|
18th May 1933 Coroner "Perturbed"Pit Victim Of Runaway TubHow a colliery tub became a runaway in No. 5 Brayton Domain Colliery, near Aspatria, and killed Alfred Sloan by crushing him against the coal face at the bottom of a dip (slope) was described at the inquest at Plumbland, near Aspatria, on Tuesday night. Sloan lived at Plumbland and was a trailer. James Pape, Aspatria, a trailer, said he was working up the dilly, with a full tub of coal. It was the first time he had been on that level, a new one, and he had trouble at the beginning of the shift because at the top of the dilly there was an awkward turn, then another dip down the other way. At the turn he had not sufficient room to put the scrutch (a type of brake) on the tub wheel to go down the slope at the other side. He had complained earlier in the shift about the lack of room. With this tub he found he had not room, and he pushed the tub a little forward on to the dip. He was endeavouring to put on the scrutch when the tub slipped away from him and became a runaway. Questioned by Mr. W. B. Brown (H.M. Inspector of Mines), Pape said there were no chocks (sometimes called stop blocks) at this awkward turn. He did not complain about their absence because they were regarded as a nuisance by trailers, because they hindered progress, although they were a safety device. Questioned by Mr. Branthwaite (foreman of the jury), Pape said stop blocks would have saved Sloan's life. Answering Mr. Eadie (for the Colliery Company), the witness said there was protection for Sloan at the bottom of the dip. It was a refuge cut into the side of the working. Thomas Hewetson, deputy, said it was his intention to put a chock at the turn that day. The Coroner said he did not think the jury would be wise in finding negligence amounting to criminal negligence, but he felt a little perturbed with the attitude to stop blocks by Pape. Hewetson also had an equal duty. He did not see how far he could be excused for not having done what in the light of events seemed obvious should have been done. He did not think, as Pape said, that it was really common for trailers in that pit to consider safety blocks a nuisance and that it was not their duty to complain of their absence. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||