Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

20th May 1932, Page: 996, Column: 1

Notes from the Coal Fields

Scotland

[Local Correspondence.]

The annual ambulance competition in connection with the St. Andrews Ambulance Association for the president's cup took place in the association's headquarters in Glasgow on Saturday, the Motherwell section of the London Midland and Scottish Railway securing first place with 279 points out of a possible 300. Second place was secured by Priory Colliery with 268 points.

A prosecution of interest to miners and colliery officials was heard in Hamilton Sheriff Court on May 16, when Moses Sage, coal contractor, 53 New-street, Stonehouse, pleaded guilty to contravening the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1908, by being below ground at No. 4 Broomfield Pit, Canderigg Colliery, Netherburn, for more than 7&189; hours during 24 consecutive hours. The fiscal said a workman was not permitted to be below ground for longer than 7&189; hours in any one day. Apparently one of the accused's men did not turn up, and Sage, after having completed his own shift, went below ground again and worked a second shift. Accused did not appear, it being intimated that he was working. A letter sent by him stated that his work was behind, and in his anxiety to have it completed he had gone down the pit again. He did not know that this was against the law. His lordship imposed a modified fine of 2s. 6d.

In Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court, Sheriff Dudley Stuart, sitting with a jury, held an inquiry under the Fatal Accidents Inquiry Acts into the circumstances connected with the death of Robert Adams, miner, who died in Kirkcaldy Hospital on March 17 as the result of a serious accident at the Julian pit of the Balgonie Colliery Co., Ltd., Thornton, on the previous day. From the evidence it transpired that the deceased was leaving his work with a bicycle. The proper entrance and exit to the colliery was by a road different from that which the deceased took. He went across a road which took him over the through line at a point near the colliery workshops, which were about 6 ft. to the north of the through line. At the time the colliery locomotive was pushing a train of nine loaded wagons towards the point where the deceased intended to cross, and for some unexplained reason the deceased was caught by the front wagon, which ran over him. Mr. David Speirs, the manager of Julian pit, stated that the point at which the deceased was crossing the rails was actually a point provided for lorries approaching the workshops, and at that point concrete blocks had been laid between the rails for the convenience of such vehicles. Michael Collins, the driver of the engine, said that when approaching the workshops from the east he sounded his whistle for fully a minute and kept a lookout until the wagons were in full view of the crossing. His attention was then taken up by a valve of the engine and when he looked out again he saw deceased lying at the side of the rails. He had seen people crossing the rails at this point before. In reply to Mr. Roberts, H.M. inspector of mines, as to whether it would not have been possible for the engine to have been pulling the wagons instead of pushing them, the witness explained that this could not be done. — John Whyte, storekeeper, stated that he looked out of the door of his office while the engine was sounding its whistle and he saw the deceased with his hand against the side of a wagon while his cycle was being pushed away from him. The jury returned a verdict in accordance with the evidence, expressing the opinion that the cause of the accident was the deceased's failure to observe the approach of the train of wagons, and adding a rider expressing the opinion that the deceased took the risk on himself and that the Balgonie Co. were wholly free from blame.

The ambulance competition for the Coltness silver shield, confined to teams drawn from the collieries and works of Coltness Iron Co., Ltd., was held in Newmains Public School on Saturday, May 14. The winners were Kingshill, with 150½ points. Kingshill were also successful last year. The shield and gold badges were handed over to the winners by Mrs. W. H. Telfer. In the public hall, Wallyford, on Saturday afternoon the fifth annual competition in proficiency in the ambulance work, open to the collieries owned in Mid and East Lothian by the Edinburgh Colliery Co., was carried through, Wallyford Colliery team won the Jack silver cup in the senior class.

A fine of £3 or 20 days imprisonment was imposed on John Heggie, shotfirer, 11 Hayford-square, Cambusbarron, on pleading guilty in Stirling Sheriff Court last week to a charge of having, at the coal face in No. 2 pit, Manor Powis Colliery, failed to examine the place within a radius of 20 yd. before firing a shot. Accused said he had made an examination, but apparently too long had elapsed between the examination and the shot being fired. Everything else, he said, was in order. The fiscal said the mines inspector and manager were in No. 2 pithead and the offence took place in No. 3 head, a distance of 50 ft. separating them. Accused told the inspector that an examination radius was 20 ft. whereas it should have been 20 yd.

A copy of the plans for the proposed pithead baths at Kinneil Colliery has been furnished to Bo'ness Town Council. The plans show 30 bath cubicles, flanked on either side by lockers for pit and shifting clothes. A women's section consists of four cubicles with lockers. Included in the suite of buildings is a first-aid room. A canteen is situated at the south end. In the east end of the colliery district of Bo'ness there is a proposal to extend the Bridgeness and Carriden Welfare Society's building so as to provide extra billiards room accommodation.

