffat who was sitting beside Bruce. Heard A Shout In reply to the Inspector, witness said he did not see anyone throw Bruce's cap off. Bruce was sitting on a bogey at the front end of the set. He afterwards heard a shout that there was someone under the set. The Inspector was further questioning the witness regarding his previous statement, when Mr. Cape again protested, and said the Inspector was using what he had learned during his inquiries as evidence against the witness. The Inspector said it was only in the form of a question. Witness had the right to agree or disagree. The Coroner said they must have material facts so far as related to deceased. He thought that was sufficient for the inquiry. Replying to Mr. Banks, witness said deceased got off the bogey to pick his cap up, and then made to get on the bogey again. By Mr. Cape: He knew it was wrong to walk out when the haulage rope was running. He had been told so. He had never asked if they were allowed to walk out when there was no riding set. By the Coroner: He had not seen notices about riding out. "Put His Foot On The Rope" John Moffatt, coal hewer at Haig Pit, said he left work about ten minutes to eight. He walked out-bye and did not notice a riding set at the brake bottom. He caught up with a full set at Saltom. He did not see Bruce. Witness walked alongside the set for some distance and then walked up to the fore end of the set. At this time Bruce passed him and got on the bogey at the fore-end. This was the first time he saw Bruce. The accident then happened. Bruce tried to get on the fore-end of the bogey. He had his back towards the pit-bottom. He put his feet on the rope and had his hands on the bogey. He then fell beneath the bogey and witness stopped the rope. Witness afterwards went for help. Asked if there was anybody else sitting on the bogey, witness said "Yes," but he did not recognise anybody. He saw no larking. Bruce's lamp was on his belt and it was burning all right. He had seen a notice that they must not travel the road while the rope was in motion. By the Coroner: It was not a big notice. He had never bothered to read it. By Mr. Cape: He had not seen a notice where the riding set started. By Mr. Banks: He had not noticed whether there was a notice at the far end of the road. In reply to the Foreman, witness again said he had not read the notice. The Foreman: If these notices were taken more notice of perhaps there would be less loss of life. I look upon this as a serious matter. It is no use putting notices up if they are not going to be read. William Crears, North Road, Kells, shifthand at Haig Pit, said he left work rather earlier than usual and walked past the brake bottom. There was no riding set there but there was a set of full tubs. Witness said he got on the first tub and rode outbye for some distance. He got off the set near the brow top, but did not see Bruce or how he met with his accident. He did not know that there were two or three persons scrambling for a seat on the first bogey. By Mr. Banks: He knew that they should not travel on that engine plane or ride on bogies. He had not noticed any notice. In reply to Mr. Cape: The riding set was expected to start at 8.30. Asked if it was the reason so many were walking out, because the riding set was not there, witness said it was very likely. Stopped The Set Robert Birkett, hewer at Haig Pit, said he left work about 8.20, and when he got to the junction he saw a full set and he walked alongside it. He heard a boy shout "There's something wrong with the set." Witness slapped the wires and got the set stopped. He went to the junction for a spanner and the tubs were afterwards uncoupled. George Elliott, Ducal Crown Inn, Queen Street, a hewer at Haig Pit, said he walked right out to the pit bottom, and on the way he heard somebody shouting that there was someone under the set. He went to the fore end of the set and found the body of Bruce under the first tub. He was lying with one foot out and the other under the set, with his head lying inbye. He was dead when he got him out. Witness was not near enough to see what happened. By Mr. Banks: He did not see a riding set out. This was about the first time he had walked out. There were notices about walking outbye. By the Coroner: There was no difficulty about seeing these notices. In reply to Mr. Cape: After the full set went away there was no sign of the riding set. If riding sets did not come in they were told by the overman to walk out. The men generally rode out. When they were told to walk out the rope was still running. Joseph Casson, Arrowthwaite, a hewer, said he walked outbye and caught up with the full set near the top of the brow. The set stopped and he heard somebody crossing the wires. When he got to the fore-end of the set there was a lot of men standing. He then learned that there was someone under the set. He helped to get Bruce out. Regulations Designed For Men's Safety The Coroner, addressing the jury said he considered it was his duty to point out that there seemed to have been a breach of regulations so far as the deceased was concerned. He thought that it would be realised by the men that these regulations were designed for their safety and he thought they should take notice of these regulations to the best of their ability. The Foreman endorsed the Coroner's remarks with regard to the regulations and then announced that the verdict of the jury was that Bruce met his death by misadventure. Both the Coroner and the Foreman expressed sympathy with the relatives. Mr. Cape on behalf of the Whitehaven miners and himself, also expressed sympathy with the parents. To a large extent he agreed with the Coroner and the Foreman with regard to rules and regulations. The men's leaders had no desire to encourage breaches of rules or regulations, but, on the contrary, they desired that the men should observe them wherever possible. However, if certain things were not done by the management he thought the men were justified in making a protest to the management respecting any neglect that might take place. Mr. Banks said it was sad that this accident should happen so early in the career of the new Company at Whitehaven. Many accidents occurred in mines which could not be helped, but this was a case where they did feel strongly that people should abide by the regulations and try to prevent accidents as far as possible. His company deeply regretted this unfortunate fatality and extended their sympathy to the relatives.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||