Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

27th May 1933, Page: 362, Column: 1

Cardowan Colliery Explosion

General Description.

in his report on the causes and circumstances attending the explosion which occurred at Cardowan Colliery, Stepps, Lanarkshire, which occurred in the West District of the Main Coal Seam on 16th November, 1932, eleven persons losing their lives and three others being injured, Sir Henry Walker, C.B.E., LL.D., Chief Inspector of Mines, says that all parties were agreed that the cause of the explosion was the firing of a shot.

Opening with a general description, the Inspector says :—

"At the colliery there are two shafts-No. 1 the downcast and No. 2 the upcast. Each shaft is sunk to the Kilsyth Coking Coal Seam, which is cut at a depth of 342 fathoms. The Main Coal Seam occurs at 237½ fathoms and the Wee Coal Seam at 242 fathoms. The output from the Kilsyth Coking Coal Seam is wound at the No. 2 Shaft and that from the Main Coal Seam at the No. 1 Shaft. The Wee Coal Seam was worked for a time but, proving too thin, its working was discontinued. In the Main Coal Seam, which varies in thickness from 24 to 36 inches, there are three districts known as the East, the South Heading and the West. The coal is worked longwall; coal-cutting machines, conveyors and gate-end loaders driven by compressed air being employed in each district. The seam is a very gassy one and dry but not dusty; the coal is fairly hard and very brittle. The main intake and return airways are supported by steel arches.

"Ventilation is produced by a double inlet Sirocco fan; the total quantity of air being passed through the mine at the time of the explosion was about 220,000 cubic feet per minute with a water-gauge of 4¾ inches. Of this quantity, some 100,000 cubic feet was circulated in the Main Coal Seam. Limestone dust was used for dusting the roof, floor and sides of the roads, about half a pound of such dust being distributed for each ton of coal produced. The firemen and the shot-firers were each provided with two flame safety-lamps and, in addition, an electric cap lamp. Electric cap lamps were used by the greater proportion of the workmen; some used electric hand lamps and a small proportion had flame safety-lamps in addition to electric lamps. Mr. John Macdonald Williamson was the agent and manager, and Mr. James Peacock the under-manager. Mr. George Ernest Sleight was the surveyor and he was also responsible for collecting representative samples of the dust on the floor, roof and sides of the roads for analysis and for making periodical tests for firedamp in the return airways by means of a McLuckie apparatus.

"The West District, at the time of the explosion, consisted of a longwall face, some 760 feet in length, dipping at the rate of 1 in 6 to the North East. This face was divided by the main intake airway and haulage road into two parts, that to the rise being 480 feet long and that to the dip 280 feet. The seam in this face was three feet thick with a blaes roof and fireclay floor.

"The ventilating current for the West District, measured on 2nd November, in the main intake 100 yards back from the face, was 22,800 cubic feet per minute. This current was split right and left, that is to the dip and to the rise, at the face. The dip side split had two returns-the 7 x 7 road, about half-way down the face, and the 'downset' road at the extreme end. A check screen was hung in the 7 x 7 road about 200 feet from the face to prevent too great a proportion of the split from travelling that way.

"Two chain coal-cutting machines driven by compressed air were used to undercut the coal to an average depth of four feet. Two shaker conveyors, arranged in tandem, delivered the coal got on the face to the rise of the main road on to a tub loader placed in that road. The coal got from the face to the dip was delivered on to the same loader by a belt conveyor.

"Work was carried on at the face throughout each 24 hours, The whole of the work in the face, with the exception of the shot-firing, was done under contract. Supervision was exercised by a fireman on each shift. The firemen on the afternoon and night shifts fired the shots in the brushings, and during the day shift the fireman on that shift and two shot-firers fired the shots in the coal. The shot-holes in the coal were bored 3½ to 4 feet deep, four to five feet apart in the top six to nine inches of the seam which was hard coal. The charge of explosive in each hole in the coal was limited to a single cartridge, weighing one and a half ounces, stemmed with eight to ten inches of tough clay.

It was stated in evidence that the hard coal — the top six to nine inches of the seam-stuck to the roof and that every day on some part of the face the remainder of the seam, in lengths up to 40 feet, broke away from the top portion, more especially when the "gum" (the cuttings made by the machines when under-cutting) had been cleared out of the cut, leaving a gap of some two inches between the two parts of the seam."

The Explosion.

