|
17th September 1932, Page: 74, Column: 1 Llwynypia Colliery ExplosionSir Henry Walker's ReportOn Monday, 25th January, 1932, in the Pentre seam of the Llwynypia Colliery, in Glamorganshire, an explosion occurred whereby eleven persons lost their lives, and following an inquiry into the causes and circumstances of the explosion, the Mines Department has issued the report prepared by Sir Henry Walker, C.B.E., H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines, from which the following notes are extracted :— Origin and Cause of Explosion. Opinions differed as to the precise point of origin of the explosion, but it was generally agreed that that point was either in George Rees' conveyor face or George Rees' road. When the first party of explorers went into George Rees' road after the explosion, and after the body there had been seen by the rescue men, there was found in the pocket of a waistcoat close by that body a small tin box which contained an unsmoked cigarette and a tram ticket for a "return " journey. The finding of this unsmoked cigarette is ominous and, in my opinion, considered in conjunction with the laxity with which searching was carried out and of which something will be said presently, points to the actual cause of ignition. "As recorded, Mr. Bassett (Junior Inspector) was of opinion that there had been an explosive mixture in the rippings of George Rees' road and that at the time of the explosion there was more firedamp at that point that. in the conveyor face. With that opinion I agree." Examining the circumstances prevailing at the time of the explosion, Sir Henry says " No imagination is needed to picture an accumulation of firedamp at the rippings of George Rees' road in the faulted area and tailing out towards the brattice outbye. It is my opinion that such an accumulation existed on the evening of Monday, 25th January, in that place; that it was ignited by the striking of a match for the purposes of smoking, and that the explosion thus caused was propagated by coal dust. "The violence of the explosion was such that of the door and its brick sidewalls which had been across Old Camm's just on the inbye side of the entrance to Cooper's, nothing was left, or in the words of Mr. Mort 'there was practically no evidence except a little bit of stick on the frame on the left side walking out. There was nothing else. The brickwork and everything else had been blown away. Then we went to look for the other door (that is the one some 50 to 60 yards further outbye) and we found that was blown all to smithereens. There was nothing to be seen there.' The block sheets across Joe Davies' and Bulgin's headings the latter sheet some 650 yards from the site of the ignition — were also blown down. "It must be remembered that coal had been dumped off the conveyor on to the floor at the inbye end of George Rees' road for several weeks and thence filled into trams — operations very conducive to the making of dust — and that there was a brattice across George Bees' road fifty feet outbye. The area between the dump and the brattice could not help but be a receptacle for coal dust. Rescue Operations. "In reference to the rescue operations, in the cold light of events it must be said that they were conducted with greater valour than discretion, for even when men from the Porth Rescue Station equipped with breathing apparatus were engaged in J. Alsop's face, officials not so equipped, including the General Manager (Mr. H. H. Evans), the Agent (Mr. R. Lloyd) and the Manager (Mr. J. Whitticombe), were engaged in Prior's and Brown's. They had with them a canary but appear to have had more regard for its life than for their own, with the result that one of their party, John Evans, Overman, was overcome by afterdamp and died. Another death, that of John Jones, a fireman from another seam, should not have occurred. He appears to have gone down the pit by himself and straight inbye on the Main Road, where afterwards he was found, with a dead canary in his hand. The Rescue Brigade itself is not free from criticism for a base was established elsewhere than in intake air. It may be said in answer that officials and men, unequipped with rescue apparatus, had already been exploring in this return air apparently without ill-effects, but such an answer does not meet the point. Men trained for the purpose of rescue work are expected to avoid such unnecessary risk. "Until Mr. T. L. Mort arrived on the scene at 9-30 o'clock, the exploration work was done on unorthodox lines. Mr. Mort, starting at the intake, followed the intake air and by replacing with boards and brattice the two doors on Camm's which, with their side walls, had been blown outbye, restored the ventilation to its normal course. Had this been done at the outset and no one allowed to go beyond the