The powers of a medical referee in a reference to him under the Workmen's Compensation Acts regarding the condition of an injured workman and his fitness for employment was the subject of a decision in Glasgow Sheriff Court, by Sheriff W. J. Robertson. John Watson, Ltd., coal masters, paid weekly compensation to John Goldie, a pony-driver, who was injured in their Robroyston Colliery on March 5, 1931. In July a doctor, who examined the workman on their behalf, certified him fit for light work. The latter alleged that he was unable for any work, and the employers made an application to the court narrating these contentions and asking the court to refer the matter to the medical referee in terms of s. 19 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1925. The reference was made and the referee reported that the claimant was suffering from slight stiffness of the muscles of the back; that there was very little wrong; and that he had practically recovered from the effects of the accident and was fit for light work. The referee added a note to the effect that the claimant was fit for his ordinary work, but that the reference to him was as between "light work" and "unable for any work." The employers then asked the court to end the right to the weekly payment. This was opposed by the workman mainly on the ground that the note of the referee was ultra vires, and on this the Sheriff heard a debate. In a considered judgment his lordship has sustained the employers' application and ended the right to the weekly payment as at July 22 with modified expenses. His lordship said that the question of whether or not the medical referee's report was ultra vires had arisen upon the form in which the referee had couched his answer to the first question in the remit. He had plainly found that the claimant was at July 22 fit for his ordinary work and recovered from the effects of his accident. A fortiori he was fit for light work as the greater included the less. The referee had stated "his condition is such that he is fit for light work," and added in a 'note' that he was fit for ordinary work and explained that "the reference to me is as between 'light work' and 'unable for any work.'" That did not appear to his lordship to be so. What was remitted to the medical referee was to be found in the Form of Reference, viz. : "to examine the said John Goldie and give his certificate as to the condition of the said John Goldie and his fitness for employment, specifying. if necessary, the kind of employment for which he is fit." That was the remit, and although the minute of application for a reference and the certificates of the doctors were sent him. he was not bound by them (Lacey v. Wallis and Sons, Ltd., 1926. B.W.C.C. 43). Suppose the conflict between the parties with their respective doctors to have been between total incapacity and absolute fitness, could it have been suggested for a moment that the medical referee could not report that the workman was only partially incapacitated and fit for light work? Certainly not. In the words of Sargant, L. J. : "The matter referred to the medical referee is the workman's condition and fitness for employment in quite general terms."

A claim for miners' nystagmus under the Workmen's Compensation Act was recently disallowed in Stirling Sheriff Court by Sheriff Dean Leslie on the ground that before entering his employment the claimant had wilfully and falsely represented in writing to the employers that he had not previously suffered from the disease. The workman, John Sherry, entered the employment of the Manor Powis Coal Co., Ltd., in their Manor Powis Colliery, Causewayhead. Stirlingshire, on June 13, 1930, and on February 20 following was officially certified to be disabled by the disease from earning full wages. The employers having tabled the defence above indicated in answer to the workman's claim for weekly compensation the case went to proof. The sheriff has found that on November 11, 1927, while in the employment of Archibald Russell, Ltd., the claimant was certified as having contracted the disease of miners' nystagmus. On June 12, 1930, he applied for work at the Manor Powis Co.'s colliery, and was instructed by an oversman in their employment to start work next day. He was at the same time notified that he would require to sign a declaration that he had not previously suffered from miners' nystagmus. On June 13, 1930, the claimant obtained a lamp, and descended the pit. Before his working place was allotted to him he wilfully and falsely represented himself in writing as not having previously suffered from the industrial disease of miners' nystagmus. On August 7, 1930, he was injured by accident, and was paid compensation on that account until August 26, when he resumed work with the Manor Powis Co. On August 30 he again became incapacitated, and on September 23 accepted a sum of £1 13s. in settlement of his claim for compensation. He was out of work for a period, and drew unemployment benefit until December 20, when he resumed work with the Manor Powis Co. On January 20, 1931, his left hand was injured by accident, and on February 17 he discharged his claim for compensation for that accident for a sum of £2 9s. On February 20, 1931, the claimant was certified as suffering from miners' nystagmus. His lordship on these facts finds that in law the Manor Powis Co. are not liable to pay compensation to the claimant under the Workmen's Compensation Act and finds the claimant liable in the expenses of process.