Regarding the explosion, short references extracted from the body of the report are as under :—

"The explosion occurred on the face to the dip of the main intake at about 8-45 a.m. At that time the conveyors and gate-end loader had been standing for several minutes owing to lack of empty tubs.

"All parties were agreed that the cause of the explosion was the firing of a shot in the coal opposite the first dummy road below the 7 x 7 road, but there was a conflict of opinion as to the means by which the explosion was extended.

"The four men who were found dead in the face were poisoned by carbon monoxide; that fact alone is strong evidence that coal dust was inflamed.

"I have no hesitation in reporting that the explosion was caused by the firing of a shot in coal which had been loosened and broken by a shot fired shortly before; that the firedamp thus ignited had been contained in the undercut and amongst the coal already brought down by the previous shot, and that flame was extended throughout the face and into the intake roadhead by coal dust."

Inquiry Pointers.

In the closing chapters of his report Sir Henry discusses points arising from the inquiry, and some abstracts may be admissible as follow :—

"The subject of shot-firing naturally occupied a good deal of time during the inquiry, especially in reference to (a) the examinations made for firedamp and (b) the application of stone dust, before a shot was fired in the coal; (c) the number of shots fired by the fireman and the two shot-firers during the day shift, and (d) the firing of two or more shots in the same place simultaneously.

"In Clause 6 of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order are set out the provisions to be observed in mines to which Part II of that Order applies. Cardowan Colliery is such a mine.

"(a) The requirements in regard to the examination to be made before a shot is fired are contained in paragraph (f) (i) of this Clause which reads :—

'No shot shall be fired unless, immediately before the shot is to be fired, the shot-firer has examined with a locked flame safety-lamp of approved type or with other apparatus approved for the purpose by the Board of Trade the place where the shot is to be fired and all contiguous accessible places within a radius of 20 yards from the place, and has found them clear of inflammable gas and in all respects safe for firing. This examination shall include an examination for any inflammable gas issuing from the shot-hole or from any break within the aforesaid radius. If within the aforesaid radius of the place there is any cavity which may contain inflammable gas and cannot be so examined, or any break where an examination cannot be made for inflammable gas issuing from it (other than inaccessible cavities or breaks in the gob, goaf or waste) the shot shall not be fired.'

"I do not think the requirements of this clause were fulfilled. I think such examination as was made was restricted to the near vicinity of each shot; it did not extend to all contiguous accessible places within a radius of 20 yards and was not made immediately before firing.

"Having regard to the last sentence of this clause, I am in grave doubt whether, in view of the condition which very frequently existed in the West District — namely, a gap left between the top six to nine inches and the remainder of the seam — the firing of a shot in the top portion was legal. I have no doubt that such condition added materially to the risk.

"(b) The requirements in regard to stonedusting before a shot is fired are contained in paragraph (f) (ii) of Clause 6 which reads :—

'No shot shall be fired until the place where the shot is to be fired and the floor, roof and sides of all contiguous accessible places within a radius of 5 yards from the place where the shot is to be fired have been thoroughly treated with incombustible dust or with water, or in such other manner as the Board of Trade may approve. If the place where the shot is to be fired is in or near the coal face and not more than 10 yards from a road which has been so treated under the General Regulations of 30th July, 1920, the treatment shall in addition he made continuous from the road to the shot-hole.'

"The shot-firer, Beaton, and the fireman, Horn, were very definite in their evidence that before firing shots they did stonedust where they thought such dust was required. Beaton said that part of the rise side face was damp and stone dust was not required there, and Horn said that if there appeared already to be sufficient stone dust at the place where he was going to fire a shot, he did not add more. Stone dust was spread by them by throwing it by hand into the air-current, which carried it along the face. As the firing of the shots proceeded, stone dust spread in this way would become covered with coal dust; to comply with the spirit of the clause, stone dust should have been applied separately for, each shot."

(c) Under (c) Sir Henry goes into the number of shots fired daily in the coal, and says: "Having regard to the conditions, I do not think it was possible for the shot-firers to fire as many shots per shift as the records show they were firing and at the same time to fulfil all the statutory requirements." There is some discussion regarding the average time taken to fire a shot, and on this question the Inspector concludes :—

"As conditions vary from mine to mine and from seam to seam in the same mine, it is not possible to lay down the time required by the shot-firer to carry out the various previsions of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order prior to firing a shot. The best that can be done is... to make an actual test . . . and then, I think, to add to the actual time taken a reasonable margin for contingencies.

