|
28th April 1932 Fatality In Whitehaven PitsMr. W. Brown's CriticismsInquests were held at Whitehaven yesterday on two men who died on Tuesday night and Wednesday morning following accidents in Whitehaven coal mines. The inquests were conducted by the Deputy Coroner for West Cumberland (Mr. R. W. Marley) at the Whitehaven Police Station. There were present Mr. W. B. Brown, H.M Inspector of Mines; Mr. W. Morgan representing the Whitehaven Colliery Company Ltd; Mr. J. Twaddle, manager of William Pit; Mr. J. Martin, Whitehaven, miners agent; Mr. J. A. Fearon and Mr. H. Skerry, representing the Deputies' Association. Mr. H. Williams was elected foreman of the jury. The second inquest concerned the death of Roland Pritchard (48), married, 9, Plumblands Lane, Whitehaven, a hewer at Wellington Pit, who was killed on Tuesday night by a fall of roof, followed. William Evans, 9, Plumblands Lane, coal-hewer in Haig Pit, uncle of deceased, gave evidence of identification. Witness saw him just before he went to work about noon on Tuesday. After the accident deceased was brought home suffering from severe head injuries. He had worked nearly 38 years in William Pit. James Dryden, White House, Parton, a hewer at William Pit, said he was working with Pritchard when the accident occurred at 7.20pm. Mr. Brown: Did the deputy visit the place? — Yes. Did you receive any instructions regarding timbering? — Yes, the usual. Witness said they were working on a piece of coal with two loose ends. Only one shot had been fired which did not bring down the coal next to the roof. The coal concerned was about four yards long, but when the accident they had "filled out" about 2½ yards. After the shot was fired they "dressed out" the loose coal and filled it on to the conveyor pans. Mr. Brown: From the time you fired the shot until you began to "fill out," did you set any props? — Yes. How many? — One on the high side and another on the low side. How far from the face did you set it? — About a yard. A Singular Feature Does it not strike you as singular that after the accident occurred the two props were cantered out? — Yes. How would you describe the roof? — Very shallow. As a practical miner can you explain how you were deceived by this section of roof? — No. Did you test the roof with your pick? — Yes. And it sounded good? — Yes. Were the props capped? — One was. Do you think it wise not to cap a prop? Witness said it was not, but they often had to go 50 or 60 yards to get a cap. Mr Brown: Are caps not provided? — Yes. In answer to Mr. Marley and Mr. Martin, witness said in future he would always use caps. In answer to Mr. Skerry, witness said Pritchard had only been working for 15 minutes before the accident. Witness saw him test the roof himself. The nearest prop was only 12 inches away. In answer to Mr. Morgan, he said the props were driven in with pick and shaft, and he was satisfied that they could be driven just as tightly by that method as with a hammer. Use Of Hammer Mr. Morgan suggested that falls would not occur if props were driven in with a hammer. Witness did not agree, and said that hammers were not supplied at the coal face. Thomas Postlethwaite, Bransty Road, deputy at William Pit, said he visited deceased's working place soon after 6.30 and fired a shot. He returned afterwards and was satisfied that the roof was safe. Mr. Brown: Was the conveyor running when you made your inspection? — Yes. Difference Of Opinion Don't you think you should make your inspection without the conveyor running? — No, not necessarily. Well, I do. Witness said that after inspecting the roof he did not consider that straps were necessary. When he saw any props without caps he had the matter put right. Mr. Brown: Would it surprise you to know that there are 12 to 14 props on this face without cap pieces? — Yes. Would it be a wise precaution to set props on sole pieces? — Yes. Why did you fire the shot? — To loose the coal. Did you think it absolutely necessary? — Yes. Do you reduce firing to a minimum where the roof is bad? — Yes. How do you account for this fall? — Witness said he thought it must have been a break in the coal independent of the portion which was strapped. A verdict of "Accidental death" was returned.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||