20th May 1932, Page: 995, Column: 1
Notes from the Coal Fields
Yorkshire
[Local Correspondence.]
Thirty-two ambulance teams, including those of the Park Hill Colliery,
Wakefield, Manvers Main Colliery, and Denaby Main Colliery, all this year's
finalists for the Wood Shield, competed at Pontefract on Saturday for the
Godfrey Brooks Shield. Manvers Main were the holders, but on Saturday Hickleton
Main won with 275 points, Park Hill, Wakefield, being second with 257 points,
and Manvers Main No. 2 third with 250 points. These three teams were winners in
their respective centres. The winners in the individual competitions were: 1.
J. Malpas, Hickleton Main; 2, A. Scott, Hickleton Main; 3, W. Angell, Park
Hill; 4, W. Backburn, Park Hill.
His Honour Judge Greene, at Rotherham, on May 3, said that if a man broke down
during the course of his work he was entitled to compensation. His Honour made
an award of 30s. a week as from August 22, 1931, in favour of James Sutton, 45,
ripper, of 15 Wolverley-road, Woodhouse, Sheffield, who twice wrenched or
twisted his back — first on February 25, 1928, and the second time on
June 22, 1931 — when filling corves at Orgreave Colliery. On the first
occasion he was paid 30s. a week for three weeks. On the second occasion he was
paid a similar amount, from February 25 to June 22, 1931, when he returned to
work, remaining until August 22. For the respondents, the United Steel
Companies, Ltd., it was submitted that incapacity was due to natural causes,
and not to accident. His Honour said he was satisfied that Sutton was not able
to do light work.
On the ground that the respondent was now fit for his old work, Messrs. Barber,
Walker and Co., Ltd., proprietors of Bentley Colliery, applied before his
Honour Judge Hildyard, at the Doncaster County Court, last week, for the
termination or reduction of the compensation of 17s. 6d. a week they had been
paying to George Crouch (38), in respect of injuries received in an accident at
the colliery five years ago. His Honour terminated the compensation and granted
a declaration of liability, remarking that he did not think it was for him to
say that throughout Crouch was a fraud. He thought that Crouch had got a wrong
idea into his head. In his opinion, Crouch was to blame for not getting himself
into a better condition to work than he now was. — Mr. E. Dale, who
appeared for the colliery company, said that after the accident respondent
entered the Doncaster Infirmary. For a period he was seen by Dr. Hargreaves,
and always complained that he had bleeding from the lung, nearly every other
day. Respondent was then seen by Dr. W. H. Maxwell-Telling, who thought it was
an extraordinary thing. Crouch entered the Leeds Infirmary, and an X-ray
examination showed that there was no damage to the lung. Nothing indicated that
he had been bleeding from the lung, although on one or two occasions there was
a slight stain on his handkerchief. — Respondent denied that he took
blood from his ear which bled, and spat it into his handkerchief. On three
occasions he had refused offers of a sum of money for the settlement of his
claim.
At the annual meeting of the executive of the Maltby Main Colliery Disaster
Relief Fund it was stated that the financial side of the scheme was healthy,
and that the fund would serve its full purpose to the end of the term of years
counted by the trustees. Arrangements were made for the working of the fund
during the coming year, it being suggested that it might he possible to arrange
for some educational benefit for those who had suffered the loss of the head of
their home.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Angell, W. | | | |
| Backburn, W. | | | |
| Crouch, George | 38 | Miner | |
| Dale, E. | | | |
| Greene, — | | Judge | |
| Hargreaves, —, Dr. | | Doctor | |
| Hildyard, — | | Judge | |
| Malpas, J. | | | |
| Maxwell-Telling, W. H., Dr. | | Doctor | |
| Scott, A. | | | |
| Sutton, James | 45 | Ripper | |