doors across the main level other than men equipped with rescue apparatus, the loss of life would probably not have been so great. Two Fine Deeds. "Mr. Bowen, who was the first official to hear of the occurrence of the explosion, and who notified the General Manager by telephone, and sent messengers to the Agent and the Manager and arranged for the Porth Rescue Brigade to be summoned, went down the pit with one Henry Hughes, who was working on the surface but had at one time been a fireman underground. They met the afternoon shift Overman, John Evans, near the entrance to Camm's and Mr. Bowen asked him if he could tell him where the men were working, but he could not, for, as he said, he had just come up from the bottom, meaning the seam below. Bowen and Hughes went forward past Camm's and found two men who were under trains with their faces in water and sludge on the floor. These men, who were George Patch and William Price, they released from beneath the trains and were giving them attention when Cordey came out of Brown's. "The succeeding events, told in the words of Mr. Bowen, who at my request gave evidence at the Inquiry, are as follows :— 'So here comes Cordey back from Brown's. He asked me what had happened. I said, Nothing much. You sit down here, my lad.' I said 'What is the matter ?' 'Nothing much,' he said. What have you got there ?' he said to me. 'It is all right,' I said 'you keep cool.' When I saw him cooling down a bit I said 'Where were you working?' I did not know the man. He said, 'Up in Brown's.' I said, 'Did you have a butty working with you ?' He said, 'Yes.' Where is he now ?' I said. 'Well, I dragged him back,' he said, 'for about 25 or 30 yards, and then I had to drop him.' I saw he was coming to himself, and I said, 'Will you hold this young man, and I will go and look for your butty.' 'Yes, I will, Mr. Bowen,' he said. I said, 'Come on, Hughes, we will go and look for his butty.' So up we goes to Brown's. We went up to the return, and I said 'Hughes, we have to be very careful here because this road is loading back to the return.' I tested for gas, but it was all right there. So we advanced for a few yards forward, and my lamp went out. So I said to Hughes, 'We have to be careful here. Let us go back a bit. We will step ten yards back, and I will put the lamps on one side.' So we stepped back ten yards, and put the lamps on the side, and we advanced on again. We could hear now this man West groaning, and so I said to Hughes, 'I can see a light up there.' 'Well now,' I said, 'We have to go for this man. You keep two yards behind me, and we can have him.' We went on, but Hughes did not keep the two yards behind I believe, so that the two of us arrived together. So we pulled him back. He had his lamp in his hand the same as Cordey said yesterday. So we drew him back to where our light was, to safety. Then we started, and we turned him round. I slackened his belt and opened his shirt and gave him plenty of ventilation, and we started first aid on him.' "Such is the story of two fine deeds. But for Cordey's carrying him out from the face the 25 or 30 yards as described, West would undoubtedly have lost his life, and might still have done so but for the timely action of Bowen and Hughes. It may appear paradoxical to look upon the piece of work by Bowen and Hughes with favour and yet to frown upon that of the officials when the Overman, John Evans, lost his life. There is, however, a difference. In the former case Bowen and Hughes took their lives in their hands; in the latter, the party had with them a canary and had they made use of it, as they should, the Overman's life would not have been lost." Search for Prohibited Articles. Regarding searching for matches and other prohibited articles, Sir Henry states " I fear the truth is that little searching, if any, was done of the men who worked on the afternoon and night shifts. and this fear is strengthened by the fact that after the explosion a cigarette was found contained in a tin box in a waistcoat pocket. This tin box measured approximately 3 inches by 2 inches by 1 inch, and was therefore not an article which could be easily missed by any person making a proper search. Its presence, having regard to its contents, seems to show clearly that the man to whom it belonged knew perfectly well that no searching was being done. "It appeared to me that some of the witnesses who were asked for their opinion as to the cause of the explosion, withheld that opinion because they did not wish to blame any person who had lost his life. Whilst such an attitude can be respected, it seems to me to be one which is neither helpful in such an Inquiry as this nor conducive to the prevention of similar accidents from similar causes in the future."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||