Simultaneous Firing Discussed.

"(d) The firing of two or more shots in the same place simultaneously is forbidden by paragraph g (i) of Clause 6, which reads:—

'Two or more shots shall not be fired in the same place simultaneously, and the precautions prescribed by paragraph f (i) of this clause shall be taken immediately before the firing of each shot.'

"Paragraph f (i) of Clause 6 has already been quoted.

"A relaxation from these provisions is allowed in connection with the driving of stone drifts and in sinking pits, such relaxation being contained in paragraph g (iv) which reads :—

'The requirements of this paragraph shall not apply to stone drifts or in sinking pits : provided that the precautions prescribed by paragraph f (i) of this clause shall be taken immediately before the firing of each round of shots: provided also that in stone drifts the number of shots which may be fired simultaneously shall not exceed three unless fired electrically in series.'

"Asked if he had any particular reason for firing two shots together, Wilson (a fireman) replied that he thought it was the safest method of firing in brushing because when firing one shot it might take away too much of the material from the other hole and so, by leaving the second shot too little work to do, make it dangerous to fire that second shot. He also said he understood that brushing was in the same category as stone drifts.

"But a case such as that adumbrated by Wilson is provided for in paragraph g (ii) of Clause 6, which reads :—

'If two or more shot-holes have been placed in such a manner that the firing of one shot would be liable to relieve any part of the work to be done by another shot, each shot to be fired shall be fired before any other of the shot-holes is charged.'

"It may be, however, that, without any appearance of having done so, the firing of one shot has in fact relieved a second shot of part of its work and has opened breaks which cannot be seen but which may contain firedamp. In such circumstances, the second shot would be fired and might ignite the firedamp contained in the unseen breaks caused by the first shot.

"To avoid this risk it has for some time been contended that in would be better to fire all the shots in one place simultaneously rather than one at a time. Further, it is claimed that when one shot has been fired, the examination required to be made before a second shot is fired, is made under most unfavourable conditions, inasmuch as (a) the strata having been shaken by the first shot there is, in consequence, an increased danger from falls, and (b) the atmosphere in which tests for firedamp are made is not clear of fumes. Whereas, when shots are fired together, the examination made before firing them is made in a clear atmosphere and under safer roof conditions. Also, when shots have been fired simultaneously, the temptation to fire a shot which has been left little work to do is removed; less explosive is required ; and the canch forming the brushing is brought down cleaner and with less shattering of the sides.

"In my opinion, there is substance in these claims, but the possibility that, when firing several shots simultaneously, one or more of them may miss-fire, must not be overlooked. This possibility, and the chance that the number of accidents which might result therefrom might be greater than any decrease in the number of accidents from explosions, are advanced as objections to firing more than one shot at a time. Given proper attention to details, the risk of missed-fire shots should be very small.

"Clause 2 (a) of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order requires, inter alia, that every charge shall be placed in a properly drilled and placed shot-hole. In cases where the shot-holes are bored all along a face ready for charging, and the charge in each shot-hole is limited to one cartridge of explosive, then, if any shot relieves an adjacent shot-hole of part of its work, as the charge cannot be reduced in that adjacent shot-hole to meet the reduced burden, such shot-hole becomes 'improperly placed' and should not be charged. This should be made plain in the Explosives in Coal Mines Order.

"It follows that if the cause of this explosion was the firing of a shot, which had been relieved of part of its work by a previously fired shot, the first-mentioned shot was fired in breach of Clause 2 (a) of the Order.

"The firing of shots in the coal at Cardowan Colliery has been discontinued."


* Report on Explosion at Cardowan Colliery, Lanarkshire. Cmd. 4309, 1s. net. H.M. Stationery Office.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Beaton, —    Shot Firer  
Horn, —    Fireman  
Peacock, James    Under Manager  
Sleight, George Ernest    Surveyor  
Walker, Henry, Sir    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Williamson, John Macdonald    Colliery Agent  
Wilson, —    Fireman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Cardowan Colliery  Cardowan Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
26 Nov 1932  The Cardowan Explosion (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Dec 1932  Cardowan Colliery Explosion (The Science and Art of Mining)
07 Jan 1933  Cardowan Inquiry (The Science and Art of Mining)
04 Mar 1933  Cardowan Verdict (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 May 1933  Cardowan Colliery Explosion (The Science and Art of Mining)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Cardowan
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print