28th May 1932, Page: 363, Column: 1
The Newcomen Engine
Paper Before North-Country Engineers.
At the meeting of the North of England Institute of Mining
and Mechanical Engineers on the 23rd April, a paper involving
considerable research work was read by Mr. R. N. Appleby Miller,
F.L.A., on "The Newcomen Atmospheric Engine: That Surprising
Machine for Raising Water by Steam." A Devonshire man,
Thomas Newcomen was born at Dartmouth in 1663 and died in
the year 1729. The author said that we do not know that
Newcomen had seen one of Savery's engines at work; but we
do know that he conceived the possibility of obtaining power in
a manner similar to that embodied in Papin's plan of an air pump
which exhausted air, through a length of pipe, from beneath a
piston working in an open topped cylinder. This piston was to
operate a machine for raising water and minerals out of mines.
The resultant effects of the condensation of steam, in specially
designed vessels, as well as that gas's elastic properties, were well
known in 1695. Also it is quite certain that the success of Savery's
engine and of Papin's ideas had not been lost upon Newcomen.
When Newcomen decided to experiment with the atmospheric
principle of engine design he took as a partner, one John Calley,
or Cawley. After many experiments based upon Papin's air
exhausting engine, of 1695, he succeeded in bringing his experiments
to a successful issue. He injected steam into the bottom
of a cylinder in which there was a moving piston, or as Papin
called it a plug, and succeeded in condensing the steam and so
forcing the piston down by "the air pressure." As a result of
this success a working arrangement was entered into between
Savery, Newcomen and Calley in the year 1705. Savery claimed
the invention as being his, but Newcomen's principles would not
allow him to fight, so "he was contented to share the honour and
profits with Savery." Mr. Miller quoted an authority who was
"Well informed that Mr. Newcomen was as early in his invention
as Mr. Savery was in his, only the latter, being nearer the Court
[he was a Captain of (Military) Engineers], had obtained his patent
before the other knew it; on which account Mr. Newcomen was
glad to come in as a partner to it."
Mr. Miller then gave the following brief description of the Savery
engine: It consisted of a boiler and a receiver (in some cases two
receivers) attached to a suction pipe. Steam from the boiler was
admitted to the receiver till full, when the boiler communication
was shut off. A stream of water was then played on to the
receiver, creating a partial vacuum and allowing the atmospheric
pressure in the mine to force the water up the suction pipe. This
stream of water being shut off, the steam cock was opened and
the water in the receiver forced up the delivery pipe. The efficiency
of this engine has been calculated at one-tenth that of a modern
steam pump. Much of its inefficiency was due to the steam coming
into direct contact with the cold water direct from the mine.
Papin later obviated this by introducing a piston into the receiver
— he made his receiver a cylinder in which was a floating piston..
Newcomen's engine is thus described by Stuart: In the Atmospheric
engine, or as it was then commonly called the Fire engine,
"the steam exerts no direct action upon the water, or upon any
part of the apparatus — it is merely employed as a means of forming
a speedy vacuum, under a piston attached to one end of a lever;
the rod of a pump-piston, or plunger, being affixed to the other
extremity. In this construction the power of the engine has no
reference whatever to the strength or temperature of the steam,
but depends upon the superficial dimensions of the piston beneath
which the vapour is introduced from the boiler."
The difference between the Savery engine and the Newcomen
is thus plainly demonstrated, said Mr. Miller. That of Savery
used high pressure steam. The height to which it was able to
force water depended upon the steam pressure its boiler was able
to stand, whereas that of Newcomen merely used low-pressure
steam [at atmospheric pressure] as a means to gain one end only,
viz., a vacuum. The only point of similarity between the two
engines was that the boilers were a separate and distinct part of
the machines: merely joined together by a steam pipe in which
was a steam cock. Of Newcomen's early experiments we know
little or nothing, Mr. Miller added. That he did make many and
that he and Calley had varying kinds of luck is, of course, obvious
to those who think; and when one considers the time which
elapsed between 1705 and the first recorded offer to pump a mine
dry (in 1711) one cannot help realising that he and Calley were men
of courage and perseverance. The full size machine did not take
shape until they erected it near Dudley Castle in 1712.
Following the result of an accidental leak Newcomen and his
partner Calley built a new engine model. It had no water-jacket,
but it had an injection pipe connected with the water-tank above
the trunnions of the beam. This injection pipe, in which there
Was a cock, entered the bottom of the cylinder. Its nozzle consisted
of a rose sprinkler, or spray-jets which, when the cold water was
turned on, sent streams of water all over the inside of the cylinder.
When the cylinder was full of steam, and its piston at the top of
its stroke by reason of the weight at the other end of its beam,
the steam cock was closed and the cold water injection cock opened.
The cold spray at once condensed the steam, consequently a
vacuum was as speedily created and, with a jerk, down went the
piston to the bottom of the cylinder, whilst at the same moment
up went the other end of the beam with its heavy weight. Their
engine now a working success, Newcomen and his partners decided
to offer their services as fire-engine pump builders to certain of
the coal farmers.
Mr. Miller proceeded to examine the history of Newcomen's
work and efforts, and whilst the advent of the Newcomen engine
into the Northern coalfields is wrapped in obscurity references were
made to the drawing of the "Engine" on the 1715 plan of the
Tanfield Lea Colliery, to the engine as built by Beighton in 1718
at Washington Fell, and others. In the year 1733 the patent
rights of the Newcomen engine — really Savery's patent-expired.
Then, said Mr. Miller, there was a general rush to install fire engines.
It was due to John Smeaton's ability as a mechanical engineer,
that the Newcomen engine was able to exist long after the advent
of the Watt and the Trevithick engines into the realms of coal
mining. Smeaton's great work was the Chasewater engine at
Chasewater in Cornwall. Its cylinder was 72 inches in diameter
by 10 feet 6 inches in height with a 9-foot 6 inches stroke.
Following references to attempts to convert the reciprocating
motion of the Atmospheric Engine of Newcomen into a rotary one,
Mr. Miller remarked that Smeaton decided that it was useless
attempting to produce rotary motion by any other means than
that of using the fire-engine to pump water from the mine and
store it in a reservoir and from there release it, at will, over a
water wheel. Concluding his paper, he said : "Smeaton did
away with the loggerhead or working beam, just as Jonathan Hulls
had done forty-one years earlier, and substituted a wheel
over which he carried the chain from the piston rod to the pump
spears. This gave a more direct pull as well as making the whole
machine more compact. With this as one of its last attempts at
holding its own as a coal drawing machine the Newcomen atmospheric
engine finally gave place to that designed by James Watt,
and later to the Trevithick high pressure steam engine. As a
colliery pumping engine, however, it long remained the chief
power unit for that purpose, and in this capacity it is interesting
to note that there is still a Newcomen engine working a set of
pumps at one of Lord Fitzwilliam's collieries near Sheffield."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Beighton, — | | | |
| Calley, John | | | |
| Cawley, John | | | |
| Fitzwilliam, —, Lord | | | |
| Hulls, Jonathan | | | |
| Miller, R. N. Appleby | | | |
| Newcomen, Thomas | | | |
| Papin, — | | | |
| Savery, — | | | |
| Smeaton, John | | | |
| Stuart, — | | | |
| Trevithick, — | | | |
| Watt, James | | | |