|
27th July 1933 Ore Mine FallEgremont Man KilledMate Escapes In TimeAn accident at the Beckermet Mining Company's Winscales No.1 mine on Tuesday evening resulted in the death of Hugh Doran, aged 59, of 7, Nelson Square, Egremont. Mr. Doran was well known and popular in the Egremont district, and a member of a well-known football family. He was a strong supporter of the Egremont Rangers R L Club and had officiated as a referee. He was working on the afternoon shift with Arthur McDonald (Bigrigg) and Charles Milburn (Scalegill), who had a narrow escape. It is a strange feature of the accident that had deceased been in the working a few minutes earlier he may have had some warning of the fall and managed to escape. Such falls are usually preceded by a trickle of small stone, but on this occasion deceased and his mates had been out of the working having their "bait." The fall occurred as Doran was entering the working, and he was killed instantly. McDonald was just a few yards behind Doran, and managed to jump clear, his lamp being extinguished. The fall had been heard by Milburn, who had gone into another working a few yards away and he rushed to Doran's working to find Doran lying behind a bogey, dead. Doran leaves a widow, but no family. Sitting with a jury, Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, held an inquest at Egremont Police Station on Wednesday. Mr. P. Clucas was elected foreman of the jury, and others present were: Messrs. W. Sherwen, general manager of the Beckermet Mines; C. Booth, Beckermet Mining Company; C. Edmonds, representing the widow; W. C. Sumner, solicitor, attending on behalf of the employers; and R. Butler, H.M Inspector. Edward Doran, iron ore miner, 20, Drummond Street, Egremont, gave evidence of identification. Witness last saw deceased alive on the pit top on Monday. Deceased had worked at Winscales for some years. Total Weight Of Stones 30 Tons William Sherwen, general manager of the Beckermet Mines, produced plans of the working where Doran was killed, and explained them to the jury. In reply to Mr. Butler, witness said Doran had been killed by a fall of debris. The total weight of the stones, which had fallen, would be about thirty tons. Four large stones were lying near where the accident occurred, one of them, which was lying on a bogey in the working, having apparently broken of a still larger (one), which was lying near. By the Coroner: There was a large heap of debris in the working. Had there been signs of the heap being in any way dangerous, it would have been taken down. Had props been considered necessary for the safety of the working they were available. There had been no blasting on that shift. Arthur McDonald, iron ore miner, 33, Springfield Road, Bigrigg, who was with Doran at the time of the fatality, said they started work at 2pm. He went into the working with Doran, and on inspection found nothing wrong. There had been a fall of roof three weeks previously and it was the debris from this fall they were shifting. The heap appeared perfectly safe, and there was no sign of any further fall. After "bait time" he went back to the working with deceased. Doran went into the working first and witness was a few yards behind. There was a rush of stone as Doran entered, and they were left in darkness, witness's lamp being extinguished as he jumped back. Witness shouted for a mate who was working near by, and a light was procured. They shouted for Doran, but got no reply. They found Doran lying dead, and witness was of the opinion that death was instantaneous. Witness could not say which stone had struck deceased, but there were injuries on the arms and legs. No Warning. There had been no firing in the working on that shift, though there had been blasting on the previous shift. The working had been inspected about 3pm by Sam Ashburner, the deputy; but there was nothing to show that a fall was at all probable. They had no warning of a fall. Timber had not been used in the working, though it was available if they considered it necessary. Witness could not suggest any method by means of which such an accident could have been avoided. In reply to the Coroner, witness said he would work under similar conditions. By Mr. Butler: There were six in the company. A shot had been fired in Milburn's working, but all was clear after "bait time." They had no warning of a fall, though it was possible that there was a preliminary trickle, which usually precedes a fall , whilst they were out of the working. By Mr. Edmonds: The accident happened as they were going into the working. Charles Milburn, iron ore miner, 49, Scalegill Place, Moor Row, said he was working two pillar lengths away from Doran at the time of the accident. He went into his own working after "bait" and heard a rush in Doran's working. He went to the working and shouted for Doran, but got no reply. He found Doran lying behind a bogey — dead. There was a big lump of stone lying on the bogey and there were lumps on Doran's back, leg, and shoulder. Samuel Ashburner, mine deputy, 5, The Crescent, Thornhill, said he inspected the working between three and four o'clock and considered the working perfectly safe. He was surprised to hear there had been a rush from the debris heap. He could not suggest anything to deal with such a position. Had he thought there was any danger he would have brought the man out of the working. It was an unpreventable accident. It was usual for such falls to be preceded by a trickle, and had the men not been out for "bait," it was possible they might have had some warning. By Mr. Butler: Had the men had any warning of the fall they could have got clear of the working in half a dozen yards. An Unavoidable Accident The jury agreed that death was due to a fall of stone from the debris heap, and that it was purely an unavoidable accident. The Coroner returned a verdict that Doran was accidentally killed by a fall of debris in the working place. Mr. W. C. Sumner expressed the Beckermet Mining Company's regret that Doran, a valuable servant, had been killed whilst following his employment. Mr. Sherwen said he and Mr. Booth had known deceased during his 24 years in the employ of the Company. He was a fine workman, and they had often welcomed his opinion on all matters pertaining to mining. They asked Mr. Edmonds to convey their deep regret to the widow. Testimony to the qualities of deceased were also paid by Mr. Edmonds, who said he had known Mr. Doran for many years and who was a personal friend.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||