|
7th September 1933 Gassed In PitBrayton Colliery FatalitySearch For Hammer Ends In TragedyHow a search for a hammer ended in tragedy was revealed at an inquest at Aspatria Police Station on Monday afternoon concerning the death of J. Craighill, aged 55, of The Station, Aspatria, a shifthand employed at the Brayton Domain Colliery, No.5, who was found dead in a gas affected working in the pit on Friday afternoon last. Deputy Coroner R. W. Marley, sitting with a jury, conducted the inquest which lasted over two hours. Mr. William Jefferson was elected foreman of the jury, and there were present Mr. W. B. Brown, H.M Inspector of Mines; Mr. H. Skerry, representing the Cumberland Colliery Officials' Association; Mr. J. Douglas, for the Cumberland Miners' Association; Mr. G. Mills, undermanager at the pit; and Mr. T. Tunstall, representing the owners. After evidence of identification had been given by the widow, who said her husband had been in good health, a plan of the district where deceased was working was produced by the surveyor, Mr. W. S. Foster. This revealed that Craighill had been working in the section of the mine known as Foster's Drift and that his dead body was discovered on a gas affected brow known as Tadd's Brow. Dr. W. F. Coulthard, Aspatria, said he was called to the pit on Friday and was told that Craighill had been found dead and that there was a possibility of him having been gassed. He had known deceased all his life and always found him to be a strong healthy man. On examining the body at the pit top he was unable to express his opinion at that time as to the cause of death, and upon the instructions of the Coroner a post mortem was held on Sunday. As a result of this, witness found that there was nothing to suggest death from natural causes, and the symptoms in the organs led him to the conclusion that death was due to asphyxiation caused by the inhalation of narcotic gas. A "Blower" Of Gas John Hewitson, Lion House, West Street, Aspatria, colliery deputy, said he made an inspection of No. 3 District last Friday prior to the afternoon shift starting and found the condition of the district improving. The district had been in an abnormal condition when a fall of roof released a "blower" of gas a week previous to the fatality. It was the usual custom to allow the "blower" to clear and this was taking place on the day of the accident. The ventilations were coping with the gas, and the accumulation was being reduced. He saw Craighill and his mate going to their work, but he did not give them any special instructions, but saw the outcoming deputy for the district. The men knew they were engaged in checking the fire-damp. All the approaches to the affected areas were fenced off and notices were marked "No Road." He was quite sure there was a fence in position at Tadd's Brow. By Mr. Skerry: He found the presence of gas to his satisfaction on that day. Joseph William Hewitson, Arkleby Road, Aspatria, an overman at the pit, said he visited No. 3 district last Friday and found a good deal of gas coming off. He made his inspection from 10am until about 1pm, and observed that the ventilation was overcoming the gas and that the district was improving. There was fencing at Tadd's Brow. By Mr. Skerry: He was quite sure that all the danger areas were fenced off. Richard Young, Westnewton, deputy, said he had charge of No. 3 District on the afternoon shift. He reached the district where deceased and his mate were to be engaged in erecting a board stopping to check the fire-damp five minutes before them. He gave the men instructions and they fully realised that they were working in connection with the fire-damp. It was quite safe where they were working, and he told them they had to remain where they were until they were seen by the afternoon overman, William Hind. There was nothing said in his presence about a hammer being required, and he thought there were sufficient tools to carry on with the work until they were seen by the overman. By Mr. Skerry: He was certain he told the men they had to remain where they were until the overman came. He was also satisfied that there were sufficient tools to work with. In answer to Mr. Brown, witness said he was satisfied that there were sufficient tools to proceed with the erection of the barrier. Deceased did not ask him about a hammer. Rushed To The Rescue William Hind, Blennerhasset, the afternoon overman, said he sent Craighill and Chapplow to their work on Friday. He visited the men at 3.40pm, and found Chapplow carrying out his instructions, but deceased was missing. In answer to witness Chapplow said Craighill had left with Deputy Young for a hammer. He had not left more than ten minutes when he heard Chapplow shouting there had been an accident. He could see Craighill's electric lamp burning, up Tadd's Brow, and he rushed up to rescue him. He was so excited that he did not notice whether there was a fencing at the brow, nor did he notice one lying by the side. Witness was carrying an oil lamp, and he placed it in a place of safety about fifteen yards from where Craighill was lying. He dragged Craighill to safety, and artificial respiration was tried without avail. It was impossible for the men to test the fire-damp with an electric lamp. Mr. Brown: I think it would be a wise precaution in the future to issue oil flame safety lamps to men engaged in this particular work so that they could detect the presence of gas. By Mr. Skerry: It would be possible for a man to get underneath or over a fence, and it was not necessary to take one down if a man wanted to pass. He was certain there was a fence at Tadd's Brow on the day before the accident. He was prepared to say that Craighill was in the wrong if he passed the fence. Questioned by Mr. Mills, the overman said he later found the fence lying on the right hand side of the brow, and he attached it again. John William Chapplow said deceased and he were sent by Overman Hind to the No. 3 District for the purpose of erecting a barrier. They took no tools with them with the exception of a saw which witness carried. They required a hammer and shovels, but they did not mention anything to Deputy Young about shortage of tools. After an hour's cleaning they decided they required a hammer, and Craighill said, "I think I will go and see if I can find a hammer." He thought deceased knew the district, and witness did not know that he would be likely to go to Tadd's Brow. He was sure nothing was said about going to find one at Tadd's Brow. He heard a man nearby, and he came to the conclusion that it was the deputy and that Craighill had accompanied him for a hammer. Twenty minutes elapsed, and, when Craighill did not return witness went in search for him. He passed several danger places, but could not be sure that they were all fenced off. He did not think Tadd's Brow was railed off. Vital Fence Missing Mr. Brown: Does it not strike you as singular that the vital fence should be missing? — I did not see a fence lying by the side nor did I get under or over one. I saw a lamp burning and went up and was within about three yards of deceased when I was driven back by the gas. It was possible that the fence might have been thrown off, but he did not see one. By Mr. Skerry: He did not think Craighill would have gone up the brow had there been a fence there. Witness should have seen the fence if it was lying by the side of the brow. The Coroner: Is it very difficult to find a hammer on a pit? — Sometimes. They have a bad system down No. 5, and the sooner it is altered the better. You are working at one end of the pit one day and the other end the next. When you are working like this it is not customary to carry tools but you rely on Providence to find tools when you get there. The Coroner, addressing the jury, said the Doctor's evidence as to the cause of death could be accepted. The other point they had to consider was whether death was accidental or not. He thought he could say without hesitation that there was not evidence of negligence. They had heard the witness and they could see there was a good deal of conflict as to whether there was fence at Tadd's Brow or not. The Jury returned a verdict of "Death from misadventure caused by "asphyxiation due to the inhalation of gas." They added a rider that "oil safety lamps" should be issued in the future to men engaged in this kind of work to enable them to detect the presence of gas." Sympathy to the deceased's widow and family was extended by Coroner and representatives present. Mr. T. Tunstall said Craighill was a good and faithful servant at the colliery and it is a matter of deep regret that his end be so tragic.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||