The claim of a one-eyed miner, who maintained that he was unable to get work as the result of the loss of an eye by accident, was rejected by Sheriff King Murray in Airdrie Sheriff Court recently. The claimant, Leggate, had his right eye removed as the result of an accident while working as a miner in the employment of Archibald Russell, Ltd., on December 18, 1927. The average of his weekly earnings was £2 16s. 10d. and the employers paid compensation at 28s. 5d. per week until August 1928, and thereafter as for partial incapacity at 15s. per week until May 21, 1930. On the latter date a medical referee certified that the claimant was fit for his ordinary work, whereupon the employers stopped payment of compensation. The claimant then registered at the labour exchange and received unemployment benefit. Having made numerous applications for work of various kinds without success, he applied to the court for compensation, maintaining that his failure to get work was the consequence wholly or mainly of the accident. The employers disputed this and the matter went to proof. On the evidence the Sheriff finds in fact that the absence of the right eye is obvious to anyone looking at the claimant; that although he made numerous applications for work of various kinds, he did not apply for work as a miner, that is, as a hewer of coal, which was his former occupation; that his reason for not applying for work as a hewer of coal was that he believed himself unfit for it owing to the loss of the eye; and that the claimant is a strongly-built man and is well known in the district where he lives as a steady and efficient workman. On these facts the sheriff finds in law that having regard to all the circumstances it is probable that the claimant would, but for the continuing effects of the injury have been able to obtain work in the same grade in the same class of employment as before the accident, but that he has not taken all reasonable steps to obtain employment, and consequently that he is not entitled at present to receive compensation. His lordship therefore refuses the workman's application and finds him liable in expenses. His lordship said that the referee's finding was, of course, final as to the claimant's capacity for work. The present claim for compensation accordingly depended on proof that the conditions set forth in s. 1 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1931, had been satisfied. One of these conditions was that the workman had taken all reasonable steps to obtain employment. The claimant said quite frankly that he had not tried to get work as a miner at the face because he thought he was unfit for it owing to the loss of his eye. This meant that he had not tried to obtain work for which he had been certified fit, and for which he therefore must be held to be fit. In his lordship's opinion, therefore, he had not taken "all reasonable steps" to obtain employment, and his claim for compensation failed.

The provisions of s. 14 (2) of the Workmen's Compensation Act. 1925, were applied recently by Sheriff Brown, K.C., in Hamilton Court in connection with a belated notice of an accident under the Act. Robert Browne, formerly a miner in Parkneuk Colliery, Motherwell, raised arbitration proceedings against the Glasgow Iron and Steel Co., Ltd., owners of the colliery, claiming weekly compensation in respect of personal injury sustained at his work on November 10, 1930. He alleged that while he was putting up props at his working place one of the props sprang out and struck him a blow on the right side of the face. He alleged that the result of the blow was to cause a superficial grazing of the skin and that this set up a severe attack of erysipelas. The employers contended that timeous notice of the accident had not been given. The sheriff has found on the evidence that, shortly after the claimant sustained the injury and during the same shift, he reported the accident to the night shift fireman, the official of the colliery under whose supervision the claimant was employed. He therefore holds that due notice was given, and awards compensation. His lordship referred to s.s. 2 of s. 14 which, he stated, provided that notice might be given either in writing or orally to the employers or to any foreman or other official under whose supervision the workman was employed. The fireman admitted that he not mentioned the occurrence to anyone, probably because he thought the matter was not serious. According to the evidence, it was his duty to pass on the report either to the manager or the undermanager. His failure to do so might have been unfortunate, and no doubt it was the reason why the employers were so suspicious.

A case under s. 9 (4) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1925, as amended by the Act of 1931, was recently disposed of in Stirling Sheriff Court by Sheriff Dean Leslie. The section provides that if the failure of an injured workman to obtain employment is a consequence wholly or mainly of his injury, the judge shall order the incapacity to be treated as total incapacity and award compensation accordingly. The Banknock Coal Co., Ltd., paid weekly compensation to one of their pony-drivers, Archibald C. Wallace, who was injured in their Broomrigg Colliery, Dennyloanhead, Stirlingshire, on December 15, 1913. The workman was subsequently provided by the employers with a job as a motor attendant and bellman in the pit bottom at a wage which did not entitle him to compensation. In December 1928 the claimant lost this job owing to the depressed condition of the coal trade. He subsequently claimed compensation at 16s. 9d. in respect of total incapacity on the averment that since he lost his job he had been unable to obtain work either with his old employers or elsewhere as a direct result of his condition caused by the accident. He alleged that he had been thrown upon the labour market and had been unable to find other employment suitable to him, not only as a result of the accident, but also through his difficulty in travelling to work, which formed an additional handicap to his obtaining employment. The employers explained that they had been unable to supply the claimant with a job, and alleged that his inability to obtain work was the result of general economic causes and was not due to the accident. The Sheriff, having taken proof, has found on the evidence that the claimant, along with others, was suspended from work at Broomrigg because of lack of work at the colliery, and that his earning capacity is the same as it was when he was suspended; that he has searched for work and has been unable to find it, but that this is mainly because of the condition of the labour market generally. His lordship therefore refuses the claim for full compensation, and has appointed parties to be heard on the amount of compensation to be awarded for partial incapacity.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Adams, Robert    Miner  Deceased , Individual Page
Brown, —    Sheriff  
Browne, Robert    Miner  
Collins, Michael    Loco Driver  
Goldie, John    Pony Driver  
Heggie, John    Shot Firer  
Leggate, —    Miner  
Leslie, Dean    Sheriff  
Leslie, Dean    Sheriff  
Murray, King    Sheriff  
Roberts, Harold Charles West    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Robertson, W. J.    Sheriff  
Sage, Moses    Coal Contactor  
Sherry, John    Miner  
Speirs, David    Colliery Manager  
Stuart, Dudley    Sheriff  
Telfer, W. H., Mrs.      
Wallace, Archibald C.    Pony Driver  
Whyte, John    Storekeeper